#  File src/library/tools/R/QC.R
#  Part of the R package, https://www.R-project.org
#
#  Copyright (C) 1995-2026 The R Core Team
#
#  This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
#  it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
#  the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or
#  (at your option) any later version.
#
#  This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
#  but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
#  MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
#  GNU General Public License for more details.
#
#  A copy of the GNU General Public License is available at
#  https://www.R-project.org/Licenses/

## R CMD check uses
## .find_charset
## .check_namespace
## .check_package_depends
## .check_demo_index
## .check_vignette_index
## .check_package_subdirs
## .check_citation
## .check_package_ASCII_code
## .check_package_code_syntax
## .check_packages_used
## .check_package_code_shlib
## .check_package_code_startup_functions
## .check_package_code_assign_to_globalenv
## .check_package_code_attach
## .check_package_code_data_into_globalenv
## .check_package_code_class_is_string
## .check_code_usage_in_package
## .check_bogus_return
## .check_dotInternal
## .check_package_parseRd
## .check_Rd_xrefs
## undoc
## codoc
## codocData
## codocClasses
## checkDocFiles
## checkDocStyle
## checkFF
## checkS3methods
## checkReplaceFuns
## .check_package_datasets
## .check_package_compact_datasets
## .check_package_compact_sysdata
## .check_make_vars
## .createExdotR (testing.R)
## .runPackageTestsR (testing.R)
## .get_LaTeX_errors_from_log_file
## .check_package_CRAN_incoming
## checkRdContents

## R CMD build uses .check_package_subdirs

## NB: 'tools' cannot use NAMESPACE imports from utils, as it exists first

## "The language elements" : all are .Primitive *and* print as .Primitive("...")
langElts <- c("(", "{", ":", "~",
              "<-", "<<-", "=",
              "[", "[[", "[[<-", "[<-", "@", "@<-", "$", "$<-",
              "&&", "||",
              "break", "for", "function", "if", "next", "repeat", "return", "while")

## Code "existing conceptually" in base,
## typically function names of default methods for .Primitive s:
conceptual_base_code <- c("c.default")

##' a "default" print method (see NAMESPACE):
.print.via.format <- function(x, ...) {
    writeLines(format(x, ...))
    invisible(x)
}

## utility for whether Rd sources are available.
.haveRds <- function(dir)
{
    ## either source package or pre-2.10.0 installed package
    dir.exists (file.path(dir, "man")) ||
    file.exists(file.path(dir, "help", "paths.rds"))
}

### * undoc/F/out

undoc <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Argument handling.
    ## <NOTE>
    ## Earlier versions used to give an error if there were no Rd
    ## objects.  This is not right: if there is code or data but no
    ## documentation, everything is undocumented ...
    ## </NOTE>
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dirdir <- dirname(dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc))
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
        is_base <- package == "base"

        all_doc_topics <- Rd_aliases(package, lib.loc = dirdir)

        ## Load package into code_env.
        if(!is_base)
            .load_package_quietly(package, dirdir)
        code_env <- .package_env(package)

        code_objs <- ls(envir = code_env, all.names = TRUE)
        pkgname <- package
    }
    else {
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        pkgname <- basename(dir)
        dirdir  <- dirname(dir)
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        is_base <- pkgname == "base"

        all_doc_topics <- Rd_aliases(dir = dir)

        code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(dir.exists(code_dir)) {
            dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
            meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile))
                .read_description(dfile)
            else
                character()
            .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
            sys_data_file <- file.path(code_dir, "sysdata.rda")
            if(file_test("-f", sys_data_file))
                load(sys_data_file, code_env)
        }

        code_objs <- ls(envir = code_env, all.names = TRUE)

        if(file.exists(file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE")) &&
           ## Code in NAMESPACE could e.g. check the version of one of
           ## its Imports.
           !inherits(tryCatch(nsInfo <-
                                  parseNamespaceFile(pkgname,
                                                     dirdir),
                              error = identity),
                     "error")) {
            ## Look only at exported objects (and not declared S3
            ## methods).
            OK <- intersect(code_objs, nsInfo$exports)
            for(p in nsInfo$exportPatterns)
                OK <- c(OK, grep(p, code_objs, value = TRUE))
            code_objs <- unique(OK)
        }
    }

    ## Find the data sets to work on.
    data_dir <- file.path(dir, "data")
    data_objs <- if(dir.exists(data_dir))
        unlist(.try_quietly(list_data_in_pkg(dir = dir)),
               use.names = FALSE)
    else
        character()

    ## There was a time when packages contained code or data (or both).
    ## But not anymore ...
    if(!missing(package) && !length(code_objs) && !length(data_objs)
       && getOption("verbose"))
        message("neither code nor data objects found")

    if(!is_base) {
        ## Code objects in add-on packages with names starting with a
        ## dot are considered 'internal' (not user-level) by
        ## convention.
        if(!config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_UNDOC_USE_ALL_NAMES_",
                                             "FALSE")))
            code_objs <- grep("^[^.].*", code_objs, value = TRUE)
        else {
            code_objs <- code_objs %w/o% c(".Depends")
            code_objs <- code_objs[!(startsWith(code_objs, ".__C__") |
                                     startsWith(code_objs, ".__T__"))]
        }
        ## Note that this also allows us to get rid of S4 meta objects
        ## (with names starting with '.__C__' or '.__M__'; well, as long
        ## as there are none in base).

        ## Implicit generic functions exist to turn method dispatch on
        ## in this package, but their definition and documentation belongs
        ## to the package in their package slot, so eliminate any
        ## foreign generic functions from code_objs
        if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
            is <- methods::is           # speed
            code_objs <-
                Filter(function(f) {
                    fdef <- code_env[[f]] # faster than get()
                    ## Running methods::is() on data sets can trigger
                    ## loading additional packages for which startup
                    ## messages et al need suppressing ...
                    if(suppressMessages(is(fdef, "genericFunction")))
                        fdef@package == pkgname
                    else
                        TRUE
                },
                code_objs)
        }

        ## Allow group generics to be undocumented other than in base.
        ## In particular, those from methods partially duplicate base
        ## and are documented in base's groupGenerics.Rd.
        code_objs <- setdiff(code_objs,
                             c("Arith", "Compare", "Complex", "Logic",
                               "Math", "Math2", "Ops", "Summary", "matrixOps"))
    }

    undoc_things <-
        list("code objects" =
             unique(setdiff(code_objs, all_doc_topics)),
             "data sets" =
             unique(setdiff(data_objs, all_doc_topics)))

    if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
        ## Undocumented S4 classes?
        S4_classes <- methods::getClasses(code_env)
        ## <NOTE>
        ## There is no point in worrying about exportClasses directives
        ## in a NAMESPACE file when working on a package source dir, as
        ## we only source the assignments, and hence do not get any
        ## S4 classes or methods.
        ## </NOTE>
        ## The bad ones:
        S4_classes <-
            S4_classes[vapply(S4_classes, utils:::topicName, " ",
                              type = "class", USE.NAMES = FALSE)
                       %notin% all_doc_topics]
        undoc_things <-
            c(undoc_things, list("S4 classes" = unique(S4_classes)))
    }

    if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
        ## Undocumented S4 methods?
        ## <NOTE>
        ## There is no point in worrying about exportMethods directives
        ## in a NAMESPACE file when working on a package source dir, as
        ## we only source the assignments, and hence do not get any
        ## S4 classes or methods.
        ## </NOTE>
        .make_S4_method_siglist <- function(g) {
            mlist <- .get_S4_methods_list(g, code_env)
            sigs <- .make_siglist(mlist) #  s/#/,/g
            if(length(sigs))
                paste0(g, ",", sigs)
            else
                character()
        }
        S4_methods <- lapply(.get_S4_generics(code_env),
                             .make_S4_method_siglist)
        S4_methods <- as.character(unlist(S4_methods, use.names = FALSE))

        ## The bad ones:
        S4_methods <-
            S4_methods[vapply(S4_methods, utils:::topicName, " ",
                               type="method", USE.NAMES = FALSE)
                       %notin% all_doc_topics]
        undoc_things <-
            c(undoc_things,
              list("S4 methods" =
                   unique(sub("([^,]*),(.*)",
                              "generic '\\1' and siglist '\\2'",
                              S4_methods))))
    }
    if(is_base) {
        ## We use .ArgsEnv and .GenericArgsEnv in checkS3methods() and
        ## codoc(), so we check here that the set of primitives has not
        ## been changed.
        ff <- as.list(baseenv(), all.names = TRUE)
        prims <- names(ff)[vapply(ff, is.primitive, NA)]
        prototypes <- sort(c(names(.ArgsEnv), names(.GenericArgsEnv)))
        extras <- setdiff(prototypes, prims)
        if(length(extras))
            undoc_things <- c(undoc_things, list(prim_extra = extras))
        miss <- setdiff(prims, c(langElts, prototypes))
        if(length(miss))
            undoc_things <- c(undoc_things, list(primitives = miss))
    }

    class(undoc_things) <- "undoc"
    undoc_things
}

format.undoc <-
function(x, ...)
{
    .fmt <- function(i) {
        tag <- names(x)[i]
        msg <- switch(tag,
                      "code objects" =
                      gettext("Undocumented code objects:"),
                      "data sets" =
                      gettext("Undocumented data sets:"),
                      "S4 classes" =
                      gettext("Undocumented S4 classes:"),
                      "S4 methods" =
                      gettext("Undocumented S4 methods:"),
                      prim_extra =
                      gettext("Prototyped non-primitives:"),
                      gettextf("Undocumented %s:", tag))
        c(msg,
          ## We avoid markup for indicating S4 methods, hence need to
          ## special-case output for these ...
          if(tag == "S4 methods") {
              strwrap(x[[i]], indent = 2L, exdent = 4L)
          } else {
              .pretty_format(x[[i]])
          })
    }

    as.character(unlist(lapply(which(lengths(x) > 0L), .fmt)))
}

### * codoc

##
is_data_for_dataset <- function(e) ## trigger for data(foo) or data(foo, package="bar") and similar
    length(e) >= 2L && e[[1L]] == quote(data) && e[[2L]] != quote(...) && length(e) <= 4L

codoc <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL,
         use.values = NULL, verbose = getOption("verbose"))
{
    has_namespace <- FALSE

    ## Argument handling.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        if(!.haveRds(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain Rd objects", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        is_base <- basename(dir) == "base"

        dirdir <- dirname(dir)

        ## Load package into code_env.
        if(!is_base)
            .load_package_quietly(package, dirdir)
        code_env <- .package_env(package)

        objects_in_code <- sort(names(code_env))

        if(is_base) {
            objects_in_code_or_namespace <- objects_in_code
        } else {
            has_namespace <- TRUE
            ns_env <- asNamespace(package)
            S3Table <- ns_env[[".__S3MethodsTable__."]]
            functions_in_S3Table <- ls(S3Table, all.names = TRUE)
            objects_in_ns <-
                setdiff(sort(names(ns_env)),
                        c(".__NAMESPACE__.", ".__S3MethodsTable__."))
            ns_S3_methods_db <- getNamespaceInfo(package, "S3methods")
            ns_S3_methods <- if(is.null(ns_S3_methods_db))
                                 character()
                             else
                                 paste(ns_S3_methods_db[, 1L],
                                       ns_S3_methods_db[, 2L],
                                       sep = ".")
            objects_in_code_or_namespace <-
                unique(c(objects_in_code, objects_in_ns, ns_S3_methods))
            objects_in_ns <- setdiff(objects_in_ns, objects_in_code)
        }

        package_name <- package
    }
    else {
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir), domain = NA)
        ## else
        package_name <- basename(dir) # early, before resolving sym.links etc in next line:
        dirdir <- dirname(dir)        # early, ...
        dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        if(!.haveRds(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain Rd objects", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        is_base <- package_name == "base"

        code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile)) .read_description(dfile) else character()
        .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
        sys_data_file <- file.path(code_dir, "sysdata.rda")
        if(file_test("-f", sys_data_file)) load(sys_data_file, code_env)

        objects_in_code <- sort(names(code_env))
        objects_in_code_or_namespace <- objects_in_code

        ## Does the package have a NAMESPACE file?
        ## Also, do not attempt to find S3 methods.
        if(file.exists(file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE")) &&
           ## Code in NAMESPACE could e.g. check the version of one of
           ## its Imports.
           !inherits(tryCatch(nsInfo <-
                                  parseNamespaceFile(package_name,
                                                     dirdir),
                              error = identity),
                     "error")) {
            has_namespace <- TRUE
            objects_in_ns <- objects_in_code
            functions_in_S3Table <- character()
            ns_env <- code_env

            ## Look only at exported objects.
            OK <- intersect(objects_in_code, nsInfo$exports)
            for(p in nsInfo$exportPatterns)
                OK <- c(OK, grep(p, objects_in_code, value = TRUE))
            objects_in_code <- unique(OK)
        }
    }

    ## Find the data sets to work on.
    data_dir <- file.path(dir, "data")
    if(dir.exists(data_dir)) {
        data_sets_in_code_variables <-
            .try_quietly(list_data_in_pkg(dir = dir))
        data_sets_in_code <- names(data_sets_in_code_variables)
    } else
        data_sets_in_code <- data_sets_in_code_variables <- character()

    ## Find the function objects to work on.
    functions_in_code <-
        Filter(function(f) {
                   ## This is expensive
                   f <- get(f, envir = code_env)
                   typeof(f) == "closure"
               },
               objects_in_code)
    ## Sourcing all R code files in the package is a problem for base,
    ## where this misses the .Primitive functions.  Hence, when checking
    ## base for objects shown in \usage but missing from the code, we
    ## get the primitive functions from the version of R we are using.
    ## Maybe one day we will have R code for the primitives as well ...
    ## As from R 2.5.0 we do for most generics.
    if(is_base) {
        objects_in_base <-
            sort(names(baseenv()))
        objects_in_code <-
            c(objects_in_code,
              conceptual_base_code,
              Filter(.is_primitive_in_base, objects_in_base),
              c(".First.lib", ".Last.lib", ".Random.seed",
                ".onLoad", ".onAttach", ".onDetach", ".onUnload"))
        objects_in_code_or_namespace <- objects_in_code
        known_env <- .make_S3_primitive_generic_env(code_env, fixup=TRUE)
        extras <- ls(known_env, all.names = TRUE)
        functions_in_code <- c(functions_in_code, extras)
        code_env <- known_env
        known_env <- .make_S3_primitive_nongeneric_env(code_env)
        extras <- ls(known_env, all.names = TRUE)
        functions_in_code <- c(functions_in_code, extras)
        code_env <- known_env
    }

    ## Build a list with the formals of the functions in the code
    ## indexed by the names of the functions.
    function_args_in_code <-
        lapply(functions_in_code,
               function(f) formals(get(f, envir = code_env))) # get is expensive
    names(function_args_in_code) <- functions_in_code
    if(has_namespace) {
        functions_in_ns <-
            Filter(function(f) {
                       f <- get(f, envir = ns_env) # get is expensive
                       is.function(f) && (length(formals(f)) > 0L)
                   },
                   objects_in_ns)
        function_args_in_ns <-
            lapply(functions_in_ns,
                   function(f) formals(get(f, envir = ns_env)))
        names(function_args_in_ns) <- functions_in_ns

        function_args_in_S3Table <-
            lapply(functions_in_S3Table, function(f) formals(S3Table[[f]]))
        names(function_args_in_S3Table) <- functions_in_S3Table

        tmp <- c(function_args_in_code, function_args_in_S3Table,
                 function_args_in_ns)
        keep <- !duplicated(names(tmp))
        function_args_in_code <- tmp[keep]
        functions_in_code <- names(function_args_in_code)
    }
    if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
        ## <NOTE>
        ## There is no point in worrying about exportMethods directives
        ## in a NAMESPACE file when working on a package source dir, as
        ## we only source the assignments, and hence do not get any
        ## S4 classes or methods.
        ## </NOTE>
        ## <NOTE>
        ## In principle, we can get codoc checking for S4 methods
        ## documented explicitly using the \S4method{GENERIC}{SIGLIST}
        ## markup by adding the corresponding "pseudo functions" using
        ## the Rd markup as their name.  However note that the formals
        ## recorded in the methods db only pertain to the signature, not
        ## to the ones of the function actually registered ... hence we
        ## use methods::unRematchDefinition() which knows how to extract
        ## the formals in the method definition from the
        ##   function(ARGLIST) {
        ##     .local <- function(FORMALS) BODY
        ##     .local(ARGLIST)
        ##   }
        ## redefinitions obtained by methods::rematchDefinition().
        ## </NOTE>
        check_S4_methods <-
            !isFALSE(as.logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CODOC_S4_METHODS_")))
        if(check_S4_methods) {
            unRematchDef <- methods::unRematchDefinition
            get_formals_from_method_definition <- function(m)
                formals(unRematchDef(m))
            lapply(.get_S4_generics(code_env),
                   function(f) {
                       mlist <- .get_S4_methods_list(f, code_env)
                       sigs <- .make_siglist(mlist)
                       if(!length(sigs)) return()
                       nm <- sprintf("\\S4method{%s}{%s}", f, sigs)
                       args <- lapply(mlist,
                                      get_formals_from_method_definition)
                       names(args) <- nm
                       functions_in_code <<-
                           c(functions_in_code, nm)
                       function_args_in_code <<-
                           c(function_args_in_code, args)
                   })
        }
    }

    check_codoc <- function(fName, ffd) {
        ## Compare the formals of the function in the code named 'fName'
        ## and formals 'ffd' obtained from the documentation.
        ffc <- function_args_in_code[[fName]]
        ident <- if(isFALSE(use.values)) {
                     ffc <- names(ffc)
                     ffd <- names(ffd)
                     identical(ffc, ffd)
                 } else {
                     identical(names(ffc), names(ffd)) &&
                         {
                             vffc <- as.character(ffc) # values
                             vffd <- as.character(ffd) # values
                             if(!isTRUE(use.values)) {
                                 ind <- nzchar(vffd)
                                 vffc <- vffc[ind]
                                 vffd <- vffd[ind]
                             }
                             identical(vffc, vffd)
                         }
                 }
        if(!ident)
            list(list(name = fName, code = ffc, docs = ffd))
    } #{check_codoc}

    db <- if(!missing(package))
        Rd_db(package, lib.loc = dirdir)
    else
        Rd_db(dir = dir)

    ## <FIXME>
    ## How exactly do we recognize docs for defunct/deprecated?
    db_names <- .Rd_get_names_from_Rd_db(db)
    ## pkg-defunct.Rd is not expected to list arguments
    ind <- db_names %in% paste0(package_name, "-defunct")
    db <- db[!ind]
    ## </FIXME>

    db_usages <- lapply(db, .Rd_get_section, "usage")
    ## FIXME: all db_usages entries are full of "srcref" which are never used
    db_usages <- lapply(db_usages, .parse_usage_as_much_as_possible)
    ind <- vapply(db_usages,
                  function(x) !is.null(attr(x, "bad_lines")), NA, USE.NAMES=FALSE)
    bad_lines <- lapply(db_usages[ind], attr, "bad_lines")

    bad_doc_objects <- list()
    functions_in_usages <- character()
    variables_in_usages <- character()
    data_sets_in_usages <- character()
    functions_in_usages_not_in_code <- list()
    data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code <- list()
    variables_in_usages_not_in_code <- list()
    objects_as_in <- c(objects_in_code_or_namespace
                     , names(compatibilityEnv()) # objects in other platforms
                     , if(missing(package) && str_parse_logic(meta["LazyData"], FALSE))
                           unlist(data_sets_in_code_variables, use.names = FALSE)
                     , if(is_base)
                           c("NA", "NULL", "Inf", "NaN", "TRUE", "FALSE", ".Autoloaded")
                       )

    for(nm in names(db)) {
        exprs <- db_usages[[nm]]
        if(!length(exprs)) next

        ## Get variable names and data set usages first, mostly for
        ## curiosity.
        ind <- vapply(exprs, is.name, NA, USE.NAMES=FALSE)
        if(any(ind)) {
            variables <- vapply(exprs[ind], deparse, "")
            variables_in_usages <- c(variables_in_usages, variables)
            variables <- setdiff(variables, objects_as_in)
            if(length(variables))
                variables_in_usages_not_in_code[[nm]] <- variables
            exprs <- exprs[!ind]
        }

        exprs <- exprs[vapply(exprs, is.call, NA, USE.NAMES=FALSE)]

        ind <- vapply(exprs, is_data_for_dataset, NA, USE.NAMES=FALSE)
        if(any(ind)) {
            data_sets <- vapply(exprs[ind],
                                function(e) as.character(e[[2L]]),
                                "")
            data_sets_in_usages <- c(data_sets_in_usages, data_sets)
            data_sets <- setdiff(data_sets, data_sets_in_code)
            if(length(data_sets))
                data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code[[nm]] <- data_sets
            exprs <- exprs[!ind]
        }
        ## Split out replacement function usages.
        ind <- vapply(exprs, .is_call_from_replacement_function_usage, NA, USE.NAMES=FALSE)
        replace_exprs <- exprs[ind]
        exprs <- exprs[!ind]
        ## Ordinary functions.
        functions <- vapply(exprs, function(e) as.character(e[[1L]]), "")
        ## Catch assignments: checkDocFiles() will report these, so drop
        ## them here.
        ## And also unary/binary operators
        ind <- (functions %notin% c("<-", "=", "+", "-"))
        exprs <- exprs[ind]
        functions <- functions[ind]
        functions <- .transform_S3_method_markup(as.character(functions))
        ind <- functions %in% functions_in_code
        bad_functions <-
            mapply(functions[ind],
                   exprs[ind],
                   FUN = function(x, y)
                   check_codoc(x, as.pairlist(as.alist.call(y[-1L]))),
                   SIMPLIFY = FALSE)
        ## Replacement functions.
        if(length(replace_exprs)) {
            replace_funs <-
                paste0(vapply(replace_exprs,
                              function(e) as.character(e[[2L]][[1L]]),
                              ""),
                       "<-")
            replace_funs <- .transform_S3_method_markup(replace_funs)
            functions <- c(functions, replace_funs)
            ind <- (replace_funs %in% functions_in_code)
            if(any(ind)) {
                bad_replace_funs <-
                    mapply(replace_funs[ind],
                           replace_exprs[ind],
                           FUN = function(x, y)
                           check_codoc(x,
                                      as.pairlist(c(as.alist.call(y[[2L]][-1L]),
                                                    as.alist.symbol(y[[3L]])))),
                           SIMPLIFY = FALSE)
                bad_functions <-
                    c(bad_functions, bad_replace_funs)
            }
        }

        bad_functions <- do.call(c, bad_functions)
        if(length(bad_functions))
            bad_doc_objects[[nm]] <- bad_functions

        ## Determine functions with a \usage entry in the documentation
        ## but 'missing from the code'.  If a package has a namespace, we
        ## really need to look at all objects in the namespace (hence
        ## 'objects_as_in' contains 'objects_in_code_or_namespace'),
        ## as one can access the internal
        ## symbols via ':::' and hence package developers might want to
        ## provide function usages for some of the internal functions.
        ## <FIXME>
        ## We may still have \S4method{}{} entries in functions, which
        ## cannot have a corresponding object in the code.  Hence, we
        ## remove these function entries, but should really do better,
        ## by comparing the explicit \usage entries for S4 methods to
        ## what is actually in the code.  We most likely also should do
        ## something similar for S3 methods.
        ind <- grepl(.S4_method_markup_regexp, functions)
        if(any(ind))
            functions <- functions[!ind]
        ## </FIXME>
        bad_functions <- setdiff(functions, objects_as_in)
        if(length(bad_functions))
            functions_in_usages_not_in_code[[nm]] <- bad_functions

        functions_in_usages <- c(functions_in_usages, functions)
    }

    ## Determine (function) objects in the code without a \usage entry.
    ## Of course, these could still be 'documented' via \alias.
    ## </NOTE>
    ## Older versions only printed this information without returning it
    ## (in case 'verbose' was true).  We now add this as an attribute to
    ## the bad_doc_objects returned.
    ## </NOTE>
    objects_in_code_not_in_usages <-
        setdiff(objects_in_code,
                c(functions_in_usages, variables_in_usages))
    functions_in_code_not_in_usages <-
        intersect(functions_in_code, objects_in_code_not_in_usages)
    ## (Note that 'functions_in_code' does not necessarily contain all
    ## (exported) functions in the package.)

    ## Determine functions which have no usage but really should have.
    ## If there is no namespace (including base), we have no idea.
    ## If there is one, everything "exported" (in the package env)
    ## should also have a \usage, apart from
    ## * Defunct functions
    ## * S4 generics.  Note that as per R-exts,
    ##     exporting methods on a generic in the namespace will also
    ##     export the generic, and exporting a generic in the namespace
    ##     will also export its methods.
    ##   so it seems there is really no way to figure out whether an
    ##   exported S4 generic should have a \usage entry or not ...
    functions_missing_from_usages <-
        if(!has_namespace && !is_base)
            character()
        else {
            functions <- functions_in_code_not_in_usages
            if(is_base)
                functions <-
                    setdiff(functions,
                            c(sprintf("%s.%s",
                                      .S3_methods_table[, 1L],
                                      .S3_methods_table[, 2L]),
                              c(".First.sys", ".OptRequireMethods",
                                "+", "-")))
            else {
                pname <- basename(dir)
                if(pname == "utils")
                    functions <- functions %w/o% "?"
                else if(pname == "grDevices")
                    functions <- functions %w/o% "x11"
            }
            if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
                ## Drop the functions which have S4 methods.
                functions <-
                    setdiff(functions, names(.get_S4_generics(code_env)))
            }
            ## Drop the defunct functions.
            predicate <-
                .predicate_for_calls_with_names(".Defunct", "base")
            is_defunct <- function(f) {
                f <- get(f, envir = code_env) # get is expensive
                if(!is.function(f)) return(FALSE)
                predicate(.get_top_call_in_fun(f))
            }
            functions[!vapply(functions, is_defunct, NA, USE.NAMES=FALSE)]
        }
    objects_missing_from_usages <-
        if(!has_namespace) character() else {
            c(functions_missing_from_usages,
              setdiff(objects_in_code_not_in_usages,
                      c(functions_in_code, data_sets_in_code)))
                                       }

    attr(bad_doc_objects, "objects_in_code_not_in_usages") <-
        objects_in_code_not_in_usages
    attr(bad_doc_objects, "functions_in_code_not_in_usages") <-
        functions_in_code_not_in_usages
    attr(bad_doc_objects, "functions_in_usages_not_in_code") <-
        functions_in_usages_not_in_code
    attr(bad_doc_objects, "function_args_in_code") <-
        function_args_in_code
    attr(bad_doc_objects, "data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code") <-
        data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code
    if(config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CODOC_VARIABLES_IN_USAGES_",
                                        "FALSE"))) {
        attr(bad_doc_objects, "variables_in_usages_not_in_code") <-
            variables_in_usages_not_in_code
    }
    attr(bad_doc_objects, "objects_missing_from_usages") <-
        objects_missing_from_usages
    attr(bad_doc_objects, "functions_missing_from_usages") <-
        functions_missing_from_usages
    attr(bad_doc_objects, "has_namespace") <- has_namespace
    attr(bad_doc_objects, "bad_lines") <- bad_lines
    class(bad_doc_objects) <- "codoc"
    bad_doc_objects
}

print.codoc <-
function(x, ...)
{
    functions_in_usages_not_in_code <-
        attr(x, "functions_in_usages_not_in_code")
    if(length(functions_in_usages_not_in_code)) {
        for(fname in names(functions_in_usages_not_in_code)) {
            writeLines(gettextf("Functions or methods with usage in Rd file '%s' but not in code:",
                                fname))
            .pretty_print(sQuote(unique(functions_in_usages_not_in_code[[fname]])))
            writeLines("")
        }
    }

    data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code <-
        attr(x, "data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code")
    if(length(data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code)) {
        for(fname in names(data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code)) {
            writeLines(gettextf("Data with usage in Rd file '%s' but not in code:",
                                fname))
            .pretty_print(sQuote(unique(data_sets_in_usages_not_in_code[[fname]])))
            writeLines("")
        }
    }

    variables_in_usages_not_in_code <-
        attr(x, "variables_in_usages_not_in_code")
    if(length(variables_in_usages_not_in_code)) {
        for(fname in names(variables_in_usages_not_in_code)) {
            writeLines(gettextf("Variables with usage in Rd file '%s' but not in code:",
                                fname))
            .pretty_print(sQuote(unique(variables_in_usages_not_in_code[[fname]])))
            writeLines("")
        }
    }

    ## In general, functions in the code which only have an \alias but
    ## no \usage entry are not necessarily a problem---they might be
    ## mentioned in other parts of the Rd object documenting them, or be
    ## 'internal'.  However, if a package has a namespace, then all
    ## *exported* functions should have \usage entries (apart from
    ## defunct functions and S4 generics, see the above comments for
    ## functions_missing_from_usages).  Currently, this information is
    ## returned in the codoc object but not shown.  Eventually, we might
    ## add something like
    ##     functions_missing_from_usages <-
    ##         attr(x, "functions_missing_from_usages")
    ##     if(length(functions_missing_from_usages)) {
    ##         writeLines("Exported functions without usage information:")
    ##         .pretty_print(functions_in_code_not_in_usages)
    ##         writeLines("")
    ##     }
    ## similar to the above.

    if(!length(x))
        return(invisible(x))

    has_only_names <- is.character(x[[1L]][[1L]][["code"]])

    format_args <- function(s) {
        if(!length(s))
            "function()"
        else if(has_only_names)
            paste0("function(", paste(s, collapse = ", "), ")")
        else {
            s <- paste(deparse(s), collapse = "")
            s <- gsub(" = ([,\\)])", "\\1", s)
            s <- gsub("<unescaped bksl>", "\\", s, fixed = TRUE)
            s <- gsub("^pairlist", "function", s)
            gsub("^as.pairlist\\(alist\\((.*)\\)\\)$", "function(\\1)", s)
        }
    }

    summarize_mismatches_in_names <- function(nfc, nfd) {
        if(length(nms <- setdiff(nfc, nfd)))
            writeLines(c(gettext("  Argument names in code not in docs:"),
                         strwrap(paste(nms, collapse = " "),
                                 indent = 4L, exdent = 4L)))
        if(length(nms <- setdiff(nfd, nfc)))
            writeLines(c(gettext("  Argument names in docs not in code:"),
                         strwrap(paste(nms, collapse = " "),
                                 indent = 4L, exdent = 4L)))
        len <- min(length(nfc), length(nfd))
        if(len) {
            len <- seq_len(len)
            nfc <- nfc[len]
            nfd <- nfd[len]
            ind <- which(nfc != nfd)
            len <- length(ind)
            if(len) {
                if(len > 3L) {
                    writeLines(gettext("  Mismatches in argument names (first 3):"))
                    ind <- ind[1L:3L]
                } else {
                    writeLines(gettext("  Mismatches in argument names:"))
                }
                for(i in ind) {
                    writeLines(sprintf("    Position: %d Code: %s Docs: %s",
                                       i, nfc[i], nfd[i]))
                }
            }
        }
    }

    summarize_mismatches_in_values <- function(ffc, ffd) {
        ## Be nice, and match arguments by names first.
        nms <- intersect(names(ffc), names(ffd))
        vffc <- ffc[nms]
        vffd <- ffd[nms]
        ind <- which(as.character(vffc) != as.character(vffd))
        len <- length(ind)
        if(len) {
            if(len > 3L) {
                writeLines(gettext("  Mismatches in argument default values (first 3):"))
                ind <- ind[1L:3L]
            } else {
                writeLines(gettext("  Mismatches in argument default values:"))
            }
            for(i in ind) {
                multiline <- FALSE
                cv <- deparse(vffc[[i]])
                if(length(cv) > 1L) {
                    cv <- paste(cv, collapse = "\n      ")
                    multiline <- TRUE
                }
                dv <- deparse(vffd[[i]])
                if(length(dv) > 1L) {
                    dv <- paste(dv, collapse = "\n      ")
                    multiline <- TRUE
                }
                dv <- gsub("<unescaped bksl>", "\\", dv, fixed = TRUE)
                sep <- if(multiline) "\n    " else " "
                writeLines(sprintf("    Name: '%s'%sCode: %s%sDocs: %s",
                                   nms[i], sep, cv, sep, dv))
            }
        }
    }

    summarize_mismatches <- function(ffc, ffd) {
        if(has_only_names)
            summarize_mismatches_in_names(ffc, ffd)
        else {
            summarize_mismatches_in_names(names(ffc), names(ffd))
            summarize_mismatches_in_values(ffc, ffd)
        }
    }

    for(fname in names(x)) {
        writeLines(gettextf("Codoc mismatches from Rd file '%s':",
                            fname))
        xfname <- x[[fname]]
        for(i in seq_along(xfname)) {
            ffc <- xfname[[i]][["code"]]
            ffd <- xfname[[i]][["docs"]]
            writeLines(c(xfname[[i]][["name"]],
                         strwrap(gettextf("Code: %s", format_args(ffc)),
                                 indent = 2L, exdent = 17L),
                         strwrap(gettextf("Docs: %s", format_args(ffd)),
                                 indent = 2L, exdent = 17L)))
            summarize_mismatches(ffc, ffd)
        }
        writeLines("")
    }

    invisible(x)
}

### * codocClasses

codocClasses <-
function(package, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Compare the 'structure' of S4 classes in an installed package
    ## between code and documentation.
    ## Currently, only compares the slot names.

    ## <NOTE>
    ## This is patterned after the current codoc().
    ## It would be useful to return the whole information on class slot
    ## names found in the code and matching documentation (rather than
    ## just the ones with mismatches).
    ## Currently, we only return the names of all classes checked.
    ## </NOTE>

    bad_Rd_objects <- structure(list(), class = "codocClasses")

    ## Argument handling.
    if(length(package) != 1L)
        stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
    dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
    if(!dir.exists(file.path(dir, "R")))
        stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code", dir),
             domain = NA)
    if(!.haveRds(dir))
        stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain Rd objects", dir),
             domain = NA)
    is_base <- basename(dir) == "base"

    ## Load package into code_env.
    if(!is_base)
        .load_package_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
    code_env <- .package_env(package)

    if(!.isMethodsDispatchOn())
        return(bad_Rd_objects)

    S4_classes <- methods::getClasses(code_env)
    if(!length(S4_classes)) return(bad_Rd_objects)

    sApply <- function(X, FUN, ...) ## fast and special case - only
        unlist(lapply(X = X, FUN = FUN, ...), recursive=FALSE, use.names=FALSE)
    ## Build Rd data base.
    db <- Rd_db(package, lib.loc = dirname(dir))

    ## Need some heuristics now.  When does an Rd object document just
    ## one S4 class so that we can compare (at least) the slot names?
    ## Try the following:
    ## 1) \docType{} identical to "class";
    ## 2) either exactly one \alias{} or only one ending in "-class"
    ## 3) a non-empty user-defined section 'Slots'.

    ## As going through the db to extract sections can take some time,
    ## we do the vectorized metadata computations first, and try to
    ## subscript whenever possible.

    idx <- vapply(lapply(db, .Rd_get_doc_type), identical, NA, "class",
                  USE.NAMES=FALSE)
    if(!any(idx)) return(bad_Rd_objects)
    db <- db[idx]
    stats <- c(n.S4classes = length(S4_classes), n.db = length(db))

    aliases <- lapply(db, .Rd_get_metadata, "alias")
    named_class <- lapply(aliases, endsWith, suffix="-class")
    nClass <- sApply(named_class, sum)
    oneAlias <- lengths(aliases, use.names=FALSE) == 1L
    idx <- oneAlias | nClass == 1L
    if(!any(idx)) return(bad_Rd_objects)
    db <- db[idx]
    stats["n.cl"] <- length(db)

    ## keep only the foo-class alias in case there was more than one:
    multi <- idx & !oneAlias
    aliases[multi] <-
        mapply(`[`, aliases[multi], named_class[multi],
               SIMPLIFY = FALSE, USE.NAMES = FALSE)
    aliases <- unlist(aliases[idx], use.names = FALSE)

    Rd_slots <- lapply(db, .Rd_get_section, "Slots", FALSE)
    idx <- lengths(Rd_slots) > 0L
    if(!any(idx)) return(bad_Rd_objects)
    db <- db[idx]; aliases <- aliases[idx]; Rd_slots <- Rd_slots[idx]
    stats["n.final"] <- length(db)

    db_names <- names(db)

    .get_slot_names <- function(x) {
        ## Get \describe (inside user-defined section 'Slots'):
        ## Should this allow for several \describe blocks?
        x <- .Rd_get_section(x, "describe")
        ## Get the \item tags inside \describe.
        txt <- .Rd_get_item_tags(x)
        if(!length(txt)) return(character())
        txt <- gsub("\\\\l?dots", "...", txt)
        ## And now strip enclosing '\code{...}:'
        txt <- gsub("\\\\code\\{([^}]*)\\}:?", "\\1", as.character(txt))
        txt <- unlist(strsplit(txt, ", *"))
        trimws(txt)
    }

    .inheritedSlotNames <- function(ext) {
        supcl <- methods::.selectSuperClasses(ext)
        unique(unlist(lapply(lapply(supcl, methods::getClassDef),
                             methods::slotNames),
                      use.names=FALSE))
    }

    S4topics <- vapply(S4_classes, utils:::topicName, " ",
                       type="class", USE.NAMES=FALSE)
    S4_checked <- S4_classes[has.a <- S4topics %in% aliases]
    idx <- match(S4topics[has.a], aliases)
    for(icl in seq_along(S4_checked)) {
        cl <- S4_checked[icl]
        cld <- methods::getClass(cl, where = code_env)
        ii <- idx[icl]
        ## Add sanity checking later ...
        scld <- methods::slotNames(cld)
        codeSlots <- if(!is.null(scld)) sort(scld) else character()
        docSlots  <- sort(.get_slot_names(Rd_slots[[ii]]))
        superSlots <- .inheritedSlotNames(cld@contains)
        if(length(superSlots)) ## allow '\dots' in docSlots
            docSlots <-
                docSlots[docSlots %notin% c("...", "\\dots")]
        ## was if(!identical(slots_in_code, slots_in_docs)) {
        if(!all(docSlots %in% codeSlots) ||
           !all(setdiff(codeSlots, superSlots) %in% docSlots) ) {
            bad_Rd_objects[[db_names[ii]]] <-
                list(name = cl,
                     code = codeSlots,
                     inherited = superSlots,
                     docs = docSlots)
        }
    }

    attr(bad_Rd_objects, "S4_classes_checked") <- S4_checked
    attr(bad_Rd_objects, "stats") <- stats
    bad_Rd_objects
} ## end{ codocClasses }

format.codocClasses <-
function(x, ...)
{
    .fmt <- function(nm) {
        wrapPart <- function(nam) {
            capWord <- function(w) sub("\\b(\\w)", "\\U\\1", w, perl = TRUE)

            if(length(O <- docObj[[nam]]))
                strwrap(sprintf("%s: %s", gettextf(capWord(nam)),
                                paste(O, collapse = " ")),
                        indent = 2L, exdent = 8L)
        }

        docObj <- x[[nm]]
        c(gettextf("S4 class codoc mismatches from Rd file '%s':",
                   nm),
          gettextf("Slots for class '%s'", docObj[["name"]]),
          wrapPart("code"),
          wrapPart("inherited"),
          wrapPart("docs"),
          "")
    }

    as.character(unlist(lapply(names(x), .fmt)))
}

### * codocData

codocData <-
function(package, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Compare the 'structure' of 'data' objects (variables or data
    ## sets) in an installed package between code and documentation.
    ## Currently, only compares the variable names of data frames found.

    ## <NOTE>
    ## This is patterned after the current codoc().
    ## It would be useful to return the whole information on data frame
    ## variable names found in the code and matching documentation
    ## (rather than just the ones with mismatches).
    ## Currently, we only return the names of all data frames checked.
    ## </NOTE>

    bad_Rd_objects <- structure(list(), class = "codocData")

    ## Argument handling.
    if(length(package) != 1L)
        stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")

    dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)

    ## Build Rd data base.
    db <- Rd_db(package, lib.loc = dirname(dir))

    is_base <- basename(dir) == "base"

    ## Load package into code_env.
    if(!is_base)
        .load_package_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
    code_env <- .package_env(package)
    ns_env <- asNamespace(package)

    ## Could check here whether the package has any variables or data
    ## sets (and return if not).

    ## Need some heuristics now.  When does an Rd object document a
    ## data.frame (could add support for other classes later) variable
    ## or data set so that we can compare (at least) the names of the
    ## variables in the data frame?  Try the following:
    ## * just one \alias{};
    ## * if documentation was generated via prompt, there is a \format
    ##   section starting with 'A data frame with' (but many existing Rd
    ##   files instead have 'This data frame contains' and containing
    ##   one or more \describe sections inside.

    ## As going through the db to extract sections can take some time,
    ## we do the vectorized metadata computations first, and try to
    ## subscript whenever possible.
    aliases <- lapply(db, .Rd_get_metadata, "alias")
    idx <- lengths(aliases) == 1L
    if(!any(idx)) return(bad_Rd_objects)
    db <- db[idx]
    aliases <- aliases[idx]

    names(db) <- names(db)

    .get_var_names_from_item_tags <- function(s, nice = TRUE) {
        if(!length(s)) return(character())

        nms <- character()
        ## Handle trailing colons and leading/trailing white space.
        s <- sub("^[[:space:]]*", "", sub("([[:space:]]*:)?[[:space:]]*$", "", s))
        ## Handle \samp entries: need to match until the first unescaped
        ## rbrace.
        re <- "\\\\samp\\{(([^\\}]|[\\].)*)\\}([[:space:]]*,[[:space:]]*)?"
        m <- gregexpr(re, s)
        if(any(unlist(m) > -1)) {
            nms <- sub(re, "\\1", unlist(regmatches(s, m)))
            ## Unescape Rd escapes.
            nms <- gsub("\\\\([{}%])", "\\1", nms)
            regmatches(s, m) <- ""
        }
        ## Handle \code entries, assuming that they can be taken literally
        ## (no escaping or quoting to obtain valid R syntax).
        re <- "\\\\code\\{([^}]*)\\}([[:space:]]*,[[:space:]]*)?"
        m <- gregexpr(re, s)
        add <- regmatches(s, m)
        lens <- lengths(add)
        add <- sub(re, "\\1", unlist(add))
        ## The old code base simply dropped the \code markup via
        ##   gsub("\\\\code\\{(.*)\\}:?", "\\1", s)
        ## unescaped underscores and stripped whitespace.
        ## Let us be nice about such whitespace inside a single \code (by
        ## default), as this should always render ok in the manual, but not
        ## about escaped underscores e.g.,
        ##   ElemStatLearn/man/marketing.Rd: Dual\_Income
        ## and comma-separated lists inside
        ## \code, e.g.,
        ##   prefmod/man/trdel.Rd: \code{V1,V2,V3,V4,V5,V6,V7,V8,V9,V10}
        ## as these will not render correctly.
        if(nice) {
            ind <- rep.int(lens == 1L, lens)
            add[ind] <- trimws(add[ind])
        }
        nms <- c(nms, add)
        regmatches(s, m) <- ""
        ## Handle rest.
        nms <- c(nms, unlist(strsplit(s, "[[:space:]]*,[[:space:]]*")))
        nms
    }

    .get_data_frame_var_names <- function(x) {
        ## Make sure that there is exactly one format section:
        ## using .Rd_get_section() would get the first one.
        x <- x[RdTags(x) == "\\format"]
        if(length(x) != 1L) return(character())
        ## Drop comments.
        ## <FIXME>
        ## Remove calling .Rd_drop_comments() eventually.
        x <- .Rd_drop_comments(x[[1L]])
        ## </FIXME>
        ## What did the format section start with?
        if(!grepl("^[[:space:]]*(A|This) data frame",
                  .Rd_deparse(x, tag = FALSE)))
            return(character())
        ## Get \describe inside \format.
        ## Should this allow for several \describe blocks?
        x <- .Rd_get_section(x, "describe")
        ## Get the \item tags inside \describe.
        x <- .Rd_get_item_tags(x)
        ## And extract the variable names from these.
        .get_var_names_from_item_tags(x)
    }

    Rd_var_names <- lapply(db, .get_data_frame_var_names)

    idx <- (lengths(Rd_var_names) > 0L)
    if(!length(idx)) return(bad_Rd_objects)
    aliases <- unlist(aliases[idx])
    Rd_var_names <- Rd_var_names[idx]

    db_names <- names(db)[idx]

    data_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
    data_dir <- file.path(dir, "data")
    ## with lazy data we have data() but don't need to use it.
    has_data <- dir.exists(data_dir) &&
        !file_test("-f", file.path(data_dir, "Rdata.rdb"))
    data_exts <- .make_file_exts("data")

    ## Now go through the aliases.
    data_frames_checked <- character()
    for(i in seq_along(aliases)) {
        ## Store the documented variable names.
        var_names_in_docs <- sort(Rd_var_names[[i]])
        ## Try finding the variable or data set given by the alias.
        al <- aliases[i]
        if(!is.null(A <- get0(al, envir = code_env, mode = "list", inherits = FALSE)))
            al <- A
        else if(!is_base &&
                !is.null(A <- get0(al, envir = ns_env, mode = "list", inherits = FALSE)))
            al <- A
        else if(has_data) {
            ## Should be a data set.
            if(!length(dir(data_dir)
                       %in% paste(al, data_exts, sep = "."))) {
                next                    # What the hell did we pick up?
            }
            ## Try loading the data set into data_env.
            utils::data(list = al, envir = data_env)
            if(!is.null(A <- get0(al, envir = data_env, mode = "list", inherits = FALSE)))
                al <- A

            ## And clean up data_env.
            rm(list = ls(envir = data_env, all.names = TRUE),
               envir = data_env)
        }
        if(!is.data.frame(al)) next
        ## Now we should be ready:
        data_frames_checked <- c(data_frames_checked, aliases[i])
        var_names_in_code <- sort(names(al))
        if(!identical(var_names_in_code, var_names_in_docs))
            bad_Rd_objects[[db_names[i]]] <-
                list(name = aliases[i],
                     code = var_names_in_code,
                     docs = var_names_in_docs)
    }

    attr(bad_Rd_objects, "data_frames_checked") <-
        as.character(data_frames_checked)
    bad_Rd_objects
}

format.codocData <-
function(x, ...)
{
    format_args <- function(s) paste(s, collapse = " ")

    .fmt <- function(nm) {
        docObj <- x[[nm]]
        ## FIXME singular or plural?
        c(gettextf("Data codoc mismatches from Rd file '%s':", nm),
          gettextf("Variables in data frame '%s'", docObj[["name"]]),
          strwrap(gettextf("Code: %s", format_args(docObj[["code"]])),
                  indent = 2L, exdent = 8L),
          strwrap(gettextf("Docs: %s", format_args(docObj[["docs"]])),
                  indent = 2L, exdent = 8L),
          "")
    }

    as.character(unlist(lapply(names(x), .fmt)))
}

### * checkDocFiles

checkDocFiles <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL, chkInternal = NULL)
{
    ## Argument handling.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
    }
    else {
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
    }

    check_internal_specially <- FALSE
    ## Do
    ##   if(!isTRUE(chkInternal) && !isFALSE(chkInternal))
    ## more efficiently.
    if(is.null(chkInternal) ||
       !is.logical(chkInternal) ||
       (length(chkInternal) != 1L) ||
       is.na(chkInternal))
        chkInternal <- check_internal_specially <- TRUE

    db <- if(!missing(package))
              Rd_db(package, lib.loc = dirname(dir))
          else
              Rd_db(dir = dir)

    db_aliases  <- lapply(db, .Rd_get_metadata, "alias")
    db_keywords <- lapply(db, .Rd_get_metadata, "keyword")

    db_usages <- lapply(db, .Rd_get_section, "usage")
    ## We traditionally also use the usage "texts" for some sanity
    ## checking ...
    ## <FIXME>
    ## Remove calling .Rd_drop_comments() eventually.
    db_usage_texts <-
        lapply(db_usages,
               function(e) .Rd_deparse(.Rd_drop_comments(e)))
    ## </FIXME>
    db_usages <- lapply(db_usages, .parse_usage_as_much_as_possible)
    ind <- vapply(db_usages,
                  function(x) !is.null(attr(x, "bad_lines")),
                  NA)
    bad_lines <- lapply(db_usages[ind], attr, "bad_lines")

    db_argument_names <- lapply(db, .Rd_get_argument_names)

    bad_doc_objects <- list()
    all_internal <- (length(bad_lines) == 0L)

    if(missing(package))
        package <- .get_package_metadata(dir)["Package"]

    for(nm in names(db)) {
        ## <FIXME>
        ## There really should be no \arguments or \value without a
        ## \usage, so it should be "safe" to skip checking \arguments in
        ## case of no \usage.
        ## However, currently the above is not ensured.
        ## Ideally, checkRd() should complain ...
        exprs <- db_usages[[nm]]
        if(!length(exprs)) next
        ## </FIXME>

        ## If !chkInternal, exclude internal Rd objects from further
        ## computations.  Otherwise, maybe treat them specially, and
        ## ignore arguments in \usage but not in \arguments.
        internal <- "internal" %in% db_keywords[[nm]]
        if(internal && !chkInternal) next
        special <-
            (internal &&
             (check_internal_specially ||
              (package == "base") ||
              nm %in% paste0(package,
                             c("-defunct", "-deprecated", "-internal"),
                             ".Rd")))

        aliases <- db_aliases[[nm]]
        arg_names_in_arg_list <- db_argument_names[[nm]]

        ## Determine function names ('functions') and corresponding
        ## arguments ('arg_names_in_usage') in the \usage.  Note how we
        ## try to deal with data set documentation.
        ind <- vapply(exprs,
                      function(e)
                          is.call(e) && !is_data_for_dataset(e),
                      NA, USE.NAMES=FALSE)
        exprs <- exprs[ind]
        ## Split out replacement function usages.
        ind <- vapply(exprs, .is_call_from_replacement_function_usage,
                      NA, USE.NAMES=FALSE)
        replace_exprs <- exprs[ind]
        exprs <- exprs[!ind]
        ## Ordinary functions.
        functions <-
            vapply(exprs, function(e) as.character(e[[1L]]), "")
        ## Catch assignments.
        ind <- functions %in% c("<-", "=")
        assignments <- exprs[ind]
        if(any(ind)) {
            exprs     <- exprs    [!ind]
            functions <- functions[!ind]
        }
        ## (Note that as.character(sapply(exprs, `[[`, 1L)) does not do
        ## what we want due to backquotifying.)
        arg_names_in_usage <-
            unlist(lapply(exprs,
                          function(e) .arg_names_from_call(e[-1L])))
        ## Replacement functions.
        if(length(replace_exprs)) {
            replace_funs <-
                paste0(vapply(replace_exprs,
                              function(e) as.character(e[[2L]][[1L]]), ""),
                       "<-")
            functions <- c(functions, replace_funs)
            arg_names_in_usage <-
                c(arg_names_in_usage,
                  unlist(lapply(replace_exprs,
                                function(e)
                                c(.arg_names_from_call(e[[2L]][-1L]),
                                  .arg_names_from_call(e[[3L]])))))
        }
        ## And finally transform the S3 \method{}{} markup into the
        ## usual function names ...
        ## <NOTE>
        ## If we were really picky, we would worry about possible
        ## namespace renaming.
        functions <- .transform_S3_method_markup(functions)
        ## </NOTE>
        ## Also transform the markup for S4 replacement methods.
        functions <- .transform_S4_method_markup(functions)

        ## Now analyze what we found.
        arg_names_in_usage_missing_in_arg_list <- if(special) NULL else
            setdiff(arg_names_in_usage, arg_names_in_arg_list)
        arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage <-
            setdiff(arg_names_in_arg_list, arg_names_in_usage)
        if(length(arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage)) {
            usage_text <- db_usage_texts[[nm]]
            bad_args <- character()
            ## In the case of 'over-documented' arguments, try to be
            ## defensive and reduce to arguments which either are not
            ## syntactically valid names or do not match the \usage text
            ## (modulo word boundaries).
            bad <- !grepl("^[[:alnum:]._]+$",
                          arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage)
            if(any(bad)) {
                bad_args <- arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage[bad]
                arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage <-
                    arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage[!bad]
            }
            bad <- vapply(arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage,
                          function(x)
                              !grepl(paste0("(^|\\W)",
                                            reQuote(x),
                                            "($|\\W)"),
                                     gsub("\\\\dots", "...",
                                          usage_text)),
                          NA)
            arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage <-
                c(bad_args,
                  arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage[as.logical(bad)])
            ## Note that the fact that we can parse the raw \usage does
            ## not imply that over-documented arguments are a problem:
            ## this works for Rd files documenting e.g. shell utilities
            ## but fails for files with special syntax (Extract.Rd).
        }

        ## Also test whether the objects we found from the \usage all
        ## have aliases, provided not all aliases end in '-deprecated'.
        ## This exception allows packages to keep the original help page of a
        ## deprecated function at help("<fun>-deprecated") (see ?deprecated)
        ## and alias <fun> to help("<pkg>-deprecated").
        functions_not_in_aliases <-
            if(!all(endsWith(aliases, "-deprecated"))) {
                ## Argh.  There are good reasons for keeping \S4method{}{}
                ## as is, but of course this is not what the aliases use ...
                ## <FIXME>
                ## Should maybe use utils:::topicName(), but in any case, we
                ## should have functions for converting between the two
                ## forms, see also the code for undoc().
                aliases <- sub("([^,]+),(.+)-method$",
                               "\\\\S4method{\\1}{\\2}",
                               aliases)
                ## </FIXME>
                aliases <- gsub("\\%", "%", aliases, fixed=TRUE)
                setdiff(functions, aliases)
            }
            else character()

        if((length(arg_names_in_usage_missing_in_arg_list))
           || anyDuplicated(arg_names_in_arg_list)
           || (length(arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage))
           || (length(functions_not_in_aliases))
           || (length(assignments))) {
            bad_doc_objects[[nm]] <-
                list(missing = arg_names_in_usage_missing_in_arg_list,
                     duplicated =
                     arg_names_in_arg_list[duplicated(arg_names_in_arg_list)],
                     overdoc = arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage,
                     unaliased = functions_not_in_aliases,
                     assignments = assignments)
            if(!internal)
                all_internal <- FALSE
        }
    } # for(..)

    structure(bad_doc_objects, class = "checkDocFiles",
              "bad_lines" = bad_lines,
              "all_internal" = all_internal)
}

format.checkDocFiles <-
function(x, ...)
{
    .fmt <- function(nm) {
        c(character(),
          if(length(arg_names_in_usage_missing_in_arg_list <-
                    x[[nm]][["missing"]])) {
              c(gettextf("Undocumented arguments in Rd file '%s'",
                         nm),
                .pretty_format(unique(arg_names_in_usage_missing_in_arg_list)))
          },
          if(length(duplicated_args_in_arg_list <-
                    x[[nm]][["duplicated"]])) {
              c(gettextf("Duplicated \\argument entries in Rd file '%s':",
                         nm),
                .pretty_format(duplicated_args_in_arg_list))
          },
          if(length(arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage <-
                    x[[nm]][["overdoc"]])) {
              c(gettextf("Documented arguments not in \\usage in Rd file '%s':",
                         nm),
                .pretty_format(unique(arg_names_in_arg_list_missing_in_usage)))
          },
          if(length(functions_not_in_aliases <-
                    x[[nm]][["unaliased"]])) {
              c(gettextf("Objects in \\usage without \\alias in Rd file '%s':",
                         nm),
                .pretty_format(unique(functions_not_in_aliases)))
          },
          if(length(assignments <-
                    x[[nm]][["assignments"]])) {
              c(gettextf("Assignments in \\usage in Rd file '%s':",
                         nm),
                sprintf("  %s", unlist(lapply(assignments, format))))
          },
          "")
    }

    y <- as.character(unlist(lapply(names(x), .fmt)))

    if(length(bad_lines <- attr(x, "bad_lines")))
        y <- c(y,
               unlist(lapply(names(bad_lines),
                             function(nm) {
                                 c(gettextf("Bad \\usage lines found in Rd file '%s':",
                                            nm),
                                   paste0("  ", bad_lines[[nm]]))
                             })),
               "")

    ## <NOTE>
    ## Terrible hack, see comments on
    ##    __R_CHECK_DOC_FILES_NOTE_IF_ALL_INTERNAL__
    ## in check.R
    if(length(y) &&
       !length(bad_lines) &&
       (Sys.getenv("__R_CHECK_DOC_FILES_NOTE_IF_ALL_INTERNAL__",
                   "FALSE") == "TRUE") &&
       isTRUE(attr(x, "all_internal")))
        y <- c(y, "All issues in internal Rd files.")
    ## </NOTE>

    y
}

### * checkDocStyle

checkDocStyle <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    has_namespace <- FALSE

    ## Argument handling.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        ## Using package installed in 'dir' ...
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile))
            .read_description(dfile)
        else
            character()
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        if(!.haveRds(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain Rd objects", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        package_name <- package
        is_base <- package_name == "base"

        ## Load package into code_env.
        if(!is_base)
            .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
        code_env <- asNamespace(package)

        objects_in_code <- sort(names(code_env))

        if(!is_base) {
            has_namespace <- TRUE
            ## Determine names of declared S3 methods and associated S3
            ## generics.
            ns_S3_methods_db <- getNamespaceInfo(package, "S3methods")
            ns_S3_generics <- as.character(ns_S3_methods_db[, 1L])
            ns_S3_methods <- ns_S3_methods_db[, 3L]
            if(!is.character(ns_S3_methods)) {
                ## As of 2018-07, direct calls to registerS3method()
                ## could have registered a function object (not name).
                ind <- vapply(ns_S3_methods, is.character, NA)
                ns_S3_methods[!ind] <- ""
                ns_S3_methods <- as.character(ns_S3_methods)
            }
        }
    }
    else {
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        package_name <- basename(dir) # early, before resolving sym.links
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        if(!.haveRds(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain Rd objects", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        is_base <- package_name == "base"

        code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile)) .read_description(dfile) else character()
        .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
        sys_data_file <- file.path(code_dir, "sysdata.rda")
        if(file_test("-f", sys_data_file)) load(sys_data_file, code_env)

        objects_in_code <- sort(names(code_env))

        if(file.exists(file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE")) &&
           !inherits(tryCatch(nsInfo <-
                                  parseNamespaceFile(package_name,
                                                     dirname(dir)),
                              error = identity),
                     "error")) {
            has_namespace <- TRUE
            ## Determine exported objects.
            OK <- intersect(objects_in_code, nsInfo$exports)
            for(p in nsInfo$exportPatterns)
                OK <- c(OK, grep(p, objects_in_code, value = TRUE))
            objects_in_code <- unique(OK)
            ## Determine names of declared S3 methods and associated S3
            ## generics.
            ns_S3_methods_db <- .get_namespace_S3_methods_db(nsInfo)
            ns_S3_generics <- ns_S3_methods_db[, 1L]
            ns_S3_methods  <- ns_S3_methods_db[, 3L]
        }

    }

    ## Find the function objects in the given package.
    functions_in_code <-
        Filter(function(f) is.function(get(f, envir = code_env)),  # get is expensive
               objects_in_code)

    ## Find all S3 generics "as seen from the package".
    all_S3_generics <- .get_S3_generics_in_base()
    if(!is_base) {
        all_S3_generics <-
            unique(c(Filter(function(f)
                                .is_S3_generic(f, envir = code_env),
                            functions_in_code),
                     if(!missing(package))
                         .get_S3_generics_in_env(parent.env(code_env)),
                     all_S3_generics))
    }
    ## Make the group S3 generics "visible" from code_env.
    code_env <- .make_S3_group_generic_env(parent = code_env)

    ## Find all methods in the given package for the generic functions
    ## determined above.  Store as a list indexed by the names of the
    ## generic functions.
    ## Change in 3.0.0: we only look for methods named generic.class,
    ## not those registered by a 3-arg S3method().
    methods_stop_list <- nonS3methods(package_name)
    methods_in_package <-
        Map(function(g) {
                ## This shouldn't happen any more ...
                if(!exists(g, envir = code_env)) return(character())
                ## <FIXME>
                ## We should really determine the name g dispatches for,
                ## see a current version of methods() [2003-07-07].
                ## (Care is needed for internal generics and group
                ## generics.)
                name <- paste0(g, ".")
                methods <-
                    functions_in_code[startsWith(functions_in_code, name)]
                ## </FIXME>
                methods <- setdiff(methods, methods_stop_list)
                if(has_namespace) {
                    ## Find registered methods for generic g.
                    methods2 <- ns_S3_methods[ns_S3_generics == g]
                    ## but for these purposes check name.
                    OK <- startsWith(methods2, name)
                    methods <- c(methods, methods2[OK])
                }
                methods
            },
            all_S3_generics)
    all_methods_in_package <- unlist(methods_in_package)
    ## There are situations where S3 methods might be documented as
    ## functions (i.e., with their full name), if they do something
    ## useful also for arguments not inheriting from the class they
    ## provide a method for.
    ## But then they should be exported under another name, and
    ## registered as an S3 method.
    ## Prior to 2.14.0 we used to allow this in the case the
    ## package has a namespace and the method is exported (even though
    ## we strongly prefer using FOO(as.BAR(x)) to FOO.BAR(x) for such
    ## cases).
    ## But this caused discontinuities with adding namespaces.
    ## Historical exception
    if(package_name == "cluster")
        all_methods_in_package <-
            setdiff(all_methods_in_package, functions_in_code)

    db <- if(!missing(package))
        Rd_db(package, lib.loc = dirname(dir))
    else
        Rd_db(dir = dir)

    ## Ignore pkg-deprecated.Rd and pkg-defunct.Rd.
    ## <FIXME>
    ## How exactly do we recognize docs for defunct/deprecated?
    db_names <- .Rd_get_names_from_Rd_db(db)
    ind <- db_names %in% paste(package_name, c("deprecated", "defunct"),
                               sep = "-")
    db <- db[!ind]
    ## </FIXME>

    db_usages <-
        lapply(db,
               function(Rd) {
                   Rd <- .Rd_get_section(Rd, "usage")
                   .parse_usage_as_much_as_possible(Rd)
               })
    ind <- vapply(db_usages,
                  function(x) !is.null(attr(x, "bad_lines")),
                  NA)
    bad_lines <- lapply(db_usages[ind], attr, "bad_lines")

    bad_doc_objects <- list()

    for(nm in names(db)) {

        ## Determine function names in the \usage.
        exprs <- db_usages[[nm]]
        exprs <- exprs[lengths(exprs) > 1L]
        ## Ordinary functions.
        functions <-
            vapply(exprs, function(e) as.character(e[[1L]]), "")
        ## (Note that as.character(sapply(exprs, `[[`, 1L)) does not do
        ## what we want due to backquotifying.)
        ## Replacement functions.
        ind <- vapply(exprs, .is_call_from_replacement_function_usage, NA)
        if(any(ind)) {
            replace_funs <-
                paste0(vapply(exprs[ind],
                              function(e) as.character(e[[2L]][[1L]]),
                              ""),
                       "<-")
            functions <- c(functions, replace_funs)
        }

        methods_with_full_name <-
            intersect(functions, all_methods_in_package)

        functions <- .transform_S3_method_markup(functions)

        methods_with_generic <-
            Map(function(g)
                    intersect(functions, methods_in_package[[g]]),
                intersect(functions, all_S3_generics))

        if((length(methods_with_generic)) ||
           (length(methods_with_full_name)))
            bad_doc_objects[[nm]] <-
                list(withGeneric  = methods_with_generic,
                     withFullName = methods_with_full_name)

    }

    attr(bad_doc_objects, "bad_lines") <- bad_lines
    class(bad_doc_objects) <- "checkDocStyle"
    bad_doc_objects
}

format.checkDocStyle <-
function(x, ...)
{
    .fmt <- function(nm) {
        ## <NOTE>
        ## With \method{GENERIC}{CLASS} now being transformed to show
        ## both GENERIC and CLASS info, documenting S3 methods on the
        ## same page as their generic is not necessarily a problem any
        ## more (as one can refer to the generic or the methods in the
        ## documentation, in particular for the primary argument).
        ## Hence, even if we still provide information about this, we
        ## no longer print it by default.  One can still access it via
        ##   lapply(checkDocStyle("foo"), `[[`, "withGeneric")
        ## (but of course it does not print that nicely anymore),
        ## </NOTE>
        methods_with_full_name <- x[[nm]][["withFullName"]]
        if(length(methods_with_full_name)) {
            c(gettextf("S3 methods shown with full name in Rd file '%s':",
                       nm),
              .pretty_format(methods_with_full_name),
              "")
        } else {
            character()
        }
    }

    as.character(unlist(lapply(names(x), .fmt)))
}


### * checkFF

checkFF <-
function(package, dir, file, lib.loc = NULL,
         registration = FALSE, check_DUP = FALSE,
         verbose = getOption("verbose"))
{
    allow_suppress <- !nzchar(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_FF_AS_CRAN_"))
    suppressCheck <- function(e)
        allow_suppress &&
            length(e) == 2L && is.call(e) && is.symbol(e[[1L]]) &&
                as.character(e[[1L]]) == "dontCheck"

    has_namespace <- FALSE
    is_installed_msg <- is_installed <- FALSE
    ## Argument handling.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        db <- .read_description(dfile)
        pkg <- pkgDLL <- basename(dir)
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        have_registration <- FALSE
        if(basename(dir) != "base") {
            .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
            code_env <- asNamespace(package)
            if(!is.null(DLLs <- get0("DLLs", envir = code_env$.__NAMESPACE__.))) {
                ## fake installs have this, of class DLLInfoList
                if(length(DLLs)) has_namespace <- TRUE
                if(length(DLLs) && inherits(DLLs[[1L]], "DLLInfo")) {
                    pkgDLL <- unclass(DLLs[[1L]])$name # different for data.table
                    if(registration) {
                        reg <- getDLLRegisteredRoutines(DLLs[[1L]])
                        have_registration <- sum(lengths(reg)) > 0L
                    }
                }
            }
        } else {
            has_namespace <- have_registration <- TRUE
            code_env <-.package_env(package)
        }
        is_installed <- TRUE
    }
    else if(!missing(dir)) {
        have_registration <- FALSE
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        pkg <- pkgDLL <- basename(dir)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        enc <- NA; db <- NULL
        if(file.exists(dfile)) {
            db <- .read_description(dfile)
            enc <- db["Encoding"]
        }
        if(pkg == "base") has_namespace <- TRUE
        if(file.exists(file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE")) &&
           !inherits(tryCatch(nm <- parseNamespaceFile(basename(dir),
                                                       dirname(dir)),
                              error = identity),
                     "error")) {
            has_namespace <- length(nm$dynlibs) > 0L
        }
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        file <- tempfile()
        on.exit(unlink(file))
        if(!file.create(file)) stop("unable to create ", file, domain = NA)
        if(!all(.file_append_ensuring_LFs(file,
                                          list_files_with_type(code_dir,
                                                               "code"))))
            stop("unable to write code files", domain = NA)
    }
    else if(!missing(file)) {
        pkg <- enc <- NA
    } else
        stop("you must specify 'package', 'dir' or 'file'")

    if(missing(package) && !file_test("-f", file))
        stop(gettextf("file '%s' does not exist", file),
             domain = NA)

    ## Should there really be a 'verbose' argument?
    ## It may be useful to extract all foreign function calls but then
    ## we would want the calls back ...
    ## What we currently do is the following: if 'verbose' is true, we
    ## show all foreign function calls in abbreviated form with the line
    ## ending in either 'OK' or 'MISSING', and we return the list of
    ## 'bad' FF calls (i.e., where the 'PACKAGE' argument is missing)
    ## *invisibly* (so that output is not duplicated).
    ## Otherwise, if not verbose, we return the list of bad FF calls.

    bad_exprs <- empty_exprs <- wrong_pkg <- other_problem <- list()
    other_desc <- character()
    bad_pkg <- character()
    dup_false <- list()
    FF_funs <- FF_fun_names <- c(".C", ".Fortran", ".Call", ".External",
                                 ".Call.graphics", ".External.graphics")
    ## As pointed out by DTL, packages could use non-base FF calls for
    ## which missing 'PACKAGE' arguments are not necessarily a problem.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        is_FF_fun_from_base <-
            vapply(FF_funs,
                   function(f) {
                       e <- .find_owner_env(f, code_env)
                       (identical(e, baseenv())
                        || identical(e, .BaseNamespaceEnv))
                   },
                   NA)
        FF_funs <- FF_funs[is_FF_fun_from_base]
    }
    ## Also, need to handle base::.Call() etc ...
    FF_funs <- c(FF_funs, sprintf("base::%s", FF_fun_names))

    check_registration <- function(e, fr) {
        sym <- e[[2L]]
        name <- deparse(sym, nlines = 1L)
        if (name == "...")
            return ("SYMBOL OK") # we cannot check this, e.g. RProtoBuf

        if (is.character(sym)) {
            if (!have_registration) return ("SYMBOL OK")
            FF_fun <- as.character(e[[1L]])
            sym <- reg[[FF_fun]][[sym]]
            if(is.null(sym)) return ("SYMBOL OK")
        }

        if (!is_installed) {
            if (!is_installed_msg) {
                other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
                other_desc <<- c(other_desc, "foreign function registration not tested, as package was not installed")
                is_installed_msg <<- TRUE
            }
            return("OTHER") # registration checks need the package to be installed
        }
        if (is.symbol(sym)) { # it might be something like pkg::sym (that's a call)
            if (!exists(name, code_env, inherits = FALSE)) {
                if (allow_suppress &&
                    name %in% utils::suppressForeignCheck(, package))
                    return ("SYMBOL OK") # skip false positives
                if (have_registration) {
                    if (name %in% fr) {
                        other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
                        other_desc <<-
                            c(other_desc,
                              sprintf("symbol %s in the local frame",
                                      sQuote(name)))
                    } else {
                        other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
                        other_desc <<-
                            c(other_desc,
                              sprintf("symbol %s not in namespace",
                                      sQuote(name)))
                    }
                }
                return("OTHER")
            }
        } else if (suppressCheck(sym))
            return("SKIPPED")

        sym <- tryCatch(eval(sym, code_env), error = function(e) e)
        if (inherits(sym, "error")) {
            if (have_registration || !allow_suppress)  {
                other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
                other_desc <<-
                    c(other_desc, sprintf("Evaluating %s during check gives error\n%s",
                                          sQuote(name), sQuote(sym$message)))
            }
            return("OTHER")
        }

        FF_fun <- as.character(e[[1L]])
        ## lmom's sym evaluate to character, so try to look up.
        ## FIXME: maybe check this is not PACKAGE = "another package"
        if (is.character(sym)) {
            if (!have_registration) return ("SYMBOL OK")
            sym <- reg[[FF_fun]][[sym]]
            if(is.null(sym)) return ("SYMBOL OK")
        }

        ## These are allowed and used by SU's packages so skip for now
        if (inherits(sym, "RegisteredNativeSymbol")
            || inherits(sym, "NativeSymbol"))
            return ("SYMBOL OK")

        if (!inherits(sym, "NativeSymbolInfo")) {
            other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
            ## other_desc <<- c(other_desc, sprintf("\"%s\" is not of class \"%s\"", name, "NativeSymbolInfo"))
            other_desc <<- c(other_desc, sprintf("%s is of class \"%s\"",
                                                 sQuote(name), class(sym)))
            return("OTHER")
        }
        ## This might be symbol from another (base?) package.
        ## Allow for Rcpp modules
        parg <- unclass(sym$dll)$name
        if(length(parg) == 1L && parg %notin% c("Rcpp", pkgDLL)) {
            wrong_pkg <<- c(wrong_pkg, e)
            bad_pkg <<- c(bad_pkg, parg)
        }
        numparms <- sym$numParameters
        if (length(numparms) && numparms >= 0) {
            ## We have to be careful if ... is in the call.
            if (any(as.character(e) == "...")) {
                other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
                other_desc <<-
                    c(other_desc,
                      sprintf("call includes ..., expected %d %s",
                              numparms,
                              if(numparms > 1L) "parameters" else "parameter"))
            } else {
                callparms <- length(e) - 2L
                if ("PACKAGE" %in% names(e)) callparms <- callparms - 1L
                if (FF_fun %in% c(".C", ".Fortran"))
                    callparms <- callparms - length(intersect(names(e), c("NAOK", "DUP", "ENCODING")))
                if (!is.null(numparms) && numparms >= 0L && numparms != callparms) {
                    other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
                    other_desc <<-
                        c(other_desc,
                          sprintf("call to %s with %d %s, expected %d",
                                  sQuote(name), callparms,
                                  if(callparms > 1L) "parameters" else "parameter",
                                  numparms))
                    return("OTHER")
                }
            }
        }
        if (inherits(sym, "CallRoutine") &&
            (FF_fun %notin% c(".Call", ".Call.graphics"))) {
            other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
            other_desc <<- c(other_desc, sprintf("%s registered as %s, but called with %s", sQuote(name), ".Call", FF_fun))
            return("OTHER")
        }
        if (inherits(sym, "ExternalRoutine") && !(FF_fun %in% c(".External", ".External.graphics"))) {
            other_problem <<- c(other_problem, e)
            other_desc <<- c(other_desc, sprintf("%s registered as %s, but called with %s", sQuote(name), ".External", FF_fun))
            return("OTHER")
        }

        "SYMBOL OK"
    }

    find_bad_exprs <- function(e) {
        if(is.call(e) || is.expression(e)) {
            ## <NOTE>
            ## This picks up all calls, e.g. a$b, and they may convert
            ## to a vector.  The function is the first element in all
            ## the calls we are interested in.
            ## BDR 2002-11-28
            ## </NOTE>
            if(deparse(e[[1L]])[1L] %in% FF_funs) {
                if(registration) check_registration(e, fr)
                dup <- e[["DUP"]]
                if(!is.null(dup) && !isTRUE(dup))
                    dup_false <<- c(dup_false, e)
                this <- ""
                this <- parg <- e[["PACKAGE"]]
                if (!is.na(pkg) && is.character(parg) &&
                    nzchar(parg) && parg != pkgDLL) {
                    wrong_pkg <<- c(wrong_pkg, e)
                    bad_pkg <<- c(bad_pkg, this)
                }
                parg <- if(!is.null(parg) && any(nzchar(parg))) "OK"
                else if(identical(parg, "")) {
                    empty_exprs <<- c(empty_exprs, e)
                    "EMPTY"
                } else if(!is.character(sym <- e[[2L]])) {
                    if (!registration) {
                        sym <- tryCatch(eval(sym, code_env),
                                        error = function(e) e)
                        if (inherits(sym, "NativeSymbolInfo")) {
                            ## This might be symbol from another package.
                            ## Allow for Rcpp modules
                            parg <- unclass(sym$dll)$name
                            if(length(parg) == 1L &&
                               parg %notin% c("Rcpp", pkgDLL)) {
                                wrong_pkg <<- c(wrong_pkg, e)
                                bad_pkg <<- c(bad_pkg, parg)
                            }
                        }
                    }
                    "Called with symbol"
                } else if(!has_namespace) {
                    bad_exprs <<- c(bad_exprs, e)
                    "MISSING"
                } else "MISSING but in a function in a namespace"
                if(verbose)
                    if(is.null(this))
                        cat(deparse(e[[1L]]), "(", deparse(e[[2L]]),
                            ", ... ): ", parg, "\n", sep = "")
                    else
                        cat(deparse(e[[1L]]), "(", deparse(e[[2L]]),
                            ", ..., PACKAGE = \"", this, "\"): ",
                            parg, "\n", sep = "")
            } else if (deparse(e[[1L]])[1L] %in% "<-") {
                fr <<- c(fr, as.character(e[[2L]]))
            }
            for(i in seq_along(e)) Recall(e[[i]])
        }
    }

    if(!missing(package)) {
        checkFFmy <- function(f)
            if(typeof(f) == "closure") {
                env <- environment(f)
                if(isNamespace(env)) {
                    nm <- getNamespaceName(env)
                    if (nm == package) body(f) else NULL
                } else body(f)
            } # else NULL
        exprs <- lapply(ls(envir = code_env, all.names = TRUE),
                        function(f) checkFFmy(get(f, envir = code_env))) # get is expensive
        if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
            ## Also check the code in S4 methods.
            ## This may find things twice if a setMethod() with a bad FF
            ## call is from inside a function (e.g., InitMethods()).
            for(f in .get_S4_generics(code_env)) {
                mlist <- .get_S4_methods_list(f, code_env)
                exprs <- c(exprs, lapply(mlist, body))
            }
            refs <- .get_ref_classes(code_env)
            if(length(refs)) {
                exprs2 <- lapply(unlist(refs, FALSE), checkFFmy)
                exprs <- c(exprs, exprs2)
            }
        }
    } else {
        if(!is.na(enc) &&
           (Sys.getlocale("LC_CTYPE") %notin% c("C", "POSIX"))) {
            ## FIXME: what if conversion fails on e.g. UTF-8 comments
            con <- file(file, encoding=enc)
            on.exit(close(con))
        } else con <- file
        exprs <-
            tryCatch(parse(file = con, n = -1L),
                     error = function(e)
                     stop(gettextf("parse error in file '%s':\n%s",
                                   file,
                                   .massage_file_parse_error(e)),
                          domain = NA, call. = FALSE))
    }
    for(i in seq_along(exprs)) {
        fr <- character()
        find_bad_exprs(exprs[[i]])
    }
    attr(bad_exprs, "wrong_pkg") <- wrong_pkg
    attr(bad_exprs, "bad_pkg") <- bad_pkg
    attr(bad_exprs, "empty") <- empty_exprs
    attr(bad_exprs, "other_problem") <- other_problem
    attr(bad_exprs, "other_desc") <- other_desc
    if(check_DUP) attr(bad_exprs, "dup_false") <- dup_false
    if (length(bad_pkg)) {              # check against dependencies.
        bases <- .get_standard_package_names()$base
        bad <- bad_pkg %w/o% bases
        if (length(bad)) {
            depends <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Depends")
            imports <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Imports")
            suggests <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Suggests")
            enhances <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Enhances")
            bad <- bad %w/o% c(depends, imports, suggests, enhances)
            attr(bad_exprs, "undeclared") <- bad
        }
    }
    class(bad_exprs) <- "checkFF"
    if(verbose)
        invisible(bad_exprs)
    else
        bad_exprs
}

format.checkFF <-
function(x, ...)
{
    xx <- attr(x, "empty")
    y <- attr(x, "wrong_pkg")
    z <- attr(x, "bad_pkg")
    zz <- attr(x, "undeclared")
    other_problem <- attr(x, "other_problem")

    res <- character()
    if (length(x)) {
        .fmt <- function(x)
            paste0("  ", deparse(x[[1L]]), "(", deparse(x[[2L]]), ", ...)")
        msg <- ngettext(length(x),
                        "Foreign function call without 'PACKAGE' argument:",
                        "Foreign function calls without 'PACKAGE' argument:",
                        domain = NA)
        res <- c(msg, unlist(lapply(x, .fmt)))
    }
    if (length(xx)) {
        .fmt <- function(x)
            paste0("  ", deparse(x[[1L]]), "(", deparse(x[[2L]]), ", ...)")
        msg <- ngettext(length(x),
                        "Foreign function call with empty 'PACKAGE' argument:",
                        "Foreign function calls with empty 'PACKAGE' argument:",
                        domain = NA)
       res <- c(res, msg, unlist(lapply(xx, .fmt)))
    }

    if (length(y)) {
        bases <- .get_standard_package_names()$base
        .fmt2 <- function(x, z) {
            if("PACKAGE" %in% names(x))
                paste0("  ", deparse(x[[1L]]), "(", deparse(x[[2L]]),
                       ", ..., PACKAGE = \"", z, "\")")
            else
                paste0("  ", deparse(x[[1L]]), "(", deparse(x[[2L]]), ", ...)")
        }
        base <- z %in% bases
        if(any(base)) {
            xx <- unlist(lapply(seq_along(y)[base],
                                function(i) .fmt2(y[[i]], z[i])))
            xx <- unique(xx)
            msg <- ngettext(length(xx),
                            "Foreign function call to a base package:",
                            "Foreign function calls to a base package:",
                            domain = NA)
            res <- c(res, msg, sort(xx))
        }
        if(any(!base)) {
            xx <-  unlist(lapply(seq_along(y)[!base],
                                 function(i) .fmt2(y[[i]], z[i])))
            xx <- unique(xx)
            msg <- ngettext(length(xx),
                            "Foreign function call to a different package:",
                            "Foreign function calls to a different package:",
                            domain = NA)
            res <- c(res, msg, sort(xx))
        }
    }
    if (length(zz)) {
        zz <- unique(zz)
        msg <- ngettext(length(zz),
                        "Undeclared package in foreign function calls:",
                        "Undeclared packages in foreign function calls:",
                        domain = NA)
        res <- c(res, msg, paste("  ", paste(sQuote(sort(zz)), collapse = ", ")))
    }
    if (length(other_problem)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(other_problem),
                        "Registration problem:",
                        "Registration problems:",
                        domain = NA)
        res <- c(res, msg)
        other_desc <- attr(x, "other_desc")
        for (i in seq_along(other_problem)) {
            res <- c(res, paste0("  ", other_desc[i], ":"),
                          paste0("   ", deparse(other_problem[[i]])))
        }
    }
    z3 <- attr(x, "dup_false")
     if (length(z3)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(z3),
                        "Call with DUP:",
                        "Calls with DUP:",
                        domain = NA)
        res <- c(res, msg)
        for (i in seq_along(z3)) {
            res <- c(res, paste0("   ", deparse(z3[[i]])))
        }
    }
   res
}

### * checkS3methods

checkS3methods <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Check S3 generics and methods consistency.

    ## Unfortunately, what is an S3 method is not clear.
    ## These days, S3 methods for a generic GEN are found
    ## A. via GEN.CLS lookup from the callenv to its topenv;
    ## B. the S3 registry;
    ## C. GEN.CLS lookup from the parent of the topenv to baseenv,
    ##    skipping everything on the search path between globalenv and
    ##    baseenv.
    ## Thus if "package code" calls GEN, we first look in the package
    ## namespace itself, then in the registry, and then in the package
    ## imports and .BaseNamespaceEnv (and globalenv and baseenv again).
    ##
    ## Clearly, everything registered via S3method() should be an S3
    ## method.  Interestingly, we seem to have some registrations for
    ## non-generics, such as grDevices::axis().  These are "harmless"
    ## but likely not "as intended", and hence inconsistencies are not
    ## ignored.
    ##
    ## If the package namespace has a function named GEN.CLS, it is used
    ## as an S3 method for an S3 generic named GEN (and hence "is an S3
    ## method") only if the package code actually calls GEN (see A
    ## above).  So one could argue that we should not be looking at all
    ## GEN.CLS matches with GEN a generic in the package itself, its
    ## imports or base, but restrict to only the ones where the package
    ## code calls GEN.  Doable, but not straightforward (calls could be
    ## PKG::GEN) and possibly quite time consuming.  For generics from
    ## the package itself or its imports, not restricting should not
    ## make a difference (why define or import when not calling?), but
    ## for generics from base it may: hence we filter out the mismatches
    ## for base GEN not called in the package.
    ##
    ## If a package provides an S3 generic GEN, there is no need to
    ## register GEN.CLS functions for "internal use" (see above).
    ## However, if GEN is exported then likely all GEN.CLS functions
    ## should be registered as S3 methods.  Hence, these cases are now
    ## noted.
    ##
    ## We used to report the apparent S3 methods exported but not
    ## registered (in fact, looking at GEN.CLS matches also for generics
    ## found in the former base packages and the direct strong package
    ## dependencies), controllable via the environment variable
    ## _R_CHECK_S3_METHODS_NOT_REGISTERED_.  Should we continue doing so?
    ## Such functions have not been used for S3 dispatch for several
    ## years now, so it would seem that reporting these functions is no
    ## longer necessary.

    ## Note that checkS3methods(dir = DIR) cannot easily know about
    ## imported generics.  One could try to approximate the imports
    ## based on already loaded or available namespaces imported from,
    ## but that's a lot of effort for very little benefit, so for now we
    ## simply only look for generics in the package and base namespaces
    ## in case we work on the package sources only.

    S3_methods_info <- matrix(character(), 0L, 4L)
    exports <- character()

    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        is_base <- basename(dir) == "base"

        ## Load package into code_env.
        if(!is_base)
            .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))

        code_env <- asNamespace(package)
        if(!is_base) {
            S3_methods_info <- .getNamespaceInfo(code_env, "S3methods")
            exports <- getNamespaceExports(code_env)
        }
    }
    else {
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        is_base <- basename(dir) == "base"

        code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE, parent = .BaseNamespaceEnv)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile))
            .read_description(dfile)
        else
            character()
        .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
        sys_data_file <- file.path(code_dir, "sysdata.rda")
        if(file_test("-f", sys_data_file)) load(sys_data_file, code_env)

        objects_in_code <- sort(names(code_env))

        if(file.exists(file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE")) &&
           ## Code in NAMESPACE could e.g. check the version of one of
           ## its Imports.
           !inherits(tryCatch(nsInfo <-
                                  parseNamespaceFile(basename(dir),
                                                     dirname(dir)),
                              error = identity),
                     "error")) {
            ## Determine exported objects.
            exports <- intersect(objects_in_code, nsInfo$exports)
            for(p in nsInfo$exportPatterns)
                exports <- c(exports,
                             grep(p, objects_in_code, value = TRUE))
            exports <- unique(exports)
            ## Determine S3 methods info.
            S3_methods_info <- .get_namespace_S3_methods_db(nsInfo)
        }
    }

    funs_in_env <- function(env, nms = NULL) {
        if(is.null(nms)) nms <- names(env)
        Filter(function(f) is.function(env[[f]]), nms)
    }

    gens_in_env <- function(env, nms = NULL) {
        if(is.null(nms)) nms <- names(env)
        Filter(function(f) .is_S3_generic(f, env), nms)
    }

    S3_group_generics_env <-
        .make_S3_group_generic_env()
    S3_primitive_generics_env <-
        .make_S3_primitive_generic_env()

    dod <- .predicate_for_calls_with_names(c(".Defunct", ".Deprecated"),
                                           "base")

    nfg <- function(gname, env) {
        ## To correctly get the arguments of a "known" S3 generic, we
        ## must do the following.
        ## First, get the generic (using get0).
        ## If this is NULL and we have one of the group generics, use
        ## the S3_group_generics_env.
        ## If this is not NULL and we have a primitive, use
        ## S3_primitive_generics_env.
        ## Otherwise, if a closure, it could still be the case that we
        ## got the S4 group generics from methods, which for Summary
        ## and Math changes the formals.  So we need to check where we
        ## found the closure.
        gcode <- get0(gname, envir = env, mode = "function")
        if(gname %in% names(S3_group_generics_env)) {
            if(is.null(gcode) ||
               identical(gcode, get0(gname, .BaseNamespaceEnv)))
                gcode <- S3_group_generics_env[[gname]]
        } else if(is.primitive(gcode))
            gcode <- S3_primitive_generics_env[[gname]]
        if(!is.null(gcode))
            names(formals(gcode))
        else
            NULL
    }

    nff <- function(f) names(formals(f))

    one <- function(e) {
        gname <- e[[1L]]
        gargs <- nfg(gname, code_env)
        mname <- sprintf("%s.%s", e[[1L]], e[[2L]])
        mcode <- if(is.character(v <- e[[3L]]))
                     get0(v, envir = code_env)
                 else
                     v
        if(!is.null(mcode) &&
           dod(.get_top_call_in_fun(mcode)))
            mcode <- NULL
        margs <- if(!is.null(mcode)) nff(mcode) else NULL
        list(gname, gargs, mname, margs)
    }

    gen_dot_cls_matches <- function(g, nms) {
        if(length(g) != 1L)
            return(character())
        else
            nms[startsWith(nms, paste0(g, "."))]
    }

    methods_not_registered_with_exported_generic <- g.c <- character()

    functions_in_code <- funs_in_env(code_env)

    generics_in_base <- unique(c(gens_in_env(.BaseNamespaceEnv),
                                 names(S3_group_generics_env),
                                 names(S3_primitive_generics_env),
                                 .get_internal_S3_generics()))
    ## Alternatively, can do
    ##   generics_in_base <- .get_S3_generics_in_base()
    ## but we need the S3 group and primitive generics envs anyway.

    if(is_base) {
        generics <- generics_in_code <- generics_in_base
    } else {
        generics_in_code <- gens_in_env(code_env)
        generics <- c(generics_in_code,
                      ## Generics from imports
                      if(!missing(package))
                          setdiff(gens_in_env(parent.env(code_env)),
                                  functions_in_code),
                      ## Generics from base
                      setdiff(generics_in_base,
                              c(functions_in_code,
                                funs_in_env(parent.env(code_env)))))
    }

    nsm <- nonS3methods(basename(dir))
    gnm <- lapply(generics,
                  function(g) {
                      methods <-
                          gen_dot_cls_matches(g, functions_in_code)
                      if((n <- length(methods)) > 0L) {
                          gargs <- nfg(g, code_env)
                          entries <-
                              lapply(methods,
                                     function(m) {
                                         mcode <- code_env[[m]]
                                         margs <-
                                             if(dod(.get_top_call_in_fun(mcode)))
                                                 NULL
                                             else
                                                 nff(mcode)
                                         list(g, gargs, m, margs)
                                     })
                          names(entries) <- methods
                          entries
                      } else NULL
                  })
    gnm <- do.call(c, gnm)
    gnm <- gnm[setdiff(names(gnm), nsm)]

    if(!is_base) {
        g.c <- sprintf("%s.%s",
                       S3_methods_info[, 1L],
                       S3_methods_info[, 2L])
        ## Record apparent S3 methods not registered for exported
        ## generics.
        ind <- (vapply(gnm, `[[`, "", 1L) %in%
                intersect(generics_in_code, exports))
        methods_not_registered_with_exported_generic <-
            setdiff(names(gnm)[ind], c(g.c, nsm))
        ## Add additional generics and methods from the registry.
        S3_methods_info <-
            S3_methods_info[!(g.c %in% names(gnm)), ,
                            drop = FALSE]
        ## Cannot easily handle delayed registration.
        S3_methods_info <-
            S3_methods_info[is.na(as.character(S3_methods_info[, 4L])), ,
                            drop = FALSE]
        if(NROW(S3_methods_info)) {
            add <- apply(S3_methods_info, 1L, one, simplify = FALSE)
            names(add) <- vapply(add, `[[`, "", 3L)
            gnm <- c(gnm, add)
        }
    }

    check_args <- function(gName, gArgs, mName, mArgs) {
        ## Drop the ones where gArgs is NULL (presumably the language
        ## elements) or mArgs is NULL (a primitive?).
        if(is.null(gArgs) || is.null(mArgs)) return()
        ## handle round.POSIXt and packages defining methods for round()
        ## without a ... argument.
        if(gName == "round" && length(mArgs) >= 1 && mArgs[[1]] == "x") return()
        if(gName == "plot") gArgs <- gArgs[-2L] # drop "y"
        ## FIXME: not quite right, could be another plot generic ...
        ogArgs <- gArgs
        omArgs <- mArgs
        ## If m is a formula method, its first argument *may* be called
        ## formula.  (Note that any argument name mismatch throws an
        ## error in current S-PLUS versions.)
        if(endsWith(mName, ".formula")) {
            if(gArgs[1L] != "...") gArgs <- gArgs[-1L]
            if(mArgs[1L] != "...") mArgs <- mArgs[-1L]
        }
        dotsPos <- which(gArgs == "...")
        ipos <- if(length(dotsPos))
            seq_len(dotsPos[1L] - 1L)
        else
            seq_along(gArgs)
        ## careful, this could match multiply in incorrect funs.
        dotsPos <- which(mArgs == "...")
        if(length(dotsPos))
            ipos <- ipos[seq_len(dotsPos[1L] - 1L)]
        posMatchOK <- identical(gArgs[ipos], mArgs[ipos])
        argMatchOK <- all(gArgs %in% mArgs) || length(dotsPos) > 0L
        margMatchOK <- all(mArgs %in% c("...", gArgs)) || "..." %in% ogArgs
        if(posMatchOK && argMatchOK && margMatchOK)
            NULL
        else if (gName %in% c("+", "-", "*", "/", "^", "%%", "%/%", "&", "|",
                              "!", "==", "!=", "<", "<=", ">=", ">")
                 && (length(ogArgs) == length(omArgs)) )
            NULL
        else {
            l <- list(ogArgs, omArgs)
            names(l) <- c(gName, mName)
            l
        }
    }

    bad_methods <- Filter(length,
                          lapply(gnm,
                                 function(e)
                                     do.call(check_args, e)))
    if(length(bad_methods) && !is_base) {
        ## For now, split out the mismatches for GEN.CLS functions not
        ## registered as methods, split according to GEN a generic in
        ## the package or not, and the mismatches for methods registered
        ## for a non-generic.
        gen <- vapply(bad_methods, function(e) names(e)[1L], "")
        ## Not registered.
        i1 <- !(names(bad_methods) %in% g.c)
        ## Generic not generic?  One can register an S3 method for an S4
        ## generic.
        if(any(i3 <- i1 & (gen %in% generics_in_base))) {
            ## Check whether the base generics are actually called.
            ## Note that these things are hard to find out: we check for
            ## calls to names of base generics, but these could be local
            ## functions ...
            p3 <- which(i3)
            gennames <- intersect(gen, generics_in_base)
            predicate <- .predicate_for_calls_with_names(gennames,
                                                         "base")
            calls <- lapply(code_env, .find_calls, predicate,
                            recursive = TRUE)
            used <- (gen[p3] %in% unique(.call_names(unlist(calls))))
            if(!all(used)) {
                keep <- - p3[!used]
                bad_methods <- bad_methods[keep]
                gen <- gen[keep]
                i1 <- i1[keep]
            }
        }
        i2 <- !(gen %in% generics)
        if(any(i2) && .isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
            p2 <- which(i2)
            i2[p2] <- ! vapply(gen[p2],
                               function(g) {
                                   gcode <- get0(g, code_env)
                                   if(is.null(gcode))
                                       FALSE
                                   else
                                       methods::is(gcode,
                                                   "genericFunction")
                               },
                               NA)
        }
        if(any(i1) || any(i2)) {
            i3 <- (gen %in% generics_in_code)
            bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_in_code <-
                bad_methods[i1 & i3]
            bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_not_in_code <-
                bad_methods[i1 & !i3]
            bad_methods_registered_for_non_generic <-
                bad_methods[i2]
            bad_methods <- bad_methods[!i1 & !i2]
            if(length(bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_in_code))
                attr(bad_methods,
                     "bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_in_code") <-
                    bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_in_code
            if(length(bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_not_in_code))
                attr(bad_methods,
                     "bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_not_in_code") <-
                    bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_not_in_code
            if(length(bad_methods_registered_for_non_generic))
                attr(bad_methods,
                     "bad_methods_registered_for_non_generic") <-
                    bad_methods_registered_for_non_generic
        }
    }

    if(length(methods_not_registered_with_exported_generic))
        attr(bad_methods, "methods_not_registered_with_exported_generic") <-
            methods_not_registered_with_exported_generic

    class(bad_methods) <- "checkS3methods"
    bad_methods
}

format.checkS3methods <-
function(x, ...)
{
    .fmt_args <- function(s)
        paste0("function(", paste(s, collapse = ", "), ")")

    .fmt_bad_one <- function(e) {
        paste(c(paste0(names(e)[1L], ":"),
                strwrap(.fmt_args(e[[1L]]), indent = 2L, exdent = 11L),
                paste0(names(e)[2L], ":"),
                strwrap(.fmt_args(e[[2L]]), indent = 2L, exdent = 11L)),
              collapse = "\n")
    }

    .fmt_bad_all <- function(x) {
        if(!length(x)) return(character())
        paste(vapply(x, .fmt_bad_one, ""), collapse = "\n\n")
    }

    show_possible_issues <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_S3_METHODS_SHOW_POSSIBLE_ISSUES_",
                                         "FALSE"))

    s <- .fmt_bad_all(x)
    if(show_possible_issues)
        s <- c(s,
               if(length(bad <- c(attr(x,
                                       "bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_in_code"),
                                  attr(x,
                                       "bad_methods_not_registered_with_generic_not_in_code"))))
                   paste0("Mismatches for apparent methods not registered:\n",
                          .fmt_bad_all(bad)),
               if(length(bad <- attr(x,
                                     "bad_methods_registered_for_non_generic")))
                   paste0("Mismatches for methods registered for non-generic:\n",
                          .fmt_bad_all(bad)),
               if(length(met <- attr(x,
                                     "methods_not_registered_with_exported_generic")))
                   paste0("Apparent methods for exported generics not registered:\n",
                          paste(strwrap(paste(sort(met), collapse = " "),
                                        exdent = 2L, indent = 2L),
                                collapse = "\n")))
    if(length(s))
        paste(s, collapse = "\n\n")
    else
        character()
}

### * checkReplaceFuns

checkReplaceFuns <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ns_S3_methods_db <- NULL

    ## Argument handling.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        is_base <- basename(dir) == "base"

        ## Load package into code_env.
        if(!is_base)
            .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
        code_env <- asNamespace(package)

        if(!is_base)
            ns_S3_methods_db <- .getNamespaceInfo(code_env, "S3methods")
    } else { # missing(package)
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        is_base <- basename(dir) == "base"

        code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile))
            .read_description(dfile)
        else
            character()
        .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
        sys_data_file <- file.path(code_dir, "sysdata.rda")
        if(file_test("-f", sys_data_file)) load(sys_data_file, code_env)

        ## Does the package have a NAMESPACE file?
        if(file.exists(file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE")) &&
           !inherits(tryCatch(nsInfo <-
                                  parseNamespaceFile(basename(dir),
                                                     dirname(dir)),
                              error = identity),
                     "error")) {
            ns_S3_methods_db <- .get_namespace_S3_methods_db(nsInfo)
        }
    }

    objects_in_code <- sort(names(code_env))
    replace_funs <- character()

    if(!is.null(ns_S3_methods_db)) {
        ns_S3_generics <- as.character(ns_S3_methods_db[, 1L])
        ns_S3_methods <- ns_S3_methods_db[, 3L]
        if(has_S3_fun_obj <- !is.character(ns_S3_methods)) {
            ## registerS3method() may have registered a function object (not name), e.g. in S7
            nonCh <- !vapply(ns_S3_methods, is.character, NA)
            ## keep these to check for <last argument name> == 'value', below:
            S3_fun_obj <- ns_S3_methods[nonCh]
            ns_S3_methods[nonCh] <- ""
            ns_S3_methods <- as.character(ns_S3_methods)
        }
        ## S3 replacement methods from namespace registration?
        replace_funs <- ns_S3_methods[ns_S3_genRepl <- endsWith(ns_S3_generics, "<-")]
        ## Now remove the functions registered as S3 methods.
        objects_in_code <- setdiff(objects_in_code, ns_S3_methods)
    } else
        has_S3_fun_obj <- FALSE

    replace_funs <-
        c(replace_funs, grep("<-$", objects_in_code, value = TRUE))
    ## Drop %xxx% binops.
    ## Spotted by Hugh Parsonage <hugh.parsonage@gmail.com>.
    replace_funs <-
        replace_funs[!(startsWith(replace_funs, "%") &
                       endsWith  (replace_funs, "%"))]

    .check_last_formal_arg <- function(f) {
        arg_names <- names(formals(f))
        if(!length(arg_names))
            TRUE                        # most likely a .Primitive()
        else
            identical(arg_names[length(arg_names)], "value")
    }

    ## Find the replacement functions (which have formal arguments) with
    ## last arg not named 'value'.
    bad_replace_funs <- if(length(replace_funs)) {
        Filter(function(f) nzchar(f) && {
                   ## Always get the functions from code_env ...
                   ## Should maybe get S3 methods from the registry ...
                   f <- get(f, envir = code_env)  # get is expensive
                   is.function(f) && ! .check_last_formal_arg(f)
               },
               replace_funs)
    } else character()

    if(has_S3_fun_obj) {
        ## S3 replacement generic/methods
        isRepl <- ns_S3_genRepl[nonCh]
        if(any(isRepl) && any(bad_last <- !vapply(S3_fun_obj[isRepl], .check_last_formal_arg, NA)))
            bad_replace_funs <-
                c(bad_replace_funs, sprintf("\\S3method{%s}{%s}",
                                            ns_S3_generics  [nonCh]    [isRepl][bad_last],
                                            ns_S3_methods_db[nonCh, 2L][isRepl][bad_last]))
    }
    if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
        S4_generics <- .get_S4_generics(code_env)
        ## Assume that the ones with names ending in '<-' are always
        ## replacement functions.
        S4_generics <- S4_generics[endsWith(names(S4_generics), "<-")]
        bad_S4_replace_methods <-
            lapply(S4_generics,
                   function(f) {
                       mlist <- .get_S4_methods_list(f, code_env)
                       ind <- !vapply(mlist, .check_last_formal_arg, NA)
                       if(!any(ind))
                           character()
                       else {
                           sigs <- .make_siglist(mlist[ind])
                           sprintf("\\S4method{%s}{%s}", f, sigs)
                       }
                   })
        bad_replace_funs <-
            c(bad_replace_funs,
              unlist(bad_S4_replace_methods, use.names = FALSE))
    }

    class(bad_replace_funs) <- "checkReplaceFuns"
    bad_replace_funs
}

format.checkReplaceFuns <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(length(x))
        .pretty_format(unclass(x))
    else
        character()
}

### * checkTnF

checkTnF <-
function(package, dir, file, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    code_files <- docs_files <- character()

    ## Argument handling.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        if(file.exists(file.path(dir, "R", "all.rda"))) {
            warning("cannot check R code installed as image")
        }
        code_file <- file.path(dir, "R", package)
        if(file.exists(code_file))      # could be data-only
            code_files <- code_file
        example_dir <- file.path(dir, "R-ex")
        if(dir.exists(example_dir)) {
            code_files <- c(code_files,
                            list_files_with_exts(example_dir, "R"))
        }
    }
    else if(!missing(dir)) {
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(dir.exists(code_dir))   # could be data-only
            code_files <- list_files_with_type(code_dir, "code")
        docs_dir <- file.path(dir, "man")
        if(dir.exists(docs_dir))
            docs_files <- list_files_with_type(docs_dir, "docs")
    }
    else if(!missing(file)) {
        if(!file_test("-f", file))
            stop(gettextf("file '%s' does not exist", file),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            code_files <- file
    }
    else
        stop("you must specify 'package', 'dir' or 'file'")

    find_TnF_in_code <- function(file, txt) {
        ## If 'txt' is given, it contains the extracted examples from
        ## the R documentation file 'file'.  Otherwise, 'file' gives a
        ## file with (just) R code.
        matches <- list()
        TnF <- c("T", "F")
        find_bad_exprs <- function(e, p) {
            if(is.name(e)
               && (as.character(e) %in% TnF)
               && !is.null(p)) {
                ## Need the 'list()' to deal with T/F in function
                ## arglists which are pairlists ...
                matches <<- c(matches, list(p))
            }
            else if(is.recursive(e)) {
                for(i in seq_along(e)) Recall(e[[i]], e)
            }
        }
        exprs <- if(missing(txt))
            tryCatch(parse(file = file, n = -1L),
                     error = function(e)
                     stop(gettextf("parse error in file '%s':\n%s",
                                   file,
                                   .massage_file_parse_error(e)),
                          domain = NA, call. = FALSE))
        else
            tryCatch(str2expression(txt),
                     error = function(e)
                     stop(gettextf("parse error in examples from file '%s':\n%s",
                                   file, conditionMessage(e)),
                          domain = NA, call. = FALSE))
        for(i in seq_along(exprs))
            find_bad_exprs(exprs[[i]], NULL)
        matches
    }

    bad_exprs <- list()
    for(file in code_files) {
        exprs <- find_TnF_in_code(file)
        if(length(exprs)) {
            exprs <- list(exprs)
            names(exprs) <- file
            bad_exprs <- c(bad_exprs, exprs)
        }
    }
    for(file in docs_files) {
        Rd <- prepare_Rd(file, defines = .Platform$OS.type)
        txt <- .Rd_get_example_code(Rd)
        exprs <- find_TnF_in_code(file, txt)
        if(length(exprs)) {
            exprs <- list(exprs)
            names(exprs) <- file
            bad_exprs <- c(bad_exprs, exprs)
        }
    }
    class(bad_exprs) <- "checkTnF"
    bad_exprs
}

format.checkTnF <-
function(x, ...)
{
    .fmt <- function(fname) {
        xfname <- x[[fname]]
        c(gettextf("File '%s':", fname),
          unlist(lapply(seq_along(xfname),
                        function(i) {
                            strwrap(gettextf("found T/F in %s",
                                             paste(deparse(xfname[[i]]),
                                                   collapse = "")),
                                    exdent = 4L)
                        })),
          "")
    }

    as.character(unlist(lapply(names(x), .fmt)))
}

### * .check_package_depends

## changed in 2.3.0 to refer to a source dir.

.check_package_depends <-
function(dir, force_suggests = TRUE, check_incoming = FALSE,
         ignore_vignettes = FALSE)
{
    .check_dependency_cycles <-
        function(db, available = utils::available.packages(),
                 dependencies = c("Depends", "Imports", "LinkingTo"))
        {
            ## given a package, find its recursive dependencies.
            ## We want the dependencies of the current package,
            ## not of a version on the repository.
##            pkg <- db[["Package"]]
            this <- db[dependencies]; names(this) <- dependencies
            ## FIXME: .extract_dependency_package_names
            known <- utils:::.clean_up_dependencies(this)
            info <- available[, dependencies, drop = FALSE]
            rn <- rownames(info)
            deps <- function(p) {
                if(p %notin% rn) return(character())
                ## FIXME: .extract_dependency_package_names
                utils:::.clean_up_dependencies(info[p, ])
            }
            extra <- known
            repeat {
                extra <- unlist(lapply(extra, deps))
                extra <- setdiff(extra, known)
                if(!length(extra)) break
                known <- c(known, extra)
            }
            known
        }

    if(length(dir) != 1L)
        stop("The package 'dir' argument must be of length 1")

    ## We definitely need a valid DESCRIPTION file.
    db <- .read_description(file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION"))

    dir_name <- basename(dir)
    package_name <- db["Package"]
    if(!identical(package_name, dir_name) &&
       (!is.character(package_name) || !nzchar(package_name))) {
        message(sprintf(
            "package name '%s' seems invalid; using directory name '%s' instead",
            package_name, dir_name))
        package_name <- dir_name
    }

    bad_depends <- list()
    ## and we cannot have cycles
    ## this check needs a package db from repository(s), so
    repos <- getOption("repos")
    if(any(repos == "@CRAN@"))
        repos <- .get_standard_repository_URLs()
    if(length(repos)) {
        available <- utils::available.packages(repos = repos)
        ad <- .check_dependency_cycles(db, available)
        pkgname <- db[["Package"]]
        if(pkgname %in% ad)
            bad_depends$all_depends <- setdiff(ad, pkgname)
    } else if (check_incoming)
        bad_depends$skipped <-
            "  No repository set, so cyclic dependency check skipped"

    ldepends <-  .get_requires_with_version_from_package_db(db, "Depends")
    limports <-  .get_requires_with_version_from_package_db(db, "Imports")
    llinks <-  .get_requires_with_version_from_package_db(db, "LinkingTo")
    lsuggests <- .get_requires_with_version_from_package_db(db, "Suggests")
    ## NB: no one checks version for 'Enhances'.
    lenhances <- .get_requires_with_version_from_package_db(db, "Enhances")
    ## VignetteBuilder packages are needed to ascertain what is a vignette.
    VB <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "VignetteBuilder")

    depends <- vapply(ldepends, `[[`, "", 1L)
    imports <- vapply(limports, `[[`, "", 1L)
    links <- vapply(llinks, `[[`, "", 1L)
    suggests <- vapply(lsuggests, `[[`, "", 1L)

    standard_package_names <- .get_standard_package_names()

    ## Are all packages listed in Depends/Suggests/Imports/LinkingTo installed?
    lreqs <- c(ldepends, limports, llinks,
               if(force_suggests) lsuggests)
    lreqs2 <- c(if(!force_suggests) lsuggests, lenhances)
    if(length(c(lreqs, lreqs2))) {
        ## Do this directly for speed.
        installed <- character()
        installed_in <- character()
        for(lib in .libPaths()) {
            pkgs <- list.files(lib)
            pkgs <- pkgs[file.access(file.path(lib, pkgs, "DESCRIPTION"), 4) == 0]
            installed <- c(installed, pkgs)
            installed_in <- c(installed_in, rep.int(lib, length(pkgs)))
        }
        if (length(lreqs)) {
            reqs <- unique(vapply(lreqs, `[[`, "", 1L))
            bad <- setdiff(reqs, installed)
            if(length(bad)) {
                ## EDanalysis has a package in all of Depends, Imports, Suggests.
                bad1 <-  bad[bad %in% c(depends, imports, links)]
                if(length(bad1))
                    bad_depends$required_but_not_installed <- bad1
                bad2 <-  setdiff(bad, bad1)
                if(length(bad2))
                    bad_depends$suggested_but_not_installed <- bad2
            }
            ## now check versions
            have_ver <- vapply(lreqs, function(x) length(x) == 3L, NA)
            lreqs3 <- lreqs[have_ver]
            if(length(lreqs3)) {
                bad <- character()
                for (r in lreqs3) {
                    pkg <- r[[1L]]
                    op <- r[[2L]]
                    where <- which(installed == pkg)
                    if(!length(where)) next
                    ## want the first one
                    desc <- readRDS(file.path(installed_in[where[1L]], pkg,
                                              "Meta", "package.rds"))
                    current <- desc$DESCRIPTION["Version"]
                    target <- as.package_version(r[[3L]])
                    if(!do.call(op, list(current, target)))
                        bad <- c(bad, pkg)
                }
                if(length(bad))
                    bad_depends$required_but_obsolete <- bad
            }
        }
        if (length(lenhances) &&
            !config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_PACKAGE_DEPENDS_IGNORE_MISSING_ENHANCES_",
                                             "FALSE"))) {
            m <- setdiff(vapply(lenhances, `[[`, "", 1L), installed)
            if(length(m))
                bad_depends$enhances_but_not_installed <- m
        }
        if (!force_suggests && length(lsuggests)) {
            m <- setdiff(vapply(lsuggests, `[[`, "", 1L), installed)
            if(length(m))
                bad_depends$suggests_but_not_installed <- m
        }
        if (!ignore_vignettes && length(VB)) {
            ## These need both to be declared and installed
            ## If people explicitly state 'utils' they ought really to
            ## declare it, but skip for now.
            bad <- VB %w/o% c(package_name, "utils", depends, imports, suggests)
            if(length(bad))
                bad_depends$required_for_checking_but_not_declared <- bad
            bad2 <- VB %w/o% c(package_name, installed)
            bad2 <- setdiff(bad2, bad)
            if(length(bad2))
                bad_depends$required_for_checking_but_not_installed <- bad2
            if (length(VB) && !dir.exists(file.path(dir, "vignettes")))
                bad_depends$no_vignettes <- VB
        }
    }
    ## FIXME: is this still needed now we do dependency analysis?
    ## Are all vignette dependencies at least suggested or equal to
    ## the package name?

    ## This is a check for old-location vignettes.
    ## If the package itself is the VignetteBuilder,
    ## we may not have installed it yet.
    defer <- package_name %in%  db["VignetteBuilder"]
    vigns <-
        .package_vignettes_via_call_to_R(dir = dir,
                                         subdirs = file.path("inst", "doc"),
                                         check = !defer)

    if(length(vigns$msg))
        bad_depends$bad_engine <- vigns$msg
    if (!is.null(vigns) && length(vigns$docs) > 0L) {
        reqs <- unique(unlist(.build_vignette_index(vigns)$Depends))
        ## For the time being, ignore base packages missing from the
        ## DESCRIPTION dependencies even if explicitly given as vignette
        ## dependencies.
        reqs <- setdiff(reqs,
                        c(depends, imports, suggests, package_name,
                          standard_package_names$base))
        if(length(reqs))
            bad_depends$missing_vignette_depends <- reqs
    }

    ## Are all namespace dependencies listed as package dependencies?
    if(file_test("-f", file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE"))) {
        reqs <- .get_namespace_package_depends(dir)
        ## <FIXME>
        ## Not clear whether we want to require *all* namespace package
        ## dependencies listed in DESCRIPTION, or e.g. just the ones on
        ## non-base packages.  Do the latter for time being ...
        ## Actually we need to know at least about S4-using packages,
        ## since we need to reinstall if those change.
        allowed_imports <-
            setdiff(standard_package_names$base, c("methods", "stats4"))
        reqs <- setdiff(reqs, c(imports, depends, allowed_imports))
        if(length(reqs))
            bad_depends$missing_namespace_depends <- reqs
    }

    ## Check for excessive 'Depends'
    deps <- setdiff(depends, c("R", "base", "datasets", "grDevices",
                               "graphics", "methods", "utils", "stats"))
    if(length(deps) > 5L) bad_depends$many_depends <- deps

    ## and Imports
    lim <- as.integer(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_EXCESSIVE_IMPORTS_", "0"))
    imps <- setdiff(imports, standard_package_names$base)
    if(!is.na(lim) && lim > 0 && length(imps) > lim)
        bad_depends$many_imports <- imps

    ## check header-only packages
    if (check_incoming) {
        hdOnly <- c("BH", "RcppArmadillo", "RcppEigen")
        hd <- setdiff(intersect(hdOnly, c(depends, imports)),
                      .get_namespace_package_depends(dir, TRUE))
        if(length(hd)) bad_depends$hdOnly <- hd
    }

    ## Check RdMacros.
    RM <- setdiff(.get_requires_from_package_db(db, "RdMacros"),
                  c(imports, depends))
    if(length(RM)) bad_depends$missing_rdmacros_depends <- RM

    ## (added in 4.0.0) Check for orphaned packages.
    if (config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_ORPHANED_", "FALSE"))) {
        ## empty fields are list().
        strict <- setdiff(unique(c(as.character(depends),
                                   as.character(imports),
                                   as.character(links))),
                           bad_depends$required_but_not_installed)

        ## (4.1.0) This needs to be recursive, since a package
        ## strictly depends on everything required to load it.
        ## All of those should be installed, so we only look at those which are.
        ## We include LinkingTo as if a dependency links to an
        ## orphaned package, it becomes uninstallable if the linked-to
        ## package is, or if it is removed.
        dependencies <- .expand_dependency_type_spec("strong")
        ipd <- utils:::.installed_package_dependencies
        new <- strict0 <- strict
        ex <- character()
        repeat {
            need <- unname(unlist(ipd(new, dependencies)))
            new <- setdiff(need, c(strict, ex))
            if(!length(new)) break
            strict <- union(strict, new)
        }

        ## First use dependencies which are installed: strict dependencies
        ## need to be for a full check.
        ## Suggests might not even exist, so we suppress warnings.
        mt <- function(x) suppressWarnings(utils::maintainer(x))
        strict2 <- vapply(strict, mt, "")
        miss1 <- is.na(strict2)
        weak <- setdiff(as.character(suggests),
                        bad_depends$suggested_but_not_installed)
        weak2 <- vapply(weak, mt, "")
        miss2 <- is.na(weak2)
        if((any(miss1) || any(miss2)) &&
           !inherits(tryCatch(db <- CRAN_package_db()[, c("Package",
                                                          "Maintainer")],
                              ## This may not be local and needs a
                              ## complete CRAN mirror.
                              error = identity),
                     "error")) {
            orphaned <- db[db$Maintainer == "ORPHANED" , 1L]
            s2 <- intersect(strict[miss1], orphaned)
            w2 <- intersect(weak[miss2], orphaned)
        } else s2 <- w2 <- character()
        strict <- c(strict[!miss1 & strict2 == "ORPHANED"], s2)
        if(length(strict)) {
            strict0 <- sort(intersect(strict, strict0))
            strict1 <- sort(setdiff(strict, strict0))
            if(length(strict0)) bad_depends$orphaned <- strict0
            if(length(strict1)) bad_depends$orphaned1 <- strict1
        }
        weak <- c(weak[!miss2 & weak2 == "ORPHANED"], w2)
        if(length(weak)) bad_depends$orphaned2 <- sort(weak)
    }

    class(bad_depends) <- "check_package_depends"
    bad_depends
}

format.check_package_depends <-
function(x, ...)
{
    c(character(),
      if(length(x$skipped)) c(x$skipped, ""),
      if(length(x$all_depends)) {
          c("There is circular dependency in the installation order:",
            .pretty_format2("  One or more packages in", x$all_depends),
            "  depend on this package (for the versions on the repositories).",
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$required_but_not_installed) > 1L) {
          c(.pretty_format2("Packages required but not available:", bad), "")
      } else if(length(bad)) {
          c(sprintf("Package required but not available: %s", sQuote(bad)), "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$suggested_but_not_installed) > 1L) {
          c(.pretty_format2("Packages suggested but not available:", bad), "")
      } else if(length(bad)) {
          c(sprintf("Package suggested but not available: %s", sQuote(bad)), "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$required_but_obsolete) > 1L) {
          c(.pretty_format2("Packages required and available but unsuitable versions:",
                            bad),
            "")
      } else if(length(bad)) {
          c(sprintf("Package required and available but unsuitable version: %s", sQuote(bad)),
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$suggests_but_not_installed) > 1L) {
          c(.pretty_format2("Packages suggested but not available for checking:",
                            bad),
            "")
      } else if(length(bad)) {
          c(sprintf("Package suggested but not available for checking: %s",
                     sQuote(bad)),
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$enhances_but_not_installed) > 1L) {
          c(.pretty_format2("Packages which this enhances but not available for checking:",
                            bad),
            "")
      } else if(length(bad)) {
          c(sprintf("Package which this enhances but not available for checking: %s", sQuote(bad)),
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$required_for_checking_but_not_declared) > 1L) {
          c(.pretty_format2("VignetteBuilder packages not declared:", bad), "")
      } else if(length(bad)) {
          c(sprintf("VignetteBuilder package not declared: %s", sQuote(bad)), "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$required_for_checking_but_not_installed) > 1L) {
          c(.pretty_format2("VignetteBuilder packages required for checking but not installed:", bad), "")
      } else if(length(bad)) {
          c(sprintf("VignetteBuilder package required for checking but not installed: %s", sQuote(bad)), "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$missing_vignette_depends)) {
          c(if(length(bad) > 1L) {
                c("Vignette dependencies not required:", .pretty_format(bad))
            } else {
                sprintf("Vignette dependency not required: %s", sQuote(bad))
            },
            strwrap(gettextf("Vignette dependencies (%s entries) must be contained in the DESCRIPTION Depends/Suggests/Imports entries.",
                             "\\VignetteDepends{}")),
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$no_vignettes)) {
          c(if(length(bad) > 1L) {
                c("Vignette dependencies required without any vignettes:", .pretty_format(bad))
            } else {
                sprintf("Vignette dependency required without any vignettes: %s", sQuote(bad))
            },
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$missing_rdmacros_depends)) {
          c(if(length(bad) > 1L)
                .pretty_format2("RdMacros packages not required:", bad)
            else
                sprintf("RdMacros package not required: %s", sQuote(bad)),
            strwrap("RdMacros packages must be contained in the DESCRIPTION Imports/Depends entries."),
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$missing_namespace_depends)) {
          error_str <- "missing from DESCRIPTION Imports/Depends entries:"
          c(if(length(bad) > 1L)
                .pretty_format2(paste("Namespace dependencies", error_str), bad)
            else
                sprintf("Namespace dependency %s %s", error_str, sQuote(bad)),
          "")
      },
      if(length(y <- x$many_depends)) {
          c(.pretty_format2("Depends: includes the non-default packages:", y),
            strwrap(paste("Adding so many packages to the search path",
                          "is excessive",
                          "and importing selectively is preferable."
                          , collapse = ", ")),
            "")
      },
      if(ly <- length(x$many_imports)) {
          c(sprintf("Imports includes %d non-default packages.", ly),
            strwrap(paste("Importing from so many packages",
                          "makes the package vulnerable to any of them",
                          "becoming unavailable.  Move as many as possible to",
                          "Suggests and use conditionally."
                          , collapse = ", ")),
            "")
      },
      if(length(y <- x$bad_engine)) {
          c(y, "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$hdOnly)) {
          c(if(length(bad) > 1L)
            c("Packages in Depends/Imports which should probably only be in LinkingTo:", .pretty_format(bad))
          else
            sprintf("Package in Depends/Imports which should probably only be in LinkingTo: %s", sQuote(bad)),
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x[["orphaned"]])) {
          c(if(length(bad) > 1L)
            c("Requires orphaned packages:", .pretty_format(bad))
          else
            sprintf("Requires orphaned package: %s", sQuote(bad)),
          "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x[["orphaned1"]])) {
          c(if(length(bad) > 1L)
            c("Requires (indirectly) orphaned packages:", .pretty_format(bad))
          else
            sprintf("Requires (indirectly) orphaned package: %s", sQuote(bad)),
            "")
      },
      if(length(bad <- x[["orphaned2"]])) {
          c(if(length(bad) > 1L)
            c("Suggests orphaned packages:", .pretty_format(bad))
          else
            sprintf("Suggests orphaned package: %s", sQuote(bad)),
            "")
      }
      )
}

### * .check_package_description

.check_package_description <-
function(dfile, strict = FALSE, db = NULL)
{
    if(is.null(db)) {
        dfile <- file_path_as_absolute(dfile)
        db <- .read_description(dfile)
    }

    standard_package_names <- .get_standard_package_names()

    valid_package_name_regexp <-
        .standard_regexps()$valid_package_name
    valid_package_version_regexp <-
        .standard_regexps()$valid_package_version

    is_base_package <-
        !is.na(priority <- db["Priority"]) && priority == "base"

    out <- list()                       # For the time being ...

    ## Check encoding-related things first.

    ## All field tags must be ASCII.
    if(any(ind <- !.is_ASCII(names(db))))
        out$fields_with_non_ASCII_tags <- names(db)[ind]
    ## For all fields used by the R package management system, values
    ## must be ASCII as well (so that the RPM works in a C locale).
    ASCII_fields <- c(.get_standard_repository_db_fields(),
                      "Encoding", "License")
    ASCII_fields <- intersect(ASCII_fields, names(db))
    if(any(ind <- !.is_ASCII(db[ASCII_fields])))
        out$fields_with_non_ASCII_values <- ASCII_fields[ind]

    ## Determine encoding and re-encode if necessary and possible.
    if("Encoding" %in% names(db)) {
        encoding <- db["Encoding"]
        if(Sys.getlocale("LC_CTYPE") %notin% c("C", "POSIX"))
            db <- iconv(db, encoding, sub = "byte")
    }
    else if(!all(.is_ISO_8859(db))) {
        ## No valid Encoding metadata.
        ## Determine whether we can assume Latin1.
        out$missing_encoding <- TRUE
    }

    if(anyNA(nchar(db, "c", TRUE))) {
        ## Ouch, invalid in the current locale.
        ## (Can only happen in a MBCS locale.)
        ## Try re-encoding from Latin1.
        db <- iconv(db, "latin1")
    }

    ## Check Authors@R and expansion if needed.
    if(!is.na(aar <- db["Authors@R"]) &&
       (is.na(db["Author"]) || is.na(db["Maintainer"]))) {
        res <- .check_package_description_authors_at_R_field(aar)
        if(is.na(db["Author"]) &&
           !is.null(s <- attr(res, "Author")))
            db["Author"] <- s
        if(is.na(db["Maintainer"]) &&
           !is.null(s <- attr(res, "Maintainer")))
            db["Maintainer"] <- s
        mostattributes(res) <- NULL     # Keep names.
        out <- c(out, res)
    }

    val <- package_name <- db["Package"]
    if(!is.na(val)) {
        tmp <- character()
        ## We allow 'R', which is not a valid package name.
        if(!grepl(sprintf("^(R|%s)$", valid_package_name_regexp), val))
            tmp <- c(tmp, gettext("Malformed package name"))
        if(!is_base_package && val %in% standard_package_names$base) {
            tmp <- c(tmp,
                     c("Invalid package name.",
                       "This is the name of a base package."))
        }
        if(length(tmp))
            out$bad_package <- tmp
    }
    if(!is.na(val <- db["Version"])
       && !is_base_package
       && !grepl(sprintf("^%s$", valid_package_version_regexp), val))
        out$bad_version <- val
    if(!is.na(val <- db["Maintainer"])
       && !grepl(.valid_maintainer_field_regexp, val))
        out$bad_maintainer <- val

    ## Optional entries in DESCRIPTION:
    ##   Depends/Suggests/Imports/Enhances, Namespace, Priority.
    ## These must be correct if present.

    val <- db[match(c("Depends", "Suggests", "Imports", "Enhances"),
                    names(db), nomatch = 0L)]
    if(length(val)) {
        depends <- trimws(unlist(strsplit(val, ",")))
        bad_dep_entry <- bad_dep_op <- bad_dep_version <- character()
        dep_regexp <-
            paste0("^[[:space:]]*",
                   paste0("(R|", valid_package_name_regexp, ")"),
                   "([[:space:]]*\\(([^) ]+)[[:space:]]+([^) ]+)\\))?",
                   "[[:space:]]*$")
        for(dep in depends) {
            if(!grepl(dep_regexp, dep)) {
                ## Entry does not match the regexp.
                bad_dep_entry <- c(bad_dep_entry, dep)
                next
            }
            if(nzchar(sub(dep_regexp, "\\2", dep))) {
                ## If not just a valid package name ...
                if(sub(dep_regexp, "\\3", dep) %notin%
                   c("<=", ">=", "<", ">", "==", "!="))
                    bad_dep_op <- c(bad_dep_op, dep)
                else if(grepl("^[[:space:]]*R", dep)) {
                    if(!grepl(sprintf("^(r[0-9]+|%s)$",
                                      valid_package_version_regexp),
                              sub(dep_regexp, "\\4", dep)))
                    bad_dep_version <- c(bad_dep_version, dep)
                } else if(!grepl(sprintf("^%s$",
                                         valid_package_version_regexp),
                                 sub(dep_regexp, "\\4", dep)))
                    bad_dep_version <- c(bad_dep_version, dep)
            }
        }
        if(length(c(bad_dep_entry, bad_dep_op, bad_dep_version)))
            out$bad_depends_or_suggests_or_imports <-
                list(bad_dep_entry = bad_dep_entry,
                     bad_dep_op = bad_dep_op,
                     bad_dep_version = bad_dep_version)
    }
    if(strict && !is.na(val <- db["VignetteBuilder"])) {
        depends <- trimws(unlist(strsplit(val, ",")))
        if(length(depends) < 1L || !all(grepl("^[[:alnum:].]*$", depends)))
            out$bad_vignettebuilder <- TRUE
    }
    if(!is.na(val <- db["Priority"])
       && !is.na(package_name)
       && (tolower(val) %in% c("base", "recommended", "defunct-base"))
       && (package_name %notin% unlist(standard_package_names)))
        out$bad_priority <- val

    ## Minimal check (so far) of Title and Description.
    if(strict && !is.na(val <- db["Title"])
       && endsWith(val, ".")
       && !grepl("[[:space:]][.][.][.]|et[[:space:]]al[.]", trimws(val)))
        out$bad_Title <- TRUE
    ## some people put punctuation inside quotes, some outside.
    if(strict && !is.na(val <- db["Description"])
       && !grepl("[.!?]['\")]?$", trimws(val)))
        out$bad_Description <- TRUE

    class(out) <- "check_package_description"
    out
}

format.check_package_description <-
function(x, ...)
{
    fmt <- function(x) {
        if(length(x)) paste(x, collapse = "\n") else character()
    }

    ## <FIXME>
    ## Currently, check_meta() will give an error unless all output
    ## matches "^Malformed (Title|Description)", so for now need to
    ## avoid the pointer to R-exts in these cases.
    xx <- x; xx$bad_Title <- xx$bad_Description <- NULL
    ## </FIXME>

    c(character(),
      if(length(x$missing_encoding))
          gettext("Unknown encoding"),
      if(length(y <- x$fields_with_non_ASCII_tags))
          paste(c(gettext("Fields with non-ASCII tags:"),
                  .strwrap22(y),
                  gettext("All field tags must be ASCII.")),
                collapse = "\n"),
      if(length(y <- x$fields_with_non_ASCII_values))
          paste(c(gettext("Fields with non-ASCII values:"),
                  .strwrap22(y),
                  gettext("These fields must have ASCII values.")),
                collapse = "\n"),
      fmt(.format_check_package_description_authors_at_R_field_results(x)),
      ## if(length(y <- x$missing_required_fields))
      ##     paste(c(gettext("Required fields missing or empty:"),
      ##             .strwrap22(y)),
      ##           collapse = "\n"),
      if(length(x$bad_package))
          paste(x$bad_package, collapse = "\n"),
      if(length(x$bad_version))
          gettext("Malformed package version."),
      if(length(x$bad_maintainer))
          gettext("Malformed maintainer field."),
      if(any(as.integer(lengths(x$bad_depends_or_suggests_or_imports)) > 0L )) {
          bad <- x$bad_depends_or_suggests_or_imports
          paste(c(gettext("Malformed Depends or Suggests or Imports or Enhances field."),
                  if(length(y <- bad$bad_dep_entry))
                      c(gettext("Offending entries:"),
                        paste0("  ", y),
                        strwrap(gettextf("Entries must be names of packages optionally followed by '<=' or '>=', white space, and a valid version number in parentheses."))),
                  if(length(y <- bad$bad_dep_op))
                      c(gettext("Entries with infeasible comparison operator:"),
                        paste0("  ", y),
                        strwrap(gettextf("Only operators '<=' and '>=' are possible."))),
                  if(length(y <- bad$bad_dep_version))
                      c(gettext("Entries with infeasible version number:"),
                        paste0("  ", y),
                        strwrap(gettextf("Version numbers must be sequences of at least two non-negative integers, separated by single '.' or '-'.")))),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      if(isTRUE(x$bad_vignettebuilder))
          paste(c(gettext("Invalid VignetteBuilder field."),
                  strwrap(gettextf("This field must contain one or more packages (and no version requirement)."))),
                collapse = "\n"),
      if(length(x$bad_priority))
          paste(c(gettext("Invalid Priority field."),
                  strwrap(gettextf("Packages with priorities 'base' or 'recommended' or 'defunct-base' must already be known to R."))),
                collapse = "\n"),
      fmt(c(if(isTRUE(x$bad_Title))
                gettext("Malformed Title field: should not end in a period."),
            if(isTRUE(x$bad_Description))
                gettext("Malformed Description field: should contain one or more complete sentences."))),
      if(any(as.integer(lengths(xx)) > 0L))
          paste(c(strwrap(gettext("See section 'The DESCRIPTION file' in the 'Writing R Extensions' manual."))),
                collapse = "\n"))
}

print.check_package_description <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(length(y <- format(x, ...)))
        writeLines(paste(y, collapse = "\n\n"))
    invisible(x)
}


### * .check_package_description2

.check_package_description2 <-
function(dfile)
{
    dfile <- file_path_as_absolute(dfile)
    db <- .read_description(dfile)
    depends <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Depends")
    imports <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Imports")
    suggests <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Suggests")
    enhances <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Enhances")
    ## Packages may occur several times in each dependency field to
    ## specify version ranges.
    ## See <https://bugs.r-project.org/show_bug.cgi?id=18735>.
    allpkgs <- c(unique(depends), unique(imports),
                 unique(suggests), unique(enhances))
    out <- unique(allpkgs[duplicated(allpkgs)])
    links <- missing_incs <- character()
    llinks <-  .get_requires_with_version_from_package_db(db, "LinkingTo")
    have_src <- TRUE # dummy
    if(length(llinks)) {
        ## This is pointless unless there is compilable code
        have_src <- dir.exists(file.path(dirname(dfile), "src"))

        ## See if this is installable under 3.0.1:
        ## if so check for versioned specs
        deps <- .split_description(db, verbose = TRUE)$Rdepends2
        status <- 0L
        current <- as.numeric_version("3.0.1")
        for(depends in deps) {
            if(depends$op %notin% c("<=", ">=", "<", ">", "==", "!=")) next
            status <- if(inherits(depends$version, "numeric_version"))
                !do.call(depends$op, list(current, depends$version))
            else {
                ver <- R.version
                if (ver$status %in% c("", "Patched")) FALSE
                else !do.call(depends$op,
                              list(ver[["svn rev"]],
                                   as.numeric(sub("^r", "", depends$version))))
            }
        }
        if(!status) {
            llinks <- llinks[lengths(llinks) > 1L]
            if(length(llinks)) links <- sapply(llinks, `[[`, 1L)
        }
        ## and check if we can actually link to these.
        llinks <-  .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "LinkingTo")
        incs <- lapply(llinks, function(x) system.file("include", package = x))
        missing_incs <- as.vector(llinks[!nzchar(incs)])
    }
    out <- list(duplicates = unique(allpkgs[duplicated(allpkgs)]),
                bad_links = links, missing_incs = missing_incs,
                have_src = have_src)
    class(out) <- "check_package_description2"
    out
}

format.check_package_description2 <-
function(x, ...)
{
    c(if(length(xx <- x$duplicates)) {
        c(if(length(xx) > 1L)
          "Packages listed in more than one of Depends, Imports, Suggests, Enhances:"
        else
          "Package listed in more than one of Depends, Imports, Suggests, Enhances:",
          paste(c(" ", sQuote(xx)), collapse = " "),
          "A package should be listed in only one of these fields.")
      },
      if(!x$have_src)
          "'LinkingTo' field is unused: package has no 'src' directory",
      if(length(xx <- x$bad_links)) {
          if(length(xx) > 1L)
              c("Versioned 'LinkingTo' values for",
                paste(c(" ", sQuote(xx)), collapse = " "),
                "are only usable in R >= 3.0.2")
          else
              sprintf("Versioned 'LinkingTo' value for %s is only usable in R >= 3.0.2",
                      sQuote(xx))
      },
      if(x$have_src && length(xx <- x$missing_incs)) {
          c(if(length(xx) > 1L)
                "Packages in 'LinkingTo' providing no 'include' directory:"
            else "Package in 'LinkingTo' providing no 'include' directory:",
            paste(c(" ", sQuote(xx)), collapse = " "))
      })
}

.check_package_description_authors_at_R_field <-
function(aar, strict = FALSE)
{
    out <- list()
    if(is.na(aar)) return(out)
    ## <FIXME>
    ## Perhaps better to actually capture warnings?
    aar <-
        suppressWarnings(tryCatch(utils:::.read_authors_at_R_field(aar,
                                                                   TRUE),
                                  error = identity))
    ## </FIXME>
    if(inherits(aar, "error")) {
        out$bad_authors_at_R_field <- trimws(conditionMessage(aar))
    } else {
        ## Check whether we can expand to something non-empty.
        s <- tryCatch(utils:::.format_authors_at_R_field_for_author(aar),
                      error = identity)
        if(inherits(s, "error")) {
            out$bad_authors_at_R_field_for_author <-
                conditionMessage(s)
        } else {
            if(s == "")
                out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_no_author <- TRUE
            else {
                attr(out, "Author") <- s
                if(strict >= 1L) {
                    has_no_name <-
                        vapply(aar,
                               function(e)
                               is.null(e$given) && is.null(e$family),
                               NA)
                    if(any(has_no_name)) {
                        out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_no_name <-
                            format(aar[has_no_name])
                    }
                    has_no_role <-
                        vapply(aar,
                               function(e) is.null(e$role),
                               NA)
                    if(any(has_no_role)) {
                        out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_no_role <-
                            format(aar[has_no_role])
                    }
                }
                if(strict >= 2L) {
                    if(all(has_no_name |
                           vapply(aar, function(e) "aut" %notin% e$role, NA)))
                        out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_no_author_roles <- TRUE
                    ids <- .ORCID_iD_from_person(aar)
                    pos <- which(!is.na(ids))
                    ids <- ids[pos]
                    pos <- pos[!.ORCID_iD_is_valid(ids)]
                    if(length(pos))
                        out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_bad_ORCID_identifiers <-
                            format(aar[pos])
                    ids <- ids[duplicated(ids)]
                    if(length(ids))
                        out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_dup_ORCID_identifiers <-
                            ids
                    ids <- .ROR_ID_from_person(aar)
                    pos <- which(!is.na(ids))
                    ids <- ids[pos]
                    pos <- pos[!.ROR_ID_is_valid(ids)]
                    if(length(pos))
                        out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_bad_ROR_identifiers <-
                            format(aar[pos])
                    ids <- ids[duplicated(ids)]
                    if(length(ids))
                        out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_dup_ROR_identifiers <-
                            ids
                }
                if(strict >= 3L) {
                    non_standard_roles <-
                        lapply(aar$role, setdiff,
                               utils:::MARC_relator_db_codes_used_with_R)
                    ind <- lengths(non_standard_roles) > 0L
                    if(any(ind)) {
                        out$authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_nonstandard_roles <-
                            sprintf("%s: %s",
                                    format(aar[ind]),
                                    vapply(non_standard_roles[ind], paste,
                                           collapse = ", ",
                                           FUN.VALUE = ""))
                    }
                }
            }
        }
        s <- tryCatch(utils:::.format_authors_at_R_field_for_maintainer(aar),
                      error = identity)
        if(inherits(s, "error")) {
            out$bad_authors_at_R_field_for_maintainer <-
                conditionMessage(s)
        } else {
            ## R-exts says
            ##   The mandatory 'Maintainer' field should give a _single_
            ##   name followed by a _valid_ (RFC 2822) email address in
            ##   angle brackets.
            ## Hence complain when Authors@R
            ## * has more than one person with a cre role
            ## * has no person with a cre role, "valid" email address
            ##   and a non-empty name.
            bad <- FALSE
            p <- Filter(function(e) "cre" %in% e$role,
                        aar)
            if(length(p) > 1L) {
                bad <- TRUE
                out$bad_authors_at_R_field_too_many_maintainers <-
                    format(p)
            }
            p <- Filter(function(e) {
                (!is.null(e$given) || !is.null(e$family)) && !is.null(e$email)
            },
                        p)
            if(!length(p)) {
                bad <- TRUE
                out$bad_authors_at_R_field_has_no_valid_maintainer <- TRUE
            }
            ## s should now be non-empty iff bad is FALSE.
            if(!bad) attr(out, "Maintainer") <- s
        }
    }
    out
}

.format_check_package_description_authors_at_R_field_results <-
function(x)
{
    c(character(),
      if(length(bad <- x[["bad_authors_at_R_field"]])) {
          c(gettext("Malformed Authors@R field:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(bad <- x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_for_author"]])) {
          c(gettext("Cannot extract Author field from Authors@R field:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_no_author"]])) {
          gettext("Authors@R field gives no person with name and roles.")
      },
      if(length(bad <-
                x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_no_name"]])) {
          c(gettext("Authors@R field gives persons with no name:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(bad <-
                x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_no_role"]])) {
          c(gettext("Authors@R field gives persons with no role:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_no_author_roles"]])) {
          gettext("Authors@R field gives no person with name and author role")
      },
      ## if(length(bad <-
      ##           x[["authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_nonstandard_roles"]])) {
      ##     c(gettext("Authors@R field gives persons with non-standard roles:"),
      ##       paste0("  ", bad))
      ## },
      if(length(bad <- x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_for_maintainer"]])) {
          c(gettext("Cannot extract Maintainer field from Authors@R field:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(bad <-
                x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_too_many_maintainers"]])) {
          c(gettext("Authors@R field gives more than one person with maintainer role:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_no_valid_maintainer"]])) {
          strwrap(gettext("Authors@R field gives no person with maintainer role, valid email address and non-empty name."))
      },
      if(length(bad <- x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_bad_ORCID_identifiers"]])) {
          c(gettext("Authors@R field gives persons with invalid ORCID identifiers:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(bad <- x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_dup_ORCID_identifiers"]])) {
          c(gettext("Authors@R field gives persons with duplicated ORCID identifiers:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(bad <- x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_bad_ROR_identifiers"]])) {
          c(gettext("Authors@R field gives persons with invalid ROR identifiers:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      },
      if(length(bad <- x[["bad_authors_at_R_field_has_persons_with_dup_ROR_identifiers"]])) {
          c(gettext("Authors@R field gives persons with duplicated ROR identifiers:"),
            paste0("  ", bad))
      }
      )
}

### * .check_package_description_encoding

.check_package_description_encoding <-
function(dfile)
{
    dfile <- file_path_as_absolute(dfile)
    db <- .read_description(dfile)
    out <- list()

    ## Check encoding-related things.

    ## All field tags must be ASCII.
    if(any(ind <- !.is_ASCII(names(db))))
        out$fields_with_non_ASCII_tags <- names(db)[ind]

    if("Encoding" %notin% names(db)) {
        ind <- !.is_ASCII(db)
        if(any(ind)) {
            out$missing_encoding <- TRUE
            out$fields_with_non_ASCII_values <- names(db)[ind]
        }
    } else {
        enc <- db[["Encoding"]]
        if (enc %notin% c("latin1", "latin2", "UTF-8"))
            out$non_portable_encoding <- enc
    }

    class(out) <- "check_package_description_encoding"
    out
}

format.check_package_description_encoding <-
function(x, ...)
{
    c(character(),
      if(length(x$non_portable_encoding)) {
          c(gettextf("Encoding '%s' is not portable",
                     x$non_portable_encoding),
            "")
      },
      if(length(x$missing_encoding)) {
          gettext("Unknown encoding with non-ASCII data")
      },
      if(length(x$fields_with_non_ASCII_tags)) {
          c(gettext("Fields with non-ASCII tags:"),
            .pretty_format(x$fields_with_non_ASCII_tags),
            gettext("All field tags must be ASCII."),
            "")
      },
      if(length(x$fields_with_non_ASCII_values)) {
          c(gettext("Fields with non-ASCII values:"),
            .pretty_format(x$fields_with_non_ASCII_values))
      },
      if(any(as.integer(lengths(x)) > 0L)) {
          c(strwrap(gettextf("See section 'The DESCRIPTION file' in the 'Writing R Extensions' manual.")),
            "")
      })
}

### * .check_package_license

.check_package_license <-
function(dfile, dir)
{
    dfile <- file_path_as_absolute(dfile)
    db <- .read_description(dfile)

    if(missing(dir))
        dir <- dirname(dfile)

    ## Analyze the license information here.
    ## Cannot easily do this in .check_package_description(), as R CMD
    ## check's R::Utils::check_package_description() takes any output
    ## from this as indication of an error.

    out <- list()
    if(!is.na(val <- db["License"])) {
        ## If there is no License field, .check_package_description()
        ## will give an error.
        status <- analyze_license(val)
        ok <- status$is_canonical
        ## This analyzes the license specification but does not verify
        ## whether pointers exist, so let us do this here.
        if(length(pointers <- status$pointers)) {
            bad_pointers <-
                pointers[!file_test("-f", file.path(dir, pointers))]
            if(length(bad_pointers)) {
                status$bad_pointers <- bad_pointers
                ok <- FALSE
            }
        }
        patt <- "(^Modified BSD License$|^BSD$|^CC BY.* [23][.]0)"
        if(any(ind <- grepl(patt, status$components))) {
            status$deprecated <- status$components[ind]
            ok <- FALSE
        }
        ## Components with extensions but not extensible:
        if(length(extensions <- status$extensions) &&
           any(ind <- !extensions$extensible)) {
            status$bad_extensions <- extensions$components[ind]
            ok <- FALSE
        }
        ## Components which need extensions (note that such components
        ## could use the name or abbrev from the license db):
        if(any(ind <- status$components %in%
               c("MIT License", "MIT",
                 "BSD 2-clause License", "BSD_2_clause",
                 "BSD 3-clause License", "BSD_3_clause"))) {
            status$miss_extension <- status$components[ind]
            ok <- FALSE
        }
        ## License stubs invalid or incomplete.
        if(length(extensions <- status$extensions)) {
            components <- extensions$components
            nms <- if(any(grepl("^BSD[ _]3", components)))
                       c("YEAR", "COPYRIGHT HOLDER", "ORGANIZATION")
                   else if(any(grepl("^(MIT|BSD[ _]2)", components)))
                       c("YEAR", "COPYRIGHT HOLDER")
                   else
                       NULL
            if(!is.null(nms)
               && length(pointers <- status$pointers)
               && file_test("-f", file.path(dir, pointers[1L]))) {
                val <- tryCatch(read.dcf(file.path(dir, pointers[1L]),
                                         fields = nms),
                                error = identity)
                if(inherits(val, "error")) {
                    status$license_stub_is_bad_DCF <- TRUE
                    ok <- FALSE
                } else {
                    ind <- is.na(val) | !nzchar(val)
                    pos <- which(rowSums(ind) > 0)
                    if(length(pos)) {
                        status$license_stub_fields_not_complete <-
                            gettextf("Record: %d Field(s): %s",
                                     pos,
                                     vapply(pos,
                                            function(p)
                                                paste(nms[ind[p, ]],
                                                      collapse = ", "),
                                            ""))
                        ok <- FALSE
                    }
                }
            }
        }

        ## Could always return the analysis results and not print them
        ## if ok, but it seems more standard to only return trouble.
        if(!ok)
            out <- c(list(license = val), status)
    }

    class(out) <- "check_package_license"
    out
}

format.check_package_license <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(!length(x))
        return(character())

    check <- Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_LICENSE_")
    check <- if(check %in% c("maybe", ""))
        (!(x$is_standardizable)
         || length(x$bad_pointers)
         || length(x$bad_extensions)
         || length(x$license_stub_is_bad_DCF)
         || length(x$license_stub_fields_not_complete))
    else
        isTRUE(as.logical(check))
    if(!check)
        return(character())

    c(character(),
      if(!(x$is_canonical)) {
          c(gettext("Non-standard license specification:"),
            strwrap(x$license, indent = 2L, exdent = 2L),
            gettextf("Standardizable: %s", x$is_standardizable),
            if(x$is_standardizable) {
                c(gettext("Standardized license specification:"),
                  strwrap(x$standardization, indent = 2L, exdent = 2L))
            })
      },
      if(length(y <- x$deprecated)) {
          c(gettextf("Deprecated license: %s",
                     paste(y, collapse = " ")))
      },
      if(length(y <- x$bad_pointers)) {
          c(gettextf("Invalid license file pointers: %s",
                     paste(y, collapse = " ")))
      },
      if(length(y <- x$bad_extensions)) {
          c(gettext("License components with restrictions not permitted:"),
            paste0("  ", y))
      },
      if(length(y <- x$miss_extension)) {
          c(gettext("License components which are templates and need '+ file LICENSE':"),
            paste0("  ", y))
      },
      if(length(y <- x$license_stub_is_bad_DCF))
          gettext("License stub is invalid DCF."),
      if(length(y <- x$license_stub_fields_not_complete)) {
          c(gettext("License stub records with missing/empty fields:",
                    paste0("  ", y)))
      }
      )
}

### * .check_make_vars

.check_make_vars <-
function(dir, makevars = c("Makevars.in", "Makevars"))
{
    bad_flags <- list()
    class(bad_flags) <- "check_make_vars"

    paths <- file.path(dir, makevars)
    paths <- paths[file_test("-f", paths)]
    if(!length(paths)) return(bad_flags)
    bad_flags$paths <- file.path("src", basename(paths))
    ## Makevars could be used with --no-configure
    ## and maybe configure does not even use src/Makevars.in
    mfile <- paths[1L]
    make <- Sys.getenv("MAKE")
    if(make == "") make <- "make"
    ## needs a target to avoid targets in src/Makevars
    command <- sprintf("%s -f %s -f %s -f %s makevars_test",
                       make,
                       shQuote(file.path(R.home("share"), "make",
                                         "check_vars_ini.mk")),
                       shQuote(mfile),
                       shQuote(file.path(R.home("share"), "make",
                                         "check_vars_out.mk")))
    lines <- suppressWarnings(tryCatch(system(command, intern = TRUE,
                                              ignore.stderr = TRUE),
                                       error = identity))
    if(!length(lines) || inherits(lines, "error"))
        return(bad_flags)

    prefixes <- c("CPP", "C", "CXX", "CXX98", "CXX11", "CXX14", "CXX17",
                  "CXX20", "CXX23", "F", "FC", "OBJC", "OBJCXX")

    uflags_re <- sprintf("^(%s)FLAGS: *(.*)$",
                         paste(prefixes, collapse = "|"))
    pos <- grep(uflags_re, lines)
    ind <- (sub(uflags_re, "\\2", lines[pos]) != "-o /dev/null")
    if(any(ind))
        bad_flags$uflags <- lines[pos[ind]]

    ## Try to be careful ...
    pflags_re <- sprintf("^PKG_(%s)FLAGS: ",
                         paste(prefixes, collapse = "|"))
    lines <- lines[grepl(pflags_re, lines)]
    names <- sub(":.*", "", lines)
    lines <- sub(pflags_re, "", lines)
    flags <- strsplit(lines, "[[:space:]]+")
    ## Bad flags:
    ##   -O*
    ##      (BDR: for example Sun Fortran compilers used to accept -O
    ##      but not -O2, and VC++ accepts -Ox (literal x) but not -O.)
    ##   -Wall -pedantic -ansi -traditional -std* -f* -m* [GCC]
    ##   -x [Solaris]
    ##   -q [AIX]
    ##   -pipe (GNU compilers, not accepted by flang-new)
    ## It is hard to think of anything apart from -I* and -D* that is
    ## safe for general use ...
    bad_flags_regexp <-
        sprintf("^-(%s)$",
                paste(c("O.*",
                        "W", # same as -Wextra in GCC.
                        "w", # GCC, Solaris inhibit all warnings
                        "W[^l].*", # -Wl, might just be portable
                        "ansi", "pedantic", "traditional",
                        "f.*", "m.*", "std.*", # includes -fopenmp
                        "isystem", # gcc and clones
                        "x",
                        "pipe",
                        "cpp", # gfortran
                        "g",  # not portable, waste of space
                        "q"),
                      collapse = "|"))
    for(i in seq_along(lines)) {
        bad <- grep(bad_flags_regexp, flags[[i]], value = TRUE)
        if (names[i] %in% c("PKG_FFLAGS", "PKG_FCFLAGS"))
            bad <- grep("^-std=f", bad, invert = TRUE, value = TRUE)
        if(length(bad))
            bad_flags$pflags <-
                c(bad_flags$pflags,
                  structure(list(bad), names = names[i]))
    }

    ## The above does not know about GNU make extensions like
    ## target.o: PKG_CXXFLAGS = -mavx
    ## so grep files directly.
    for (f in paths) {
        lines <- readLines(f, warn = FALSE)
        pflags_re2 <- sprintf(".*[.o]: +PKG_(%s)FLAGS *=",
                              paste(prefixes, collapse = "|"))
        lines <- grep(pflags_re2, lines, value = TRUE)
        lines <- sub(pflags_re2, "", lines)
        flags <- strsplit(lines, "[[:space:]]+")
        bad <- character()
        for(i in seq_along(lines))
            bad <- c(bad, grep(bad_flags_regexp, flags[[i]], value = TRUE))
        if(length(bad))
            bad_flags$p2flags <-
                c(bad_flags$p2flags,
                  structure(list(bad), names = file.path("src", basename(f))))
    }

    bad_flags
}

format.check_make_vars <-
function(x, ...)
{
    .fmt <- function(x) {
        s <- Map(c,
                 gettextf("Non-portable flags in variable '%s':",
                          names(x)),
                 sprintf("  %s", lapply(x, paste, collapse = " ")))
        as.character(unlist(s))
    }

    .fmt2 <- function(x) {
        s <- Map(c,
                 gettextf("Non-portable flags in file '%s':",
                          names(x)),
                 sprintf("  %s", lapply(x, paste, collapse = " ")))
        as.character(unlist(s))
    }

    c(character(),
      if(length(bad <- x$pflags)) .fmt(bad),
      if(length(bad <- x$p2flags)) .fmt2(bad),
      if(length(bad <- x$uflags)) {
          c(gettextf("Variables overriding user/site settings:"),
            sprintf("  %s", bad))
      },
      if(length(x$paths) > 1L) {
          c(sprintf("Package has both %s and %s.",
                  sQuote("src/Makevars.in"), sQuote("src/Makevars")),
            strwrap(sprintf("Installation with --no-configure' is unlikely to work.  If you intended %s to be used on Windows, rename it to %s otherwise remove it.  If %s created %s, you need a %s script.",
                            sQuote("src/Makevars"),
                            sQuote("src/Makevars.win"),
                            sQuote("configure"),
                            sQuote("src/Makevars"),
                            sQuote("cleanup"))))
      })
}

### * .check_code_usage_in_package

## First, its auxiliaries
##
## - .unix_only_proto_objects
## - .windows_only_proto_objects
## - compatibilityEnv ()        -- used also in codoc()

.unix_only_proto_objects <- as.environment(list(
    nsl = function(hostname) {}
  , X11Font = function(font) {}
  , X11Fonts = function(...) {}
  , X11.options = function(..., reset = TRUE) {}
  , quartz = function(title, width, height, pointsize, family,
                      fontsmooth, antialias, type, file = NULL,
                      bg, canvas, dpi) {}
  , quartzFont = function(family) {}
  , quartzFonts = function(...) {}
  , quartz.options = function(..., reset = TRUE) {}
  , quartz.save = function(file, type = "png", device = dev.cur(),
                           dpi = 100, ...) {}
))

.windows_only_proto_objects <- as.environment(list(
    arrangeWindows = function(action = c("vertical", "horizontal",
                                         "cascade", "minimize", "restore"),
                              windows, preserve = TRUE, outer = FALSE) {}
  , askYesNoWinDialog = function(msg, ...) {}
  , bringToTop = function(which = grDevices::dev.cur(), stay = FALSE) {}
  , choose.dir = function(default = "", caption = "Select folder") {}
  , choose.files = function(default = "", caption = "Select files", multi = TRUE,
                            filters = Filters, index = nrow(Filters)) {
      Filters <- NULL }
  , Filters = NULL
  , close.winProgressBar = function(con, ...) {}
  , DLL.version = function(path) {}
  , .fixupGFortranStderr = function() {}
  , .fixupGFortranStdout = function() {}
  , getClipboardFormats = function(numeric = FALSE) {}
  , getIdentification = function() {}
  , getWindowsHandle = function(which = "Console") {}
  , getWindowsHandles = function(which = "R", pattern = "", minimized = FALSE) {}
  , getWindowTitle = function() {}
  , getWinProgressBar = function(pb) {}
  , .install.winbinary = function(pkgs, lib, repos = getOption("repos"),
                                  contriburl = utils::contrib.url(repos),
                                  method, available = NULL, destdir = NULL,
                                  dependencies = FALSE, libs_only = FALSE, ...) {}
  , loadRconsole = function(file = choose.files(file.path(
                                Sys.getenv("R_USER"), "Rconsole"))) {}
  , msgWindow = function(type = c("minimize", "restore", "maximize", "hide",
                                  "recordOn", "recordOff"),
                         which = dev.cur()) {}
  , readClipboard = function(format = 1, raw = FALSE) {}
  , readRegistry = function(key,
                            hive = c("HLM", "HCR", "HCU", "HU", "HCC", "HPD"),
                            maxdepth = 1,
                            view = c("default", "32-bit", "64-bit")) {}
  ## Exists on all platforms though with differing formals :
  ## , savePlot = function(filename = "Rplot",
  ##                       type = c("wmf", "emf", "png", "jpeg", "jpg",
  ##                                "bmp", "ps", "eps", "pdf"),
  ##                       device = grDevices::dev.cur(), restoreConsole = TRUE) {}
  , setStatusBar = function(text) {}
  , setWindowTitle = function(suffix, title = paste(utils::getIdentification(),
                                                    suffix)) {}
  , setWinProgressBar = function(pb, value, title=NULL, label=NULL) {}
  , shell = function(cmd, shell, flag = "/c", intern = FALSE,
                     wait = TRUE, translate = FALSE, mustWork = FALSE, ...) {}
  , shell.exec = function(file) {}
  , shortPathName = function(path) {}
  , Sys.junction = function(from, to) {}
  , win.graph = function(width = 7, height = 7, pointsize = 12,
                         restoreConsole = FALSE) {}
  , win.metafile = function(filename = "", width = 7, height = 7,
                            pointsize = 12, family = "",
                            restoreConsole = TRUE) {}
  , win.print = function(width = 7, height = 7, pointsize = 12,
                         printer = "", family = "", antialias = "default",
                         restoreConsole = TRUE) {}
  , win.version = function() {}
  , windows = function(width, height, pointsize,
                       record, rescale, xpinch, ypinch,
                       bg, canvas, gamma, xpos, ypos,
                       buffered, title, restoreConsole, clickToConfirm,
                       fillOddEven, family = "", antialias) {}
  , windowsFont = function(font) {}
  , windowsFonts = function(...) {}
  , windows.options = function(..., reset = TRUE) {}
  , winDialog = function(type = "ok", message) {}
  , winDialogString = function(message, default) {}
  , winMenuAdd = function(menuname) {}
  , winMenuAddItem = function(menuname, itemname, action) {}
  , winMenuDel = function(menuname) {}
  , winMenuDelItem = function(menuname, itemname) {}
  , winMenuNames = function() {}
  , winMenuItems = function(menuname) {}
  , winProgressBar = function(title = "R progress bar", label = "",
                              min = 0, max = 1, initial = 0, width = 300) {}
  , writeClipboard = function(str, format = 1L) {}
  , zip.unpack = function(zipname, dest) {}
))

compatibilityEnv <- function() {
    ## (this formulation allows more than two OS.type s)
    switch(.Platform$OS.type,
           "windows" = .unix_only_proto_objects,
           "unix" = .windows_only_proto_objects,
           ## in such a future case, possibly the "union" of these environments:
           stop(gettextf("invalid 'OS.type' \"%s\".  Should not happen",
                         .Platform$OS.type), domain = NA))
}

.check_code_usage_in_package <-
function(package, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    is_base <- package == "base"

    check_without_loading <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CODE_USAGE_VIA_NAMESPACES_",
                                         "TRUE"))

    if(!is_base) {
        if(!check_without_loading) {
            .load_package_quietly(package, lib.loc)
            .eval_with_capture({
                ## avoid warnings about code in other packages the package
                ## uses
                desc <- readRDS(file.path(find.package(package, NULL),
                                          "Meta", "package.rds"))
                pkgs1 <- sapply(desc$Suggests, `[[`, "name")
                pkgs2 <- sapply(desc$Enhances, `[[`, "name")
                for(pkg in unique(c(pkgs1, pkgs2)))
                    ## tcltk warns if no DISPLAY variable
                    ##, errors if not compiled in
                    suppressMessages(
                        tryCatch(require(pkg, character.only = TRUE,
                                         quietly = TRUE),
                                 error  = function(.) NULL,
                                 warning= function(.) NULL))
            }, type = "output")
        }
        if(is.null(.GlobalEnv$.Random.seed)) # create .Random.seed if necessary
            stats::runif(1)
        attach(compatibilityEnv(), name="compat", pos = length(search()),
               warn.conflicts = FALSE)
        on.exit(detach("compat"))
    }

    ## A simple function for catching the output from the codetools
    ## analysis using the checkUsage report mechanism.
    out <- character()
    foo <- function(x) out <<- c(out, x)
    ## (Simpler than using a variant of capture.output().)
    ## Of course, it would be nice to return a suitably structured
    ## result, but we can always do this by suitably splitting the
    ## messages on the double colons ...

    ## Not only check function definitions, but also S4 methods
    ## [a version of this should be part of codetools eventually] :
    checkMethodUsageEnv <- function(env, ...) {
        for(g in .get_S4_generics(env))
            for(m in .get_S4_methods_list(g, env)) {
                fun <- methods::unRematchDefinition(methods::getDataPart(m))
                signature <- paste(m@generic,
                                   paste(m@target, collapse = "-"),
                                   sep = ",")
                codetools::checkUsage(fun, signature, ...)
            }
    }
    checkMethodUsagePackage <- function (pack, ...) {
        pname <- paste0("package:", pack)
        if (pname %notin% search())
            stop("package must be loaded", domain = NA)
        checkMethodUsageEnv(if (isNamespaceLoaded(pack))
                            getNamespace(pack) else as.environment(pname), ...)
    }

    ## Allow specifying a codetools "profile" for checking via the
    ## environment variable _R_CHECK_CODETOOLS_PROFILE_, used as e.g.
    ##   _R_CHECK_CODETOOLS_PROFILE_="suppressLocalUnused=FALSE"
    ## (where the values get converted to logicals "the usual way").
    args <- list(skipWith = TRUE,
                 suppressPartialMatchArgs = FALSE,
                 suppressLocalUnused = TRUE)
    opts <- unlist(strsplit(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CODETOOLS_PROFILE_"),
                            "[[:space:]]*,[[:space:]]*"))
    if(length(opts)) {
        args[sub("[[:space:]]*=.*", "", opts)] <-
            lapply(sub(".*=[[:space:]]*", "", opts),
                   config_val_to_logical)
    }
    if(check_without_loading)
        env <- suppressWarnings(suppressMessages(loadNamespace(package,
                                                               lib.loc)))
    ## look for globalVariables declaration in package
    ## (This loads the namespace if not already loaded.)
    .glbs <- suppressMessages(utils::globalVariables(, package))
    if(length(.glbs)) {
        ## Cannot use globalVariables() for base
        ## (and potentially tools and utils)
        dflt <- c(if(package == "base") "last.dump",
                  ".Generic", ".Method", ".Class")
        args$suppressUndefined <- c(dflt, .glbs)
    }

    if(check_without_loading) {
        args <- c(list(env, report = foo), args)
        suppressMessages(do.call(codetools::checkUsageEnv, args))
        suppressMessages(do.call(checkMethodUsageEnv, args))
    } else {
        args <- c(list(package, report = foo), args)
        suppressMessages(do.call(codetools::checkUsagePackage, args))
        suppressMessages(do.call(checkMethodUsagePackage, args))
    }

    out <- unique(out)
    class(out) <- "check_code_usage_in_package"
    out
}

format.check_code_usage_in_package <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(length(x)) {
        ## There seems no easy we can gather usage diagnostics by type,
        ## so try to rearrange to some extent when formatting.
        ind <- grepl(": partial argument match of", x, fixed = TRUE)
        if(any(ind)) x <- c(x[ind], x[!ind])
    }
    if(length(x)) {
        ## Provide a summary listing of the undefined globals:
        y <- .canonicalize_quotes(x)
        m <- regexec("no visible global function definition for '(.*)'", y)
        funs <- vapply(Filter(length, regmatches(y, m)), `[`, "", 2L)
        m <- regexec("no visible binding for global variable '(.*)'", y)
        vars <- vapply(Filter(length, regmatches(y, m)), `[`, "", 2L)
        y <- sort(unique(c(funs, vars)))
        c(strwrap(x, indent = 0L, exdent = 2L),
          if(length(y)) {
              c("Undefined global functions or variables:",
                strwrap(paste(y, collapse = " "),
                        indent = 2L, exdent = 2L))
          })
    } else character()
}

### * .check_Rd_xrefs

.check_Rd_xrefs <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Build a db with all possible link targets (aliases) in the base
    ## and recommended packages.
    base <- unlist(.get_standard_package_names()[c("base", "recommended")],
                   use.names = FALSE)
    ## May not have recommended packages
    base <- base[dir.exists(file.path(.Library, base))]
    aliases <- lapply(base, Rd_aliases, lib.loc = NULL)
    ## (Don't use lib.loc = .Library, as recommended packages may have
    ## been installed to a different place.)

    ## Now find the aliases in packages it depends on
    if(!missing(package)) {
        pfile <- system.file("Meta", "package.rds", package = package,
                             lib.loc = lib.loc)
        pkgInfo <- readRDS(pfile)
    } else {
        pkgInfo <- .split_description(.get_package_metadata(dir))
    }
    pkgname <- pkgInfo$DESCRIPTION[["Package"]]
    ## only 'Depends' are guaranteed to be on the search path, but
    ## 'Imports' have to be installed and hence help there will be found
    deps <- c(names(pkgInfo$Depends), names(pkgInfo$Imports))
    pkgs <- setdiff(unique(deps), base)
    try_Rd_aliases <- function(...) tryCatch(Rd_aliases(...), error = identity)
    aliases <- c(aliases, lapply(pkgs, try_Rd_aliases, lib.loc = lib.loc))
    aliases[vapply(aliases, inherits, "error", FUN.VALUE = NA)] <- NULL

    ## Add the aliases from the package itself, and build a db with all
    ## (if any) \link xrefs in the package Rd objects.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        aliases1 <- Rd_aliases(package, lib.loc = lib.loc)
        if(!length(aliases1))
            return(structure(list(), class = "check_Rd_xrefs"))
        aliases <- c(aliases, list(aliases1))
        db <- .build_Rd_xref_db(package, lib.loc = lib.loc)
    } else {
        aliases1 <- Rd_aliases(dir = dir)
        if(!length(aliases1))
            return(structure(list(), class = "check_Rd_xrefs"))
        aliases <- c(aliases, list(aliases1))
        db <- .build_Rd_xref_db(dir = dir)
    }

    ## Flatten the xref db into one big matrix.
    db <- cbind(do.call(rbind, db),
                File = rep.int(names(db), vapply(db, NROW, 0L)))
    if(nrow(db) == 0L)
        return(structure(list(), class = "check_Rd_xrefs"))

    ## fixup \link[=dest] form
    anchor <- db[, 2L]
    have_equals <- startsWith(anchor, "=")
    if(any(have_equals))
        db[have_equals, 1:2] <- cbind(sub("^=", "", anchor[have_equals]), "")

    db <- cbind(db, bad = FALSE, report = db[, 1L])
    have_anchor <- nzchar(anchor <- db[, 2L])
    db[have_anchor, "report"] <-
        paste0("[", db[have_anchor, 2L], "]{", db[have_anchor, 1L], "}")

    ## Check the targets from the non-anchored xrefs.
    db[!have_anchor, "bad"] <- db[!have_anchor, 1L] %notin% unlist(aliases)

    ## and then check the anchored ones if we can.
    have_colon <- grepl(":", anchor, fixed = TRUE)
    unknown <- undeclared <- unavailable <- character()
    thispkg <- anchor
    thisfile <- db[, 1L]
    thispkg [have_colon] <- sub("([^:]*):(.*)", "\\1", anchor[have_colon])
    thisfile[have_colon] <- sub("([^:]*):(.*)", "\\2", anchor[have_colon])

    use_aliases_from_CRAN <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_XREFS_USE_ALIASES_FROM_CRAN_",
                                         "FALSE"))
    if(use_aliases_from_CRAN) {
        aliases_db <- NULL
        tried_aliases_db <- FALSE
    }

    anchors <- unique(thispkg[have_anchor])

    ## added in 4.1.0: are anchors declared?
    check_anchors <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_XREFS_PKGS_ARE_DECLARED_",
                                         "FALSE"))
    if(check_anchors) {
        deps2 <- c(names(pkgInfo$Depends), names(pkgInfo$Imports),
                   names(pkgInfo$Suggests))
        ## people link to the package itself, although never needed.
        undeclared <- setdiff(anchors, c(unique(deps2), pkgname, base))
        if(length(undeclared)) {
            ## Now dig out Enhances
            DESC <- pkgInfo$DESCRIPTION
            if("Enhances" %in% names(DESC)) {
                enh <- names(.split_dependencies(DESC[["Enhances"]]))
                undeclared <- setdiff(undeclared, enh)
            }
        }
    }

    mind_suspects <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_XREFS_MIND_SUSPECT_ANCHORS_",
                                         "FALSE"))
    if(mind_suspects) {
        db <- cbind(db, suspect = FALSE)
    }

    for(pkg in anchors) {
        ## we can't do this on the current uninstalled package!
        if (missing(package) && pkg == pkgname) next
        this <- have_anchor & (thispkg %in% pkg)
        top <- system.file(package = pkg, lib.loc = lib.loc)
        if(nzchar(top)) {
            aliases1 <- if(pkg %in% names(aliases))
                            aliases[[pkg]]
                        else
                            Rd_aliases(pkg, lib.loc = lib.loc)
            good <- thisfile[this] %in% aliases1
            suspect <- if(any(!good)) {
                           RdDB <- file.path(top, "help", "paths.rds")
                           nm <- sub("\\.[Rr]d", "", basename(readRDS(RdDB)))
                           !good & (thisfile[this] %in% nm)
                       } else FALSE
            db[this, "bad"] <- !good & !suspect
            if(mind_suspects)
                db[this, "suspect"] <- suspect

        } else if(use_aliases_from_CRAN) {
            if(is.null(aliases_db)) {
                if (tried_aliases_db) {
                    unknown <- c(unknown, pkg)
                    next
                }
                tried_aliases_db <- TRUE
                ## Not yet read in.
                ## This can fail if e.g. CRAN is updating DB
                aliases_db <- tryCatch(CRAN_aliases_db(),
                                       error = function(e) NULL)
                if (is.null(aliases_db)) {
                    unknown <- c(unknown, pkg)
                    next
                }
            }
            aliases <- aliases_db[[pkg]]
            if(is.null(aliases)) {
                unknown <- c(unknown, pkg)
                next
            }
            ## message(sprintf("Using aliases db for package %s", pkg))
            aliases1 <- unique(as.character(unlist(aliases,
                                                   use.names = FALSE)))
            good <- thisfile[this] %in% aliases1
            suspect <- if(any(!good)) {
                           nm <- sub("\\.[Rr]d", "",
                                     basename(names(aliases)))
                           !good & (thisfile[this] %in% nm)
                       } else FALSE
            db[this, "bad"] <- !good & !suspect
            if(mind_suspects)
                db[this, "suspect"] <- suspect
        }
        else
            unknown <- c(unknown, pkg)
    }

    unknown <- unique(unknown)
    if(length(unknown)) {
        ## respect _R_CHECK_XREFS_REPOSITORIES_ for this use
        repos <- .get_standard_repository_URLs(ForXrefs = TRUE)
        ## Also allow for additionally specified repositories.
        aurls <- pkgInfo[["DESCRIPTION"]]["Additional_repositories"]
        if(!is.na(aurls)) {
            repos <- c(repos, .read_additional_repositories_field(aurls))
        }
        known <-
            try(suppressWarnings(utils::available.packages(utils::contrib.url(repos, "source"),
               filters = c("R_version", "duplicates"))[, "Package"]))
        miss <- if(inherits(known, "try-error")) TRUE
        else unknown %in% c(known, c("GLMMGibbs", "survnnet", "yags"))
        ## from CRANextras
        unavailable <- unknown[miss]
        unknown <- unknown[!miss]
    }

    ## The bad ones:
    bad <- db[, "bad"] == "TRUE"

    out <- list(bad = split(db[bad, "report"], db[bad, "File"]))
    if(mind_suspects && any(ind <- db[, "suspect"] == "TRUE")) {
        out <- c(out, list(suspect = split(db[ind, "report"],
                                           db[ind, "File"])))
    }
    out <- c(out, Filter(length,
                         list(unknown = unknown,
                              undeclared = undeclared,
                              unavailable = unavailable)))
    structure(out, class = "check_Rd_xrefs")
}

format.check_Rd_xrefs <-
function(x, ...)
{
    xb <- x$bad
    xs <- x$suspect
    if(any(lengths(x)) > 0L) {
        .fmtb <- function(i) {
            c(gettextf("Missing link(s) in Rd file '%s':",
                       names(xb)[i]),
              ## NB, link might be empty, and was in mvbutils
              .pretty_format(unique(xb[[i]])),
              "")
        }
        .fmts <- function(i) {
            c(gettextf("Non-topic package-anchored link(s) in Rd file '%s':",
                       names(xs)[i]),
              .pretty_format(unique(xs[[i]])),
              "")
        }
        c(if(length(y <- x$undeclared))
              sprintf(ngettext(length(y),
                               "Undeclared package %s in Rd xrefs",
                               "Undeclared packages %s in Rd xrefs"),
                      paste(sQuote(y), collapse = ", ")),
          if(length(y <- x$unavailable))
              sprintf(ngettext(length(y),
                               "Package unavailable to check Rd xrefs: %s",
                               "Packages unavailable to check Rd xrefs: %s"),
                      paste(sQuote(y), collapse = ", ")),
          if(length(y <- x$unknown))
              sprintf(ngettext(length(y),
                               "Unknown package %s in Rd xrefs",
                               "Unknown packages %s in Rd xrefs"),
                      paste(sQuote(y), collapse = ", ")),
          unlist(lapply(seq_along(xb), .fmtb)),
          unlist(lapply(seq_along(xs), .fmts)),
          if(length(xb) || length(xs))
              strwrap(gettextf("See section 'Cross-references' in the 'Writing R Extensions' manual."))
          )
    } else {
        character()
    }
}

### * .check_package_datasets

.check_package_datasets <-
function(pkgDir)
{
    oLC_ct <- Sys.getlocale("LC_CTYPE"); on.exit(Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", oLC_ct))
    Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", "C")
    oop <- options(warn = -1)
    on.exit(options(oop), add = TRUE)
    check_one <- function(x, ds)
    {
        if(!length(x)) return()
        ## avoid as.list methods
        if(is.list(x)) lapply(unclass(x), check_one, ds = ds)
        if(is.character(x)) {
            xx <- unclass(x)
            enc <- Encoding(xx)
            latin1 <<- latin1 + sum(enc == "latin1")
            utf8 <<- utf8 + sum(enc == "UTF-8")
            bytes <<- bytes + sum(enc == "bytes")
            unk <- xx[enc == "unknown"]
            ind <- .Call(C_check_nonASCII2, unk)
            if(length(ind)) {
                non_ASCII <<- c(non_ASCII, unk[ind])
                where <<- c(where, rep.int(ds, length(ind)))
            }
        }
        a <- attributes(x)
        if(!is.null(a)) {
            lapply(a, check_one, ds = ds)
            check_one(names(a), ds)
        }
        invisible()
    }

    sink(tempfile()) ## suppress startup messages to stdout
    on.exit(sink(), add = TRUE)
    files <- list_files_with_type(file.path(pkgDir, "data"), "data")
    files <- unique(basename(file_path_sans_ext(files)))
    ans <- vector("list", length(files))
    dataEnv <- new.env(hash=TRUE)
    names(ans) <- files
    old <- setwd(pkgDir)

    ## formerly used .try_quietly which stops on error
    .try <- function (expr, msg) {
        oop <- options(warn = 1)
        on.exit(options(oop))
        outConn <- file(open = "w+")
        sink(outConn, type = "output")
        sink(outConn, type = "message")
        tryCatch(withRestarts(withCallingHandlers(expr, error = {
            function(e) invokeRestart("grmbl", e, sys.calls())
        }), grmbl = function(e, calls) {
            n <- length(sys.calls())
            calls <- calls[-seq.int(length.out = n - 1L)]
            calls <- rev(calls)[-c(1L, 2L)]
            tb <- lapply(calls, deparse)
            message(msg, conditionMessage(e), "\nCall sequence:\n",
                    paste(c(utils::head(.eval_with_capture(traceback(tb))$output, 5),
                            "  ..."),
                          collapse = "\n"),
                    "\n")
        }), error = identity, finally = {
            sink(type = "message")
            sink(type = "output")
            close(outConn)
        })
    }

    for(f in files) {
        msg <- sprintf("Error loading dataset %s: ", sQuote(f))
        .try(utils::data(list = f, package = character(), envir = dataEnv), msg)
    }
    setwd(old)

    non_ASCII <- where <- character()
    latin1 <- utf8 <- bytes <- 0L
    ## avoid messages about loading packages that started with r48409
    ## (and some more ...)
    ## add try() to ensure that all datasets are looked at
    ## (if not all of each dataset).
    for(ds in ls(envir = dataEnv, all.names = TRUE)) {
        if(inherits(suppressWarnings(suppressMessages(try(check_one(get(ds, envir = dataEnv), ds), silent = TRUE))),
                    "try-error")) {
            msg <- sprintf("Error loading dataset %s:\n ", sQuote(ds))
            message(msg, geterrmessage())
        }
    }
    unknown <- unique(cbind(non_ASCII, where))
    structure(list(latin1 = latin1, utf8 = utf8, bytes = bytes,
                   unknown = unknown),
              class = "check_package_datasets")
}

format.check_package_datasets <-
function(x, ...)
{
    ## not sQuote as we have mucked about with locales.
    iconv0 <- function(x, ...) paste0("'", iconv(x, ...), "'")

    suppress_notes <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_PACKAGE_DATASETS_SUPPRESS_NOTES_",
                                         "TRUE"))

    c(character(),
      if((n <- x$latin1) && !suppress_notes) {
          sprintf(ngettext(n,
                           "Note: found %d marked Latin-1 string",
                           "Note: found %d marked Latin-1 strings"),
                  n)
      },
      if((n <- x$utf8) && !suppress_notes) {
          sprintf(ngettext(n,
                           "Note: found %d marked UTF-8 string",
                           "Note: found %d marked UTF-8 strings"),
                  n)
      },
      ## if(n <- x$bytes) { ## elevated to a Warning in 4.5.0
      ##     sprintf(
      ##             ngettext(n,
      ##                      "Warning: found %d string marked as \"bytes\"",
      ##                      "Warning: found %d strings marked as \"bytes\""), n)
      ## },
      if((n <- x$bytes) && !suppress_notes) {
          sprintf(ngettext(n,
                           "Note: found %d string marked as \"bytes\"",
                           "Note: found %d strings marked as \"bytes\""),
                  n)
      },
      if(nr <- nrow(x$unknown)) {
          msg <- ngettext(nr,
                          "Warning: found non-ASCII string",
                          "Warning: found non-ASCII strings",
                          domain = NA)
          c(msg,
            paste0(iconv0(x$unknown[, 1L], "", "ASCII", sub = "byte"),
                   " in object '", x$unknown[, 2L], "'"))
      })
}

### * .check_package_datasets2

.check_package_datasets2 <-
function(fileName, pkgname)
{
    oldSearch <- search()
    dataEnv <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
    suppressMessages(utils::data(list = fileName, package = pkgname,
                                 envir = dataEnv))
    if (!length((ls(dataEnv)))) message("No dataset created in 'envir'")
    if (!identical(search(), oldSearch)) message("Search path was changed")
    invisible(NULL)
}

### * .check_package_compact_datasets

.check_package_compact_datasets <-
function(pkgDir, thorough = FALSE)
{
    msg <- NULL
    rdas <- checkRdaFiles(file.path(pkgDir, "data"))
    row.names(rdas) <- basename(row.names(rdas))
    problems <- with(rdas, (ASCII | compress == "none") & (size > 1e5))
    if (any(rdas$compress %in% c("bzip2", "xz"))) {
        OK <- FALSE
        Rdeps <- .split_description(.read_description(file.path(pkgDir, "DESCRIPTION")))$Rdepends2
        for(dep in Rdeps) {
            if(!(dep$op %in% c(">=", ">"))) next
            if(dep$version >= package_version("2.10")) {OK <- TRUE; break;}
        }
        if(!OK) msg <- "Warning: package needs dependence on R (>= 2.10)"
    }
    if (sum(rdas$size) < 1e5 || # we don't report unless we get a 1e5 reduction
        any(rdas$compress %in% c("bzip2", "xz"))) # assume already optimized
        thorough <- FALSE
    sizes <- improve <- NULL
    if (thorough) {
        files <- Sys.glob(c(file.path(pkgDir, "data", "*.rda"),
                            file.path(pkgDir, "data", "*.RData")))
        ## Exclude .RData, which this may or may not match
        files <- files[!endsWith(files, "/.RData")]
        if (length(files)) {
            cpdir <- tempfile('cp')
            dir.create(cpdir)
            file.copy(files, cpdir)
            resaveRdaFiles(cpdir)
            rdas2 <- checkRdaFiles(cpdir)
            row.names(rdas2) <- basename(row.names(rdas2))
            diff2 <- (rdas2$ASCII != rdas$ASCII) | (rdas2$compress != rdas$compress)
            diff2 <- diff2 & (rdas$size > 1e4) & (rdas2$size < 0.9*rdas$size)
            sizes <- c(sum(rdas$size), sum(rdas2$size))
            improve <- data.frame(old_size = rdas$size,
                                  new_size = rdas2$size,
                                  compress = rdas2$compress,
                                  row.names = row.names(rdas))[diff2, ]
        }
    }
    structure(list(rdas = rdas[problems, 1:3], msg = msg,
                   sizes = sizes, improve = improve),
              class = "check_package_compact_datasets")
}

print.check_package_compact_datasets <-
function(x, ...)
{
    reformat <- function(x) {
        xx <- paste0(x, "b")
        ind1 <- (x >= 1024)
        xx[ind1] <- sprintf("%.0fKb", x[ind1]/1024)
        ind2 <- x >= 1024^2
        xx[ind2] <- sprintf("%.1fMb", x[ind2]/(1024^2))
        ind3 <- x >= 1024^3
        xx[ind3] <- sprintf("%.1fGb", x[ind3]/1024^3)
        xx
    }
    if(nr <- nrow(x$rdas)) {
        msg <- ngettext(nr,
                        "Warning: large data file saved inefficiently:",
                        "Warning: large data files saved inefficiently:",
                        domain = NA)
        writeLines(msg)
        rdas <- x$rdas
        rdas$size <- reformat(rdas$size)
        print(rdas)
    }
    if(!is.null(x$msg)) writeLines(x$msg)
    if(!is.null(s <- x$sizes) && s[1L] - s[2L] > 1e5  # save at least 100Kb
       && s[2L]/s[1L] < 0.9) { # and at least 10%
        writeLines(c("",
                     "Note: significantly better compression could be obtained",
                     "      by using R CMD build --resave-data"))
        if(nrow(x$improve)) {
            improve <- x$improve
            improve$old_size <- reformat(improve$old_size)
            improve$new_size <- reformat(improve$new_size)
            print(improve)
        }
    }
    invisible(x)
}

### * .check_package_compact_sysdata

.check_package_compact_sysdata <-
function(pkgDir, thorough = FALSE)
{
    msg <- NULL
    files <- file.path(pkgDir, "R", "sysdata.rda")
    rdas <- checkRdaFiles(files)
    row.names(rdas) <- basename(row.names(rdas))
    problems <- with(rdas, (ASCII | compress == "none") & (size > 1e5))
    if (any(rdas$compress %in% c("bzip2", "xz"))) {
        OK <- FALSE
        Rdeps <- .split_description(.read_description(file.path(pkgDir, "DESCRIPTION")))$Rdepends2
        for(dep in Rdeps) {
            if(!(dep$op %in% c(">=", ">"))) next
            if(dep$version >= package_version("2.10")) {OK <- TRUE; break;}
        }
        if(!OK) msg <- "Warning: package needs dependence on R (>= 2.10)"
    }
    if (sum(rdas$size) < 1e5 || # we don't report unless we get a 1e5 reduction
        any(rdas$compress %in% c("bzip2", "xz"))) # assume already optimized
        thorough <- FALSE
    if (thorough) {
        cpdir <- tempfile('cp')
        dir.create(cpdir)
        file.copy(files, cpdir)
        resaveRdaFiles(cpdir)
        rdas2 <- checkRdaFiles(cpdir)
        row.names(rdas2) <- basename(row.names(rdas2))
        diff2 <- (rdas2$ASCII != rdas$ASCII) | (rdas2$compress != rdas$compress)
        diff2 <- diff2 & (rdas$size > 1e4) & (rdas2$size < 0.9*rdas$size)
        sizes <- c(sum(rdas$size), sum(rdas2$size))
        improve <- data.frame(old_size = rdas$size,
                              new_size = rdas2$size,
                              compress = rdas2$compress,
                              row.names = row.names(rdas))[diff2, ]
    } else sizes <- improve <- NULL
    structure(list(rdas = rdas[problems, 1:3], msg = msg,
                   sizes = sizes, improve = improve),
              class = "check_package_compact_datasets")
}


### * .check_package_subdirs

## used by R CMD build
.check_package_subdirs <-
function(dir, doDelete = FALSE)
{
    OS_subdirs <- c("unix", "windows")

    mydir <- function(dir)
    {
        d <- list.files(dir, all.files = TRUE, full.names = FALSE)
        if(!length(d)) return(d)
        if(basename(dir) %in% c("R", "man"))
            for(os in OS_subdirs) {
                os_dir <- file.path(dir, os)
                if(dir.exists(os_dir))
                    d <- c(d,
                           file.path(os,
                                     list.files(os_dir,
                                                all.files = TRUE,
                                                full.names = FALSE)))
            }
        d[file_test("-f", file.path(dir, d))]
    }

    if(!dir.exists(dir))
        stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir), domain = NA)
    else
        dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)

    wrong_things <- list(R = character(), man = character(),
                         demo = character(), `inst/doc` = character())

    code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
    if(dir.exists(code_dir)) {
        all_files <- mydir(code_dir)
        ## Under Windows, need a Makefile.win for methods.
        R_files <- c("sysdata.rda", "Makefile.win", "Makefile.ucrt",
                     list_files_with_type(code_dir, "code",
                                          full.names = FALSE,
                                          OS_subdirs = OS_subdirs))
        wrong <- setdiff(all_files, R_files)
        ## now configure might generate files in this directory
        generated <- which(endsWith(wrong, ".in"))
        if(length(generated)) wrong <- wrong[-generated]
        if(length(wrong)) {
            wrong_things$R <- wrong
            if(doDelete) unlink(file.path(dir, "R", wrong))
        }
    }

    man_dir <- file.path(dir, "man")
    if(dir.exists(man_dir)) {
        all_files <- mydir(man_dir)
        man_files <- list_files_with_type(man_dir, "docs",
                                          full.names = FALSE,
                                          OS_subdirs = OS_subdirs)
        wrong <- setdiff(all_files, man_files)
        if(length(wrong)) {
            wrong_things$man <- wrong
            if(doDelete) unlink(file.path(dir, "man", wrong))
        }
    }

    demo_dir <- file.path(dir, "demo")
    if(dir.exists(demo_dir)) {
        all_files <- mydir(demo_dir)
        demo_files <- list_files_with_type(demo_dir, "demo",
                                           full.names = FALSE)
        save_files <- paste0(sub("r$", "R", demo_files), "out.save")
        wrong <- setdiff(all_files,
                         c("00Index", demo_files, save_files))
        if(length(wrong)) {
            wrong_things$demo <- wrong
            if(doDelete) unlink(file.path(dir, "demo", wrong))
        }
    }

    ## check installed vignette material
    subdir <- file.path("inst", "doc")
    vigns <-
        .package_vignettes_via_call_to_R(dir = dir, subdirs = subdir)
    if (!is.null(vigns) && length(vigns$docs)) {
        vignettes <- basename(vigns$docs)

        ## Add vignette output files, if they exist
        tryCatch({
            vigns <-
                .package_vignettes_via_call_to_R(dir = dir,
                                                 subdirs = subdir,
                                                 output = TRUE)
            vignettes <- c(vignettes, basename(vigns$outputs))
        }, error = function(ex) {})

        ## 'the file names should start with an ASCII letter and be comprised
        ## entirely of ASCII letters or digits or hyphen or underscore'
        ## Do this in a locale-independent way.
        OK <- grep("^[ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZabcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz][ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZabcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz0123456789._-]+$", vignettes)
        wrong <- vignettes
        if(length(OK)) wrong <- wrong[-OK]
        if(length(wrong)) wrong_things$`inst/doc` <- wrong
    }

    class(wrong_things) <- "subdir_tests"
    wrong_things
}

format.subdir_tests <-
function(x, ...)
{
    .fmt <- function(i) {
        tag <- names(x)[i]
        c(sprintf("Subdirectory '%s' contains invalid file names:",
                  tag),
          .pretty_format(x[[i]]))
    }

    as.character(unlist(lapply(which(lengths(x) > 0L), .fmt)))
}

### * .check_package_ASCII_code

## FIXME: respect_quotes=TRUE does not work well for multi-line quotes
.check_package_ASCII_code <-
function(dir, respect_quotes = FALSE) # by default also look inside quotes
{
    if(!dir.exists(dir))
        stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir), domain = NA)

    dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
    wrong_things <- character()
    for(f in c(file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE"),
               list_files_with_type(file.path(dir, "R"), "code",
                                    OS_subdirs = c("unix", "windows")))) {
        text <- readLines(f, warn = FALSE)
        if (.Call(C_check_nonASCII, text, respect_quotes))
            wrong_things <- c(wrong_things, f)
    }
    if(length(wrong_things)) {
        wrong_things <- substring(wrong_things, nchar(dir) + 2L)
        cat(wrong_things, sep = "\n")
    }
    invisible(wrong_things)
}

### * .check_package_code_syntax

.check_package_code_syntax <-
function(dir)
{
    if(!dir.exists(dir))
        stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir), domain = NA)
    else
        dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
    dir_name <- basename(dir)

    dfile <- file.path(dirname(dir), "DESCRIPTION")
    enc <- if(file.exists(dfile))
        .read_description(dfile)["Encoding"] else NA

    ## This was always run in the C locale < 2.5.0
    ## However, what chars are alphabetic depends on the locale,
    ## so as from R 2.5.0 we try to set a locale.
    ## Any package with no declared encoding should have only ASCII R
    ## code.
    oLC_ct <- Sys.getlocale("LC_CTYPE"); on.exit(Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", oLC_ct))
    if(!is.na(enc)) {  ## try to use the declared encoding
        if(.Platform$OS.type == "windows" && !l10n_info()[["UTF-8"]]) {
            ## "C" is in fact "en"
            switch(enc,
                   "latin2" = Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", 'polish'),
                   Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", "C")
                   )
        } else {
            loc <- Sys.getenv("R_ENCODING_LOCALES", NA_character_)
            if(!is.na(loc)) {
                loc <- strsplit(strsplit(loc, ":")[[1L]], "=")
                nm <- lapply(loc, `[[`, 1L)
                loc <- lapply(loc, `[[`, 2L)
                names(loc) <- nm
                if(!is.null(l <- loc[[enc]]))
                    Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", l)
                else
                    Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", "C")

            } else if(l10n_info()[["UTF-8"]]) {
                ## the hope is that the conversion to UTF-8 works and
                ## so we can validly test the code in the current locale.
            } else {
                ## these are the POSIX forms, but of course not all Unixen
                ## abide by POSIX.  These locales need not exist, but
                ## do in glibc.
                switch(enc,
                       "latin1" = Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", "en_US"),
                       "utf-8"  =,  # not valid, but used
                       "UTF-8"  = Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", "en_US.UTF-8"),
                       "latin2" = Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", "pl_PL"),
                       "latin9" = Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE",
                       "fr_FR.iso885915@euro"),
                       Sys.setlocale("LC_CTYPE", "C")
                      )
            }
        }
    }

    collect_parse_woes <- function(f) {
        .error <- .warnings <- character()
        file <- file.path(dir, f)
        if(!is.na(enc) &&
           (Sys.getlocale("LC_CTYPE") %notin% c("C", "POSIX"))) {
            lines <- iconv(readLines(file, warn = FALSE), from = enc, to = "",
                           sub = "byte")
            withCallingHandlers(tryCatch(str2expression(lines),
                                         error = function(e)
                                         .error <<- conditionMessage(e)),
                                warning = function(e) {
                                    .warnings <<- c(.warnings,
                                                    conditionMessage(e))
                                    tryInvokeRestart("muffleWarning")
                                })
        } else {
            withCallingHandlers(tryCatch(parse(file),
                                         error = function(e)
                                         .error <<- conditionMessage(e)),
                                warning = function(e) {
                                    .warnings <<- c(.warnings,
                                                    conditionMessage(e))
                                    tryInvokeRestart("muffleWarning")
                                })
        }
        ## (We show offending file paths starting with the base of the
        ## given directory as this provides "nicer" output ...)
        if(length(.error) || length(.warnings))
            list(File = file.path(dir_name, f),
                 Error = .error, Warnings = .warnings)
        else
            NULL
    }

    out <-
        lapply(list_files_with_type(dir, "code", full.names = FALSE,
                                    OS_subdirs = c("unix", "windows")),
               collect_parse_woes)
    structure(out[lengths(out) > 0L],
              class = "check_package_code_syntax")
}

print.check_package_code_syntax <-
function(x, ...)
{
    first <- TRUE
    for(i in seq_along(x)) {
        if(!first) writeLines("") else first <- FALSE
        xi <- x[[i]]
        if(length(xi$Error)) {
            msg <- gsub("\n", "\n  ", sub("[^:]*: *", "", xi$Error),
                        perl = TRUE, useBytes = TRUE)
            writeLines(c(sprintf("Error in file '%s':", xi$File),
                         paste0("  ", msg)))
        }
        if(len <- length(xi$Warnings))
            writeLines(c(sprintf(ngettext(len,
                                          "Warning in file %s:",
                                          "Warnings in file %s:"),
                                 sQuote(xi$File)),
                         paste0("  ", gsub("\n\n", "\n  ", xi$Warnings,
                                           perl = TRUE, useBytes = TRUE))))
    }
    invisible(x)
}

### * .check_package_code_shlib

.check_package_code_shlib <-
function(dir)
{
    predicate <- function(e) {
        ((length(e) > 1L)
            && (length(x <- as.character(e[[1L]])) == 1L)
            && (x %in% c("library.dynam", "library.dynam.unload"))
            && (length(y <- e[[2L]]) == 1L)
            && is.character(y)
            && grepl("\\.(so|sl|dll)$", y))
    }

    x <- Filter(length,
                .find_calls_in_package_code(dir, predicate,
                                            recursive = TRUE))

    ## Because we really only need this for calling from R CMD check, we
    ## produce output here in case we found something.
    if(length(x))
        writeLines(c(unlist(Map(.format_calls_in_file, x, names(x))),
                     ""))
    ## (Could easily provide format() and print() methods ...)

    invisible(x)
}

### * .check_package_code_startup_functions

.check_package_code_startup_functions <-
function(dir)
{
    bad_call_names <-
        unlist(.bad_call_names_in_startup_functions)

    .check_startup_function <- function(fcode, fname) {
        out <- list()
        nms <- names(fcode[[2L]])
        ## Check names of formals.
        ## Allow anything containing ... (for now); otherwise, insist on
        ## length two with names starting with lib and pkg, respectively.
        if(("..." %notin% nms) &&
           ((length(nms) != 2L) ||
            any(substr(nms, 1L, 3L) != c("lib", "pkg"))))
            out$bad_arg_names <- nms
        ## Look at all calls (not only at top level).
        calls <- .find_calls(fcode[[3L]], recursive = TRUE)
        if(!length(calls)) return(out)
        cnames <- .call_names(calls)
        ## And pick the ones which should not be there ...
        bcn <- bad_call_names
        if(fname == ".onAttach") bcn <- c(bcn, "library.dynam")
        if(fname == ".onLoad") bcn <- c(bcn, "packageStartupMessage")
        ind <- (cnames %in% bcn)
        if(any(ind)) {
            calls <- calls[ind]
            cnames <- cnames[ind]
            ## Exclude library(help = ......) calls.
            pos <- which(cnames == "library")
            if(length(pos)) {
                pos <- pos[vapply(calls[pos],
                                  function(e)
                                      any(names(e)[-1L] == "help"),
                                  NA)]
                ## Could also match.call(base::library, e) first ...
                if(length(pos)) {
                    calls <- calls[-pos]
                    cnames <- cnames[-pos]
                }
            }
            if(length(calls)) {
                out$bad_calls <-
                    list(calls = calls, names = cnames)
            }
        }
        out
    }

    calls <- .find_calls_in_package_code(dir,
                                         .worker =
                                         .get_startup_function_calls_in_file)
    FL <- unlist(lapply(calls, `[[`, ".First.lib"))
    calls <- Filter(length,
                    lapply(calls,
                           function(e)
                           Filter(length,
                                  Map(.check_startup_function,
                                      e, names(e)))))
    if(length(FL)) attr(calls, ".First.lib") <- TRUE
    class(calls) <- "check_package_code_startup_functions"
    calls
}

format.check_package_code_startup_functions <-
function(x, ...)
{
    res <- if(!is.null(attr(x, ".First.lib"))) "NB: .First.lib is obsolete and will not be used in R >= 3.0.0" else character()
    if(length(x)) {

        ## Flatten out doubly recursive list of functions within list of
        ## files structure for computing summary messages.
        y <- unlist(x, recursive = FALSE)

        has_bad_wrong_args <-
            "bad_arg_names" %in% unlist(lapply(y, names))
        calls <-
            unique(unlist(lapply(y,
                                 function(e) e[["bad_calls"]][["names"]])))
        has_bad_calls_for_load <-
            any(calls %in% .bad_call_names_in_startup_functions$load)
        has_bad_calls_for_output <-
            any(calls %in% .bad_call_names_in_startup_functions$output)
        has_unsafe_calls <-
            any(calls %in% .bad_call_names_in_startup_functions$unsafe)

        .fmt_entries_for_file <- function(e, f) {
            c(gettextf("File %s:", sQuote(f)),
              unlist(Map(.fmt_entries_for_function, e, names(e))),
              "")
        }

        .fmt_entries_for_function <- function(e, f) {
            c(if(length(bad <- e[["bad_arg_names"]])) {
                gettextf("  %s has wrong argument list %s",
                         f, sQuote(paste(bad, collapse = ", ")))
            },
              if(length(bad <- e[["bad_calls"]])) {
                  c(gettextf("  %s calls:", f),
                    paste0("    ",
                           unlist(lapply(bad[["calls"]], function(e)
                                         paste(deparse(e), collapse = "")))))
              })
        }

        res <-
            c(res,
              unlist(Map(.fmt_entries_for_file, x, names(x)),
                     use.names = FALSE),
              if(has_bad_wrong_args)
              strwrap(gettextf("Package startup functions should have two arguments with names starting with %s and %s, respectively.",
                               sQuote("lib"), sQuote("pkg")),
                      exdent = 2L),
              if(has_bad_calls_for_load)
              strwrap(gettextf("Package startup functions should not change the search path."),
                      exdent = 2L),
              if(has_bad_calls_for_output)
              strwrap(gettextf("Package startup functions should use %s to generate messages.",
                               sQuote("packageStartupMessage")),
                      exdent = 2L),
              if(has_unsafe_calls)
              strwrap(gettextf("Package startup functions should not call %s.",
                               sQuote("installed.packages")),
                      exdent = 2L),
              gettextf("See section %s in '%s'.",
                       sQuote("Good practice"), "?.onAttach")
              )
    }
    res
}

.bad_call_names_in_startup_functions <-
    list(load = c("library", "require"),
         output = c("cat", "message", "print", "writeLines"),
         unsafe = c("installed.packages", "utils::installed.packages"))

.get_startup_function_calls_in_file <-
function(file, encoding = NA)
{
    exprs <- .parse_code_file(file, encoding)

    ## Use a custom gatherer rather than .find_calls() with a suitable
    ## predicate so that we record the name of the startup function in
    ## which the calls were found.
    calls <- list()
    for(e in exprs) {
        if((length(e) > 2L) &&
           (is.name(x <- e[[1L]])) &&
           (as.character(x) %in% c("<-", "=")) &&
           (length(y <- as.character(e[[2L]])) == 1L) &&
           (y %in% c(".First.lib", ".onAttach", ".onLoad")) &&
           (is.call(z <- e[[3L]])) &&
           (length(w <- as.character(z[[1L]])) == 1L) &&
           (w == "function")) {
            new <- list(z)
            names(new) <- as.character(y)
            calls <- c(calls, new)
        }
    }
    calls
}

.call_names <-
function(x)
    vapply(x, function(e) deparse1(e[[1L]]), "")


### * .check_package_code_unload_functions

.check_package_code_unload_functions <-
function(dir)
{
    bad_call_names <- "library.dynam.unload"

    .check_unload_function <- function(fcode, fname) {
        out <- list()
        nms <- names(fcode[[2L]])
        ## Check names of formals.
        ## Allow anything containing ... (for now); otherwise, insist on
        ## length one with names starting with lib.
        if("..." %notin% nms && (length(nms) != 1L || !startsWith(nms, "lib")))
            out$bad_arg_names <- nms
        ## Look at all calls (not only at top level).
        calls <- .find_calls(fcode[[3L]], recursive = TRUE)
        if(!length(calls)) return(out)
        cnames <- .call_names(calls)
        ## And pick the ones which should not be there ...
        ind <- cnames %in% bad_call_names
        if(any(ind))
            out$bad_calls <- list(calls = calls[ind], names = cnames[ind])
        out
    }

    calls <- .find_calls_in_package_code(dir,
                                         .worker =
                                         .get_unload_function_calls_in_file)
    LL <- unlist(lapply(calls, `[[`, ".Last.lib"))
    calls <- Filter(length,
                    lapply(calls,
                           function(e)
                           Filter(length,
                                  Map(.check_unload_function,
                                      e, names(e)))))
    if(length(LL) &&
       !inherits(tryCatch(nsInfo <-
                              parseNamespaceFile(basename(dir),
                                                 dirname(dir)),
                          error = identity),
                 "error")) {
        code_objs <- ".Last.lib"
        OK <- intersect(code_objs, nsInfo$exports)
        for(p in nsInfo$exportPatterns)
            OK <- c(OK, grep(p, code_objs, value = TRUE))
        if(!length(OK)) attr(calls, ".Last.lib") <- TRUE
    }
    class(calls) <- "check_package_code_unload_functions"
    calls
}

format.check_package_code_unload_functions <-
function(x, ...)
{
    res <- if(!is.null(attr(x, ".Last.lib"))) "NB: .Last.lib will not be used unless it is exported" else character()
    if(length(x)) {

        ## Flatten out doubly recursive list of functions within list of
        ## files structure for computing summary messages.
        y <- unlist(x, recursive = FALSE)

        has_bad_wrong_args <-
            "bad_arg_names" %in% unlist(lapply(y, names))
##        calls <-
##            unique(unlist(lapply(y,
##                                 function(e) e[["bad_calls"]][["names"]])))
        .fmt_entries_for_file <- function(e, f) {
            c(gettextf("File %s:", sQuote(f)),
              unlist(Map(.fmt_entries_for_function, e, names(e))),
              "")
        }

        .fmt_entries_for_function <- function(e, f) {
            c(if(length(bad <- e[["bad_arg_names"]])) {
                gettextf("  %s has wrong argument list %s",
                         f, sQuote(paste(bad, collapse = ", ")))
            },
              if(length(bad <- e[["bad_calls"]])) {
                  c(gettextf("  %s calls:", f),
                    paste0("    ",
                           unlist(lapply(bad[["calls"]], function(e)
                                         paste(deparse(e), collapse = "")))))
              })
        }

        res <-
            c(res,
              unlist(Map(.fmt_entries_for_file, x, names(x)),
                     use.names = FALSE),
              if(has_bad_wrong_args)
              strwrap(gettextf("Package detach functions should have one argument with name starting with %s.", sQuote("lib")),
                      exdent = 2L),
              if(length(call))
              strwrap(gettextf("Package detach functions should not call %s.",
                               sQuote("library.dynam.unload")),
                      exdent = 2L),
              gettextf("See section %s in '%s'.",
                       sQuote("Good practice"), "?.Last.lib")
              )
    }
    res
}

.get_unload_function_calls_in_file <-
function(file, encoding = NA)
{
    exprs <- .parse_code_file(file, encoding)

    ## Use a custom gatherer rather than .find_calls() with a suitable
    ## predicate so that we record the name of the unload function in
    ## which the calls were found.
    calls <- list()
    for(e in exprs) {
        if((length(e) > 2L) &&
           (is.name(x <- e[[1L]])) &&
           (as.character(x) %in% c("<-", "=")) &&
           (length(y <- as.character(e[[2L]])) == 1L) &&
           (y %in% c(".Last.lib", ".onDetach")) &&
           (is.call(z <- e[[3L]])) &&
           (length(w <- as.character(z[[1L]])) == 1L) &&
           (w == "function")) {
            new <- list(z)
            names(new) <- as.character(y)
            calls <- c(calls, new)
        }
    }
    calls
}

### * .check_package_code_tampers

.check_package_code_tampers <-
function(dir)
{
    dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
    pkgname <- if(file.exists(dfile))
        .read_description(dfile)["Package"] else ""

    predicate <- function(e) {
        if(length(e) <= 1L) return(FALSE)
        if(as.character(e[[1L]])[1L] %in% "unlockBinding") {
            e3 <- as.character(e[[3L]])
            if (e3[[1L]] == "asNamespace") e3 <- as.character(e[[3L]][[2L]])
            ## maybe this should use any()
            return(e3 != pkgname)
        }
        if((as.character(e[[1L]])[1L] %in% ".Internal") &&
           as.character(e[[2L]][[1L]]) == "unlockBinding") return(TRUE)
        if(as.character(e[[1L]])[1L] %in% "assignInNamespace") {
            e3 <- as.character(e[[4L]])
            if (e3[[1L]] == "asNamespace") e3 <- as.character(e[[4L]][[2L]])
            ## maybe this should use any()
            return(e3 != pkgname)
        }
        FALSE
    }

    x <- Filter(length,
                .find_calls_in_package_code(dir, predicate,
                                            recursive = TRUE))

    ## Because we really only need this for calling from R CMD check, we
    ## produce output here in case we found something.
    if(length(x))
        writeLines(unlist(Map(.format_calls_in_file, x, names(x))))
    ## (Could easily provide format() and print() methods ...)

    invisible(x)
}

### * .check_package_code_assign_to_globalenv

.check_package_code_assign_to_globalenv <-
function(dir)
{
    predicate <- function(e) {
        if(!is.call(e) ||
           (length(x <- as.character(e[[1L]])) != 1L) ||
           (x != "assign"))
            return(FALSE)
        e <- e[as.character(e) != "..."]
        ## Capture assignments to global env unless to .Random.seed.
        ## (This may fail for conditionalized code not meant for R
        ## [e.g., argument 'where'].)
        mc <- tryCatch(match.call(base::assign, e), error = identity)
        if(inherits(mc, "error") || identical(mc$x, ".Random.seed"))
            return(FALSE)
        if(!is.null(env <- mc$envir) &&
           identical(tryCatch(eval(env),
                              error = identity),
                     globalenv()))
            return(TRUE)
        if(!is.null(pos <- mc$pos) &&
           identical(tryCatch(eval(call("as.environment", pos)),
                              error = identity),
                     globalenv()))
            return(TRUE)
        FALSE
    }

    calls <- Filter(length,
                    .find_calls_in_package_code(dir, predicate,
                                                recursive = TRUE))
    class(calls) <- "check_package_code_assign_to_globalenv"
    calls
}

format.check_package_code_assign_to_globalenv <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(!length(x)) return(character())

    c("Found the following assignments to the global environment:",
      unlist(Map(.format_calls_in_file, x, names(x))))
}

### * .check_package_code_attach

.check_package_code_attach <-
function(dir)
{
    predicate <- function(e)
    ((length(x <- as.character(e[[1L]])) == 1L) &&
     (x == "attach"))

    calls <- Filter(length,
                    .find_calls_in_package_code(dir, predicate,
                                                recursive = TRUE))
    class(calls) <- "check_package_code_attach"
    calls
}

format.check_package_code_attach <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(!length(x)) return(character())

    c("Found the following calls to attach():",
      unlist(Map(.format_calls_in_file, x, names(x))))
}

### * .check_package_code_data_into_globalenv

.check_package_code_data_into_globalenv <-
function(dir)
{
    predicate <- function(e) {
        if(!is.call(e) ||
           (length(x <- as.character(e[[1L]])) != 1L) ||
           (x != "data"))
            return(FALSE)
        ## As data() has usage
        ##   data(..., list = character(), package = NULL, lib.loc = NULL,
        ##        verbose = getOption("verbose"), envir = .GlobalEnv))
        ## argument 'envir' must be matched exactly, and calls which
        ## only have the last four arguments do not load any data.
        env <- e$envir
        tab <- c("package", "lib.loc", "verbose", "envir")
        if(!is.null(nms <- names(e)))
            e <- e[nms %notin% tab]
        ((length(e) > 1L) &&
         (is.null(env) ||
          (is.name(env) && as.character(env) == ".GlobalEnv") ||
          (is.call(env) && as.character(env[[1L]]) == "globalenv")))
    }

    calls <- Filter(length,
                    .find_calls_in_package_code(dir, predicate,
                                                recursive = TRUE))
    class(calls) <- "check_package_code_data_into_globalenv"
    calls
}

format.check_package_code_data_into_globalenv <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(!length(x)) return(character())

    c("Found the following calls to data() loading into the global environment:",
      unlist(Map(.format_calls_in_file, x, names(x))))
}

### * .check_package_code_class_is_string

## Could easily make this return something classed with suitable
## format() and print() methods ...

.check_package_code_class_is_string <-
function(dir) {
    funA <- function(e) {
        if(is.call(e) &&
           (length(e) >= 2L) &&
           (length(s <- as.character(e[[1L]])) == 1L)) {
            if(s %in% c("(", "!"))
                return(Recall(e[[2L]]))
            else if(s %in% c("||", "&&", "|", "&"))
                return(Recall(e[[2L]]) || Recall(e[[3L]]))
            else if(s %in% c("==", "!=") &&
                    is.call(e2 <- e[[2L]]) &&
                    (as.character(e2[[1L]])[1L] == "class") &&
                    is.character(e[[3L]]))
                return(TRUE)
        }
        FALSE
    }
    funB <- function(e) {
        if(is.call(e) &&
           (length(e) >= 2L) &&
           (as.character(e[[1L]])[1L] == "if"))
            return(funA(e[[2L]]))
        FALSE
    }
    x <- Filter(length,
                .find_calls_in_package_code(dir, funB, recursive = TRUE))
    if(length(x)) {
        s <- sprintf("File %s: %s",
                     sQuote(rep.int(names(x), lengths(x))),
                     vapply(unlist(x),
                            function(e)
                                sprintf("if (%s) ...", deparse1(e[[2L]])),
                            ""))
        writeLines(c("Found if() conditions comparing class() to string:",
                     s,
                     "Use inherits() (or maybe is()) instead."))
    }
    invisible(x)
}

### * .check_packages_used

.check_packages_used <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Argument handling.
    ns <- NULL
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!dir.exists(code_dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not contain R code",
                          dir),
                 domain = NA)
        if(basename(dir) != "base")
            .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
        code_env <- asNamespace(package)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        db <- .read_description(dfile)
        ## fake installs do not have this.
        nsfile <- file.path(dir, "Meta", "nsInfo.rds")
        if (file.exists(nsfile)) ns <- readRDS(nsfile)
        else {
            nsfile <- file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE")
            if(file.exists(nsfile))
                ns <- parseNamespaceFile(basename(dir), dirname(dir))
        }
    }
    else if(!missing(dir)) {
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        db <- .get_package_metadata(dir)
        nsfile <- file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE")
        if(file.exists(nsfile) &&
           inherits(tryCatch(ns <- parseNamespaceFile(basename(dir),
                                                      dirname(dir)),
                             error = identity),
                    "error"))
            ns <- NULL
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(dir.exists(code_dir)) {
            file <- tempfile()
            on.exit(unlink(file))
            if(!file.create(file)) stop("unable to create ", file)
            if(!all(.file_append_ensuring_LFs(file,
                                              list_files_with_type(code_dir,
                                                                   "code"))))
                stop("unable to write code files")
        } else return(invisible())
    }
    pkg_name <- db["Package"]
    depends <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Depends")
    imports <- imports0 <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Imports")
    suggests <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Suggests")
    enhances <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Enhances")

    ## it is OK to refer to yourself and non-S4 standard packages
    standard_package_names <-
        setdiff(.get_standard_package_names()$base,
                c("methods", "stats4"))
    ## It helps to know if non-default standard packages are require()d
    ## but safer to list them: compiler & parallel got included for years
    ## Some people depend on 'base'!
    default_package_names <-
        c("base", "datasets", "grDevices", "graphics", "stats", "utils")
    depends_suggests <- c(depends, suggests, enhances, pkg_name, default_package_names)
    imports <- c(imports, depends, suggests, enhances, pkg_name,
                 standard_package_names)
    ## the first argument could be named, or could be a variable name.
    ## we just have a stop list here.
    common_names <- c("pkg", "pkgName", "package", "pos", "dep_name")

    bad_exprs <- bad_deps <- bad_imps <- bad_prac <- character()
    bad_imports <- all_imports <- imp2 <- imp2f <- imp3 <- imp3f <- character()
    uses_methods <- FALSE
    find_bad_exprs <- function(e) {
        if(is.call(e) || is.expression(e)) {
            Call <- deparse(e[[1L]])[1L]
            if(Call %in% c("clusterEvalQ", "parallel::clusterEvalQ")) return()
            if((Call %in%
                c("library", "require", "loadNamespace", "requireNamespace"))
               && (length(e) >= 2L)) {
                ## We need to remove '...': OTOH the argument could be NULL
                keep <- vapply(e, function(x) deparse(x)[1L] != "...", NA)
                mc <- match.call(baseenv()[[Call]], e[keep])
                if(!is.null(pkg <- mc$package)) {
                    ## <NOTE>
                    ## Using code analysis, we really don't know which
                    ## package was called if character.only = TRUE and
                    ## the package argument is not a string constant.
                    ## (BTW, what if character.only is given a value
                    ## which is an expression evaluating to TRUE?)
                    dunno <- FALSE
                    if((Call %in% c("loadNamespace",
                                    "requireNamespace"))) {
                        if(!identical(class(pkg), "character"))
                            dunno <- TRUE
                    } else {
                        if(!identical(class(pkg), "character") &&
                           !is.null(co <- mc$character.only) &&
                           !isFALSE(co))
                            dunno <- TRUE
                    }
                    ## </NOTE>
                    ## <FIXME> could be inside substitute or a variable
                    ## and is in e.g. R.oo
                    if(!dunno) {
                        pkg <- as.character(pkg)
                        all_imports <<- c(all_imports, pkg)
                        if(Call %in% c("loadNamespace",
                                       "requireNamespace")) {
                            if(pkg %notin%
                               c(imports, depends_suggests, common_names))
                                bad_imps <<- c(bad_imps, pkg)
                        } else {
                            if(pkg %notin% c(depends_suggests, common_names))
                                bad_exprs <<- c(bad_exprs, pkg)
                            if(pkg %in% depends)
                                bad_deps <<- c(bad_deps, pkg)
                            ## assume calls to itself are to clusterEvalQ etc
                            else if (pkg != pkg_name)
                                bad_prac <<- c(bad_prac, pkg)
                        }
                    }
                }
            } else if(Call %in% "::") {
                pkg <- deparse(e[[2L]])
                all_imports <<- c(all_imports, pkg)
                if(pkg %notin% imports)
                    bad_imports <<- c(bad_imports, pkg)
                else {
                    imp2 <<- c(imp2, pkg)
                    imp2f <<- c(imp2f, deparse(e[[3L]]))
                }
            } else if(Call %in% ":::") {
                pkg <- deparse(e[[2L]])
                all_imports <<- c(all_imports, pkg)
                imp3 <<- c(imp3, pkg)
                imp3f <<- c(imp3f, deparse(e[[3L]]))
                if(pkg %notin% imports)
                    bad_imports <<- c(bad_imports, pkg)
            } else if(Call %in% c("setClass", "setMethod")) {
                uses_methods <<- TRUE
            } else if((Call %in% c("<-", "<<-")) &&
                      is.call(e[[2L]]) &&
                      is.call(e21 <- e[[2L]][[1L]]) &&
                      (deparse(e21[[1L]])[1L] %in% c("::", ":::"))) {
                ## For complex assignments like
                ##    pkg::fun(......) <- rhs
                ## need to look for replacement function 'fun<-' in pkg
                ## (PR#17613).
                e[[2L]][[1L]][[3L]] <-
                    as.name(paste0(deparse(e21[[3L]])[1L], "<-"))
            }
            for(i in seq_along(e)) Recall(e[[i]])
        } else if (is.pairlist(e))
            for(i in seq_along(e)) Recall(e[[i]])

    }

    if(!missing(package)) {
        ## <FIXME>
        ## Suggested way of checking for S4 metadata.
        ## Change to use as envir_has_S4_metadata() once this makes it
        ## into base or methods.
        if(length(objects(code_env, all.names = TRUE,
                          pattern = "^[.]__[CT]_")))
            uses_methods <- TRUE
        ## </FIXME>
        exprs <- lapply(ls(envir = code_env, all.names = TRUE),
                        function(f) {
                            f <- get(f, envir = code_env) # get is expensive
                            if(typeof(f) == "closure") pairlist(formals(f), body(f)) # else NULL
                        })
        if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
            ## Also check the code in S4 methods.
            ## This may find things twice.
            for(f in .get_S4_generics(code_env)) {
                mlist <- .get_S4_methods_list(f, code_env)
                exprs <- c(exprs, lapply(mlist, body))
            }
        }
    }
    else {
        enc <- db["Encoding"]
        if(!is.na(enc) &&
           (Sys.getlocale("LC_CTYPE") %notin% c("C", "POSIX"))) {
            ## FIXME: what if conversion fails on e.g. UTF-8 comments
            con <- file(file, encoding=enc)
            on.exit(close(con))
        } else con <- file
        exprs <-
            tryCatch(parse(file = con, n = -1L),
                     error = function(e)
                     stop(gettextf("parse error in file '%s':\n%s",
                                   file,
                                   .massage_file_parse_error(e)),
                               domain = NA, call. = FALSE))
    }
    for(i in seq_along(exprs)) find_bad_exprs(exprs[[i]])

    if(length(ns)) {
        imp <- c(ns$imports, ns$importClasses, ns$importMethods)
        if (length(imp)) {
            imp <- sapply(imp, function(x) x[[1L]])
            all_imports <- unique(c(imp, all_imports))
        }
    } else imp <- character()
    bad_imp <- setdiff(imports0, all_imports)

    ## All the non-default packages need to be imported from.
    depends_not_import <- setdiff(depends, c(imp, default_package_names))

    methods_message <-
        if(uses_methods && "methods" %notin% c(depends, imports))
            gettext("package 'methods' is used but not declared")
        else ""

    extras <- list(
        base = c("Sys.junction", "shell", "shell.exec"),
        grDevices = c("X11.options", "X11Font", "X11Fonts", "quartz",
        "quartz.options", "quartz.save", "quartzFont", "quartzFonts",
        "bringToTop", "msgWindow", "win.graph", "win.metafile", "win.print",
        "windows", "windows.options", "windowsFont", "windowsFonts"),
        parallel = c("mccollect", "mcparallel", "mc.reset.stream", "mcaffinity"),
        utils = c("nsl", "DLL.version", "Filters",
        "choose.dir", "choose.files", "getClipboardFormats",
        "getIdentification", "getWindowsHandle", "getWindowsHandles",
        "getWindowTitle", "loadRconsole", "readClipboard",
        "readRegistry", "setStatusBar", "setWindowTitle",
        "shortPathName", "win.version", "winDialog",
        "winDialogString", "winMenuAdd", "winMenuAddItem",
        "winMenuDel", "winMenuDelItem", "winMenuNames",
        "winMenuItems", "writeClipboard", "zip.unpack",
        "winProgressBar", "getWinProgressBar", "setWinProgressBar",
        "setInternet2", "arrangeWindows"),
        RODBC = c("odbcConnectAccess", "odbcConnectAccess2007",
        "odbcConnectDbase", "odbcConnectExcel", "odbcConnectExcel2007")
        )
    imp2un <- character()
    if(length(imp2)) { ## Try to check these are exported
        names(imp2f) <- imp2
        imp2 <- unique(imp2)
        imps <- split(imp2f, names(imp2f))
        for (p in names(imps)) {
            ## some people have these quoted:
            this <- imps[[p]]
            this <- sub('^"(.*)"$', "\\1", this)
            this <- sub("^'(.*)'$", "\\1", this)
            if (p %in% "base") {
                this <- setdiff(this, ls(baseenv(), all.names = TRUE))
                if(length(this))
                    imp2un <- c(imp2un, paste(p, this, sep = "::"))
                next
            }
            ns <- .getNamespace(p)
            value <- if(is.null(ns)) {
                ## this could be noisy
                tryCatch(suppressWarnings(suppressMessages(loadNamespace(p))),
                         error = function(e) e)
            } else NULL
            if (!inherits(value, "error")) {
                ns <- asNamespace(p)
                exps <- c(ls(envir = .getNamespaceInfo(ns, "exports"),
                             all.names = TRUE),
                          ls(envir = .getNamespaceInfo(ns, "lazydata"),
                             all.names = TRUE),
                          extras[[p]])
                this2 <- setdiff(this, exps)
                if(length(this2))
                    imp2un <- c(imp2un, paste(p, this2, sep = "::"))
            }
        }
    }

    names(imp3f) <- imp3
    ## Eliminate some methods ::: self-calls which we know are in fact
    ## necessary.
    if(pkg_name == "methods") {
        imp3f <- imp3f[(imp3 != "methods") |
                       (imp3f %notin% c(".class1",
                                        ".missingMethod",
                                        ".selectDotsMethod",
                                        ".setDummyField",
                                        ".InhSlotNames"))]
        imp3 <- names(imp3f)
    }
    imp3 <- unique(imp3)
    imp3self <- pkg_name %in% imp3
    imp3selfcalls <- as.vector(imp3f[names(imp3f) == pkg_name])
    imp3 <- setdiff(imp3, pkg_name)
    if(length(imp3)) {
        imp3f <- imp3f[names(imp3f) %in% imp3]
        imps <- split(imp3f, names(imp3f))
        imp32 <- imp3 <- imp3f <- imp3ff <- unknown <- character()
        for (p in names(imps)) {
            this <- imps[[p]]
            this <- sub('^"(.*)"$', "\\1", this)
            this <- sub("^'(.*)'$", "\\1", this)
            if (p %in% "base") {
                imp32 <- c(imp32, paste(p, this, sep = ":::"))
                next
            }
            ns <- .getNamespace(p)
            value <- if(is.null(ns)) {
                ## this could be noisy
                tryCatch(suppressWarnings(suppressMessages(loadNamespace(p))),
                         error = function(e) e)
            } else NULL
            if (inherits(value, "error")) {
                unknown <- c(unknown, p)
            } else {
                 exps <- c(ls(envir = getNamespaceInfo(p, "exports"),
                              all.names = TRUE), extras[[p]])
                 this2 <- this %in% exps
                 if (any(this2))
                     imp32 <- c(imp32, paste(p, this[this2], sep = ":::"))
                 if (any(!this2)) {
                     imp3 <- c(imp3, p)
                     this <- this[!this2]
                     pp <- ls(envir = asNamespace(p), all.names = TRUE)
                     this2 <- this %in% pp
                     if(any(this2))
                         imp3f <- c(imp3f, paste(p, this[this2], sep = ":::"))
                     if(any(!this2))
                         imp3ff <- c(imp3ff, paste(p, this[!this2], sep = ":::"))
                 }
            }
        }
        if(length(imp3f)) {
            ## remove other packages which have the same maintainer,
            ## but report references to itself.  Unless they should be :: .
            maintainers <-
                sapply(strsplit(imp3f, ":::", fixed = TRUE),
                       function(p) {
                           dfile <- system.file("DESCRIPTION", package = p[[1L]])
                           if(dfile == "") return("")
                           unname(.read_description(dfile)["Maintainer"])
                       })
            imp3f <- imp3f[(maintainers != db["Maintainer"])]
        }
    } else imp32 <- imp3f <- imp3ff <- unknown <- character()
    ## An unexported function only available on Windows, used in tools
    imp3ff <- setdiff(sort(unique(imp3ff)), "utils:::unpackPkgZip")
    res <- list(others = unique(bad_exprs),
                bad_practice = unique(bad_prac),
                imports = unique(bad_imports),
                imps = unique(bad_imps),
                in_depends = unique(bad_deps),
                unused_imports = bad_imp,
                depends_not_import = depends_not_import,
                imp2un = sort(unique(imp2un)),
                imp32 = sort(unique(imp32)),
                imp3 = imp3, imp3f = sort(unique(imp3f)),
                imp3ff = imp3ff, imp3self = imp3self,
                imp3selfcalls = sort(unique(imp3selfcalls)),
                imp3unknown = unknown,
                methods_message = methods_message)
    class(res) <- "check_packages_used"
    res
}

format.check_packages_used <-
function(x, ...)
{
    incoming <-
        identical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_PACKAGES_USED_CRAN_INCOMING_NOTES_",
                             "FALSE"),
                  "TRUE")
    ignore_unused_imports <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_PACKAGES_USED_IGNORE_UNUSED_IMPORTS_",
                                         "FALSE"))
                                        # ^^^^^ rather "TRUE" ??
    c(character(),
      if(length(xx <- x$imports)) {
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("'::' or ':::' imports not declared from:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)))
          } else {
              gettextf("'::' or ':::' import not declared from: %s", sQuote(xx))
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$others)) {
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("'library' or 'require' calls not declared from:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)))
          } else {
              gettextf("'library' or 'require' call not declared from: %s",
                       sQuote(xx))
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$imps)) {
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("'loadNamespace' or 'requireNamespace' calls not declared from:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)))
          } else {
              gettextf("'loadNamespace' or 'requireNamespace' call not declared from: %s",
                       sQuote(xx))
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$in_depends)) {
          msg <- "  Please remove these calls from your code."
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("'library' or 'require' calls to packages already attached by Depends:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)), msg)
          } else {
              c(gettextf("'library' or 'require' call to %s which was already attached by Depends.",
                         sQuote(xx)), msg)
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$bad_practice)) {
          msg <-
              "  Please use :: or requireNamespace() instead.\n  See section 'Suggested packages' in the 'Writing R Extensions' manual."
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("'library' or 'require' calls in package code:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)), msg)
          } else {
              c(gettextf("'library' or 'require' call to %s in package code.",
                         sQuote(xx)), msg)
          }
      },

      if(length(xx <- x$unused_imports) && !ignore_unused_imports) {
          msg <- "  All declared Imports should be used."
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("Namespaces in Imports field not imported from:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)), msg)
          } else {
              c(gettextf("Namespace in Imports field not imported from: %s",
                       sQuote(xx)), msg)
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$depends_not_import)) {
          msg <- c("  These packages need to be imported from (in the NAMESPACE file)",
                   "  for when this namespace is loaded but not attached.")
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("Packages in Depends field not imported from:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)), msg)
          } else {
              c(gettextf("Package in Depends field not imported from: %s",
                         sQuote(xx)), msg)
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$imp2un)) {
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("Missing or unexported objects:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)))
          } else {
              gettextf("Missing or unexported object: %s", sQuote(xx))
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$imp32)) { ## ' ' seems to get converted to dir quotes
          msg <- "See the note in ?`:::` about the use of this operator."
          msg <- strwrap(paste(msg, collapse = " "), indent = 2L, exdent = 2L)
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("':::' calls which should be '::':"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)), msg)
          } else {
              c(gettextf("':::' call which should be '::': %s",
                         sQuote(xx)), msg)
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$imp3ff)) {
           if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("Missing objects imported by ':::' calls:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)))
          } else {
              gettextf("Missing object imported by a ':::' call: %s",
                       sQuote(xx))
          }
     },
      if(length(xxx <- x$imp3f)) { ## ' ' seems to get converted to dir quotes
          msg <- "See the note in ?`:::` about the use of this operator."
          msg <- strwrap(paste(msg, collapse = " "), indent = 2L, exdent = 2L)
          if(incoming) {
              z <- sub(":::.*", "", xxx)
              base <- unlist(.get_standard_package_names()[c("base", "recommended")])
              if (any(z %in% base))
                  msg <- c(msg,
                           "  Including base/recommended package(s):",
                           .pretty_format(intersect(base, z)))
          }
          if(length(xxx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("Unexported objects imported by ':::' calls:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xxx)), msg)
          } else  if(length(xxx)) {
              c(gettextf("Unexported object imported by a ':::' call: %s",
                         sQuote(xxx)), msg)
          }
      },
      if(isTRUE(x$imp3self)) {
          msg <-
              c("There are ::: calls to the package's namespace in its code.",
                "A package almost never needs to use ::: for its own objects:")
          c(strwrap(paste(msg, collapse = " "), indent = 0L, exdent = 2L),
            .pretty_format(sort(x$imp3selfcalls)))
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$imp3unknown)) {
          msg <- "See the note in ?`:::` about the use of this operator."
          msg <- strwrap(paste(msg, collapse = " "), indent = 2L, exdent = 2L)
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("Unavailable namespaces imported from by ':::' calls:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)), msg)
          } else {
              c(gettextf("Unavailable namespace imported from by a ':::' call: %s",
                         sQuote(xx)), msg)
          }
      },
      if(length(xx <- x$data)) {
          if(length(xx) > 1L) {
              c(gettext("'data(package=)' calls not declared from:"),
                .pretty_format(sort(xx)))
          } else {
              gettextf("'data(package=)' call not declared from: %s",
                       sQuote(xx))
          }
      },
      if(nzchar(x$methods_message)) {
          x$methods_message
      })
}

### * .check_packages_used_in_examples

.check_packages_used_helper <-
function(db, files)
{
    pkg_name <- db["Package"]
    depends <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Depends")
    imports <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Imports")
    suggests <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Suggests")
    enhances <- .get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Enhances")

    ## it is OK to refer to yourself and standard packages
    standard_package_names <- .get_standard_package_names()$base
    depends_suggests <- c(depends, imports, suggests, enhances, pkg_name,
                          standard_package_names)
    ## the first argument could be named, or could be a variable name.
    ## we just have a stop list here.
    common_names <- c("pkg", "pkgName", "package", "pos")

    parse_errors <-
    bad_exprs <- character()
    bad_imports <- character()
    bad_data <- character()
    find_bad_exprs <- function(e) {
        if(is.call(e) || is.expression(e)) {
            Call <- deparse(e[[1L]])[1L]
            if((Call %in%
               c("library", "require", "loadNamespace", "requireNamespace"))
               && (length(e) >= 2L)) {
                ## We need to remove '...': OTOH the argument could be NULL
                keep <- vapply(e,
                               function(x) deparse(x)[1L] != "...",
                               NA)
                mc <- match.call(baseenv()[[Call]], e[keep])
                if(!is.null(pkg <- mc$package)) {
                    ## <NOTE>
                    ## Using code analysis, we really don't know which
                    ## package was called if character.only = TRUE and
                    ## the package argument is not a string constant.
                    ## (Btw, what if character.only is given a value
                    ## which is an expression evaluating to TRUE?)
                    dunno <- FALSE
                    if((Call %in% c("loadNamespace",
                                    "requireNamespace"))) {
                        if(!identical(class(pkg), "character"))
                            dunno <- TRUE
                    } else {
                        if(!identical(class(pkg), "character") &&
                           !is.null(co <- mc$character.only) &&
                           !isFALSE(co))
                            dunno <- TRUE
                    }
                    if(!dunno) {
                        pkg <- as.character(pkg)
                        if(pkg %notin% c(depends_suggests, common_names))
                            bad_exprs <<- c(bad_exprs, pkg)
                    }
                }
            } else if(Call %in%  "::") {
                pkg <- deparse(e[[2L]])
                if(! pkg %in% depends_suggests)
                    bad_imports <<- c(bad_imports, pkg)
            } else if(Call %in%  ":::") {
                pkg <- deparse(e[[2L]])
                if(! pkg %in% depends_suggests)
                    bad_imports <<- c(bad_imports, pkg)
            } else if((Call %in% "data" && length(e) >= 3L) ||
                      (Call %in% c("utils::data", "utils:::data"))) {
                mc <- match.call(utils::data, e)
                if(is.character(pkg <- mc$package) && pkg %notin% depends_suggests)
                    bad_data <<- c(bad_data, pkg)
            }

            for(i in seq_along(e)) Recall(e[[i]])
        }
    }

    if (is.character(files)) {
        for (f in files) {
            tryCatch({
                        ## This can give errors because the vignette etc
                        ## need not be in the session encoding.
                        exprs <- parse(file = f, n = -1L)
                        for(i in seq_along(exprs)) find_bad_exprs(exprs[[i]])
                     },
                     error = function(e) {
                         ## so ignore 'invalid multibyte character' errors.
                         msg <- .massage_file_parse_error(e)
                         if(!startsWith(msg, "invalid multibyte character"))
                         {
                             parse_errors <<- c(parse_errors, f)
                             warning(gettextf("parse error in file '%s':\n%s",
                                              f, msg),
                                     domain = NA, call. = FALSE)
                         }
                     })
        }
    } else {
        ## called for examples with translation
        tryCatch({
            exprs <- parse(file = files, n = -1L)
            for(i in seq_along(exprs)) find_bad_exprs(exprs[[i]])
        },
                 error = function(e)
                 warning(gettextf("parse error in file '%s':\n%s",
                                  summary(files)$description,
                                  .massage_file_parse_error(e)),
                         domain = NA, call. = FALSE))
    }

    res <- list(others = unique(bad_exprs),
                imports = unique(bad_imports),
                data = unique(bad_data),
                methods_message = ""
              , parse_errors = unique(parse_errors)
            )
    class(res) <- "check_packages_used"
    res
}

.check_packages_used_in_examples <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Argument handling.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        db <- .read_description(dfile)
    }
    else if(!missing(dir)) {
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir), domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
        db <- .read_description(dfile)
    }
    pkg_name <- db["Package"]

    file <- .createExdotR(pkg_name, dir, silent = TRUE,
                          commentDonttest = FALSE,
                          installed = !missing(package))
    if (is.null(file)) return(invisible(NULL)) # e.g, no examples
    enc <- db["Encoding"]
    if(!is.na(enc) &&
       (Sys.getlocale("LC_CTYPE") %notin% c("C", "POSIX"))) {
        ## Avoid conversion failing on e.g. UTF-8 comments
        ## con <- file(file, encoding = enc)
        lines <- iconv(readLines(file, warn = FALSE),
                       from = "UTF-8", to = "", sub = "byte")
        con <- textConnection(lines, name = file)
        on.exit(close(con), add = TRUE)
    } else con <- file

    .check_packages_used_helper(db, con)
}


### * .check_packages_used_in_tests

.check_packages_used_in_tests <-
function(dir, testdir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Argument handling.
    ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
    if(!dir.exists(dir))
        stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir), domain = NA)
    else
        dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
    dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
    db <- .read_description(dfile)

    testsrcdir <- file.path(dir, testdir)
    od <- setwd(testsrcdir)
    on.exit(setwd(od))
    Rinfiles <- list.files(".", pattern = "\\.Rin$")
    Rfiles <- list.files(".", pattern = "\\.[rR]$")
    if(testdir != "tests") {
        use_subdirs <- FALSE
    } else {
        use_subdirs <-
            Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_PACKAGES_USED_IN_TESTS_USE_SUBDIRS_",
                       "FALSE")
        use_subdirs <- config_val_to_logical(use_subdirs)
        if(use_subdirs) {
            subdirs <- c("testthat", "testit", "unitizer", "RUnit")
            subdirs <- subdirs[dir.exists(subdirs)]
            if(length(subdirs)) {
                Rfiles <-
                    c(Rfiles,
                      unlist(lapply(subdirs, list.files,
                                    pattern = "\\.[rR]$",
                                    full.names = TRUE),
                             use.names = FALSE))
            } else {
                use_subdirs <- FALSE
            }
        }
    }
    res <- .check_packages_used_helper(db, c(Rinfiles, Rfiles))
    if(any(lengths(bad <- res[1L : 3L]))) {
        ## Filter results against available package names to avoid (too
        ## many) false positives.
        ## <FIXME>
        ## Should really standardize getting available packages when
        ## checking.
        repos <- .get_standard_repository_URLs()
        available <- utils::available.packages(repos = repos)
        if (nrow(available)) # cannot filter when offline
        res[1L : 3L] <- lapply(bad, intersect, available[, "Package"])
    }
    res
}

### * .check_packages_used_in_vignettes

.check_packages_used_in_vignettes <-
function(package, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Argument handling.
    if(missing(package) || length(package) != 1L)
        stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
    dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
    ## FIXME: use Meta directory.
    db <- .read_description(file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION"))
    vinfo <- .package_vignettes_via_call_to_R(dir = dir,
                                              subdirs = "doc",
                                              source = TRUE)
    Rfiles <- unique(as.character(unlist(vinfo$sources)))
    .check_packages_used_helper(db, Rfiles)
}

### * .check_T_and_F

## T and F checking, next generation.
##
## What are we really trying to do?
##
## In R, T and F are "just" variables which upon startup are bound to
## TRUE and FALSE, respectively, in the base package/namespace.  Hence,
## if code uses "global" variables T and F and dynamic lookup is in
## place (for packages, if they do not have a namespace), there may be
## trouble in case T or F were redefined.  So we'd like to warn about
## these cases.
##
## A few things to note:
## * Package code top-level bindings *to* T and F are not a problem for
##   packages installed for lazy-loading (as the top-level T and F get
##   evaluated "appropriately" upon installation.
## * Code in examples using "global" T and F is always a problem, as
##   this is evaluated in the global envionment by examples().
## * There is no problem with package code using T and F as local
##   variables.
## * Functions in a namespace will always find the T or F in the
##   namespace, imports or base, never in the global environment.
##
## Our current idea is the following.  Function findGlobals() in
## codetools already provides a way to (approximately) determine the
## globals.  So we can try to get these and report them.
##
## Note that findGlobals() only works on closures, so we definitely miss
## top-level assignments to T or F.  This could be taken care of rather
## easily, though.
##
## Note also that we'd like to help people find where the offending
## globals were found.  Seems that codetools currently does not offer a
## way of recording e.g. the parent expression, so we do our own thing
## based on the legacy checkTnF code.

.check_T_and_F <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Seems that checking examples has several problems, and can result
    ## in "strange" diagnostic output.  Let's more or less disable this
    ## for the time being.
    check_examples <-
        isTRUE(as.logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_RD_EXAMPLES_T_AND_F_")))


    bad_closures <- character()
    bad_examples <- character()

    find_bad_closures <- function(env) {
        x <- lapply(as.list(env, all.names = TRUE, sorted = TRUE),
                    function(v) {
                        if (typeof(v) == "closure")
                            codetools::findGlobals(v)
                    })
        names(x)[vapply(x, function(s) any(s %in% c("T", "F")), NA)]
    }

    find_bad_examples <- function(txts) {
        env <- new.env(hash = TRUE) # might be many
        x <- lapply(txts,
                    function(txt) {
                        tryCatch({
                            eval(str2expression(
                                       paste("FOO <- function() {",
                                             paste(txt, collapse = "\n"),
                                             "}",
                                             collapse = "\n")),
                                 env)
                            find_bad_closures(env)
                        },
                                 error = function(e) character())
                    })
        names(txts)[lengths(x) > 0L]
    }

    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        if(check_examples)
            example_texts <-
                .get_example_texts_from_example_dir(file.path(dir, "R-ex"))
    }
    else {
        ## The dir case.
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(!packageHasNamespace(basename(dir), dirname(dir))
           && dir.exists(code_dir)) {
            code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
            dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
            meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile))
                .read_description(dfile)
            else
                character()
            .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
            bad_closures <- find_bad_closures(code_env)
        }
        if(check_examples)
            example_texts <- .get_example_texts_from_source_dir(dir)
    }

    if(check_examples)
        bad_examples <- find_bad_examples(example_texts)

    out <- list(bad_closures = bad_closures,
                bad_examples = bad_examples)
    class(out) <- "check_T_and_F"
    out
}

.get_example_texts_from_example_dir <-
function(dir)
{
    if(!dir.exists(dir)) return(NULL)
    files <- list_files_with_exts(dir, "R")
    texts <- lapply(files,
                    function(f) paste(readLines(f, warn = FALSE),
                                      collapse = "\n"))
    names(texts) <- files
    texts
}

.get_example_texts_from_source_dir <-
function(dir)
{
    if(!dir.exists(file.path(dir, "man"))) return(NULL)
    lapply(Rd_db(dir = dir), .Rd_get_example_code)
}

format.check_T_and_F <-
function(x, ...)
{
    c(character(),
      if(length(x$bad_closures)) {
          msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_closures),
                          "Found possibly global 'T' or 'F' in the following function:",
                          "Found possibly global 'T' or 'F' in the following functions:"
                          )
          c(strwrap(msg),
            .pretty_format(x$bad_closures))
      },
      if(length(x$bad_examples)) {
          msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_examples),
                          "Found possibly global 'T' or 'F' in the examples of the following Rd file:",
                          "Found possibly global 'T' or 'F' in the examples of the following Rd files:"
                          )
          c(strwrap(msg),
            paste0("  ", x$bad_examples))
      })
}

### * .check_bogus_return

## Find bogus 'return' statements probably intended as a return() call.
## This uses codetools::findGlobals() to find functions which rely on a
## global variable "return".
## The code is derived from .check_T_and_F above.

.check_bogus_return <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    bad_closures <- character()

    find_bad_closures <- function(env) {
        x <- lapply(as.list(env, all.names = TRUE, sorted = TRUE),
                    function(v) {
                        if (typeof(v) == "closure")
                            codetools::findGlobals(v, merge = FALSE)$variables
                    })
        names(x)[vapply(x, function(s) any(s %in% "return"), NA)]
    }

    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        if(package %notin% .get_standard_package_names()$base) {
            .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
            code_env <- asNamespace(package)
            bad_closures <- find_bad_closures(code_env)
        }
    }
    else {
        ## The dir case.
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(dir.exists(code_dir)) {
            code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
            dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
            meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile))
                .read_description(dfile)
            else
                character()
            .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
            bad_closures <- find_bad_closures(code_env)
        }
    }

    out <- list(bad_closures = bad_closures)
    class(out) <- "check_bogus_return"
    out
}

format.check_bogus_return <-
function(x, ...)
{
    c(character(),
      if(length(x$bad_closures)) {
          msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_closures),
                          "Possibly missing '()' after 'return' in the following function:",
                          "Possibly missing '()' after 'return' in the following functions:"
                          )
          c(strwrap(msg),
            .pretty_format(x$bad_closures))
      })
}


### * .check_dotIntenal

.check_dotInternal <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL, details = TRUE)
{
    bad_closures <- character()

    find_bad_closures <- function(env) {
        objects_in_env <- as.list(env, all.names = TRUE, sorted = TRUE)
        x <- lapply(objects_in_env,
                    function(v) {
                        if (typeof(v) == "closure")
                            codetools::findGlobals(v)
                    })
        names(x)[vapply(x, function(s) any(s %in% ".Internal"), NA)]
    }

    find_bad_S4methods <- function(env) {
        gens <- .get_S4_generics(code_env)
        x <- lapply(gens, function(f) {
            tab <- get(methods:::.TableMetaName(f, attr(f, "package")),
                       envir = code_env)
            ## The S4 'system' does **copy** base code into packages ....
            any(unlist(eapply(tab, function(v) !inherits(v, "derivedDefaultMethod") &&
                                   any(codetools::findGlobals(v) %in% ".Internal"))))
        })
        gens[unlist(x)]
    }

    find_bad_refClasses <- function(refs) {
        cl <- names(refs)
        x <- lapply(refs, function(z) {
            any(vapply(z,
                       function(v)
                           any(codetools::findGlobals(v) %in%
                               ".Internal"),
                       NA))
        })
        cl[unlist(x)]
    }


    bad_S4methods <- list()
    bad_refs <- character()
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        if(package %notin% .get_standard_package_names()$base) {
            .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
            code_env <- asNamespace(package)
            bad_closures <- find_bad_closures(code_env)
            if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
                bad_S4methods <- find_bad_S4methods(code_env)
                refs <- .get_ref_classes(code_env)
                if(length(refs)) bad_refs <- find_bad_refClasses(refs)
            }
        }
    }
    else {
        ## The dir case.
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(dir.exists(code_dir)) {
            code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
            dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
            meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile))
                .read_description(dfile)
            else
                character()
            .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
            bad_closures <- find_bad_closures(code_env)
        }
    }

    internals <- character()
    if (length(bad_closures) && details) {
        lapply(bad_closures, function(o) {
            v <- get(o, envir = code_env)
            calls <- .find_calls(v, recursive = TRUE)
            if(!length(calls)) return()
            calls <- calls[.call_names(calls) == ".Internal"]
            calls2 <- lapply(calls, `[`, 2L)
            calls3 <-
                sapply(calls2, function(x) sub("\\(.*", "", deparse(x)[1L]))
            internals <<- c(internals, calls3)
        })
    }
    out <- list(bad_closures = bad_closures, internals = internals,
                bad_S4methods = bad_S4methods, bad_refs = bad_refs)
    class(out) <- "check_dotInternal"
    out
}

format.check_dotInternal <-
function(x, ...)
{
    out <- if(length(x$bad_closures)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_closures),
                        "Found a .Internal call in the following function:",
                        "Found .Internal calls in the following functions:"
                        )
        out <- c(strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$bad_closures))
        if (length(unique(x$internals)))
            out <- c(out, "with calls to .Internal functions",
                     .pretty_format(sort(unique(x$internals))))
        out
    } else character()
    if(length(x$bad_S4methods)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_S4methods),
                        "Found a .Internal call in methods for the following S4 generic:",
                        "Found .Internal calls in methods for the following S4 generics:"
                        )
        out <- c(out, strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$bad_S4methods))
    }
    if(length(x$bad_refs)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_refs),
                        "Found a .Internal call in methods for the following reference class:",
                        "Found .Internal calls in methods for the following reference classes:"
                        )
        out <- c(out, strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$bad_refs))
    }
    out
}

### * .check_namespace

.check_namespace <-
function(dir)
{
    dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
    invisible(tryCatch(parseNamespaceFile(basename(dir), dirname(dir)),
                       error = function(e) {
                           writeLines("Invalid NAMESPACE file, parsing gives:")
                           stop(e)
                       }))
}

### * .check_citation

.check_citation <-
function(cfile, dir = NULL)
{
    cfile <- file_path_as_absolute(cfile)

    if(!is.null(dir)) {
        meta <- utils::packageDescription(basename(dir), dirname(dir))
        db <- .read_citation_quietly(cfile, meta)
        if(inherits(db, "error")) {
            msg <- conditionMessage(db)
            call <- conditionCall(db)
            if(is.null(call))
                msg <- c("Error: ", msg)
            else
                msg <- c("Error in ", deparse(call), ": ", msg)
            writeLines(paste(msg, collapse = ""))
        }
        return(invisible())
    }

    meta <- if(basename(dir <- dirname(cfile)) == "inst")
        as.list(.get_package_metadata(dirname(dir)))
    else
        NULL

    db <- tryCatch(suppressMessages(get_CITATION_entry_fields(cfile,
                                                              meta$Encoding)),
                   error = identity)

    if(inherits(db, "error")) {
        writeLines(conditionMessage(db))
        return(invisible())
    }

    if(!NROW(db)) return(invisible())

    bad <- Map(find_missing_required_BibTeX_fields, db$Entry, db$Fields,
               USE.NAMES = FALSE)
    ind <- vapply(bad, identical, NA_character_, FUN.VALUE = NA)
    if(length(pos <- which(ind))) {
        entries <- db$Entry[pos]
        entries <-
            ifelse(nchar(entries) < 20L,
                   entries,
                   paste(substr(entries, 1L, 20L), "[TRUNCATED]"))
        writeLines(sprintf("entry %d: invalid type %s",
                           pos, sQuote(entries)))
    }
    pos <- which(!ind & (lengths(bad) > 0L))
    if(length(pos)) {
        writeLines(strwrap(sprintf("entry %d (%s): missing required field(s) %s",
                                   pos,
                                   db$Entry[pos],
                                   vapply(bad[pos],
                                          function(s)
                                          paste(sQuote(s),
                                                collapse = ", "),
                                          "")),
                           indent = 0L, exdent = 2L))
    }
}

### * .check_package_parseRd

## FIXME: could use dumped files, except for use of encoding = "ASCII"
.check_package_parseRd <-
function(dir, silent = FALSE, def_enc = FALSE, minlevel = -1)
{
    enc <- .get_package_metadata(dir)["Encoding"]
    if(is.na(enc)) enc <- "ASCII"
    else def_enc <- TRUE
    macros <- loadPkgRdMacros(dir)
    ## UGLY! FIXME: add (something like) 'dir' as argument to checkRd() below!
    oenv <- Sys.getenv("_R_RD_MACROS_PACKAGE_DIR_", unset = NA)
    on.exit(if (!is.na(oenv)) Sys.setenv("_R_RD_MACROS_PACKAGE_DIR_" = oenv)
            else Sys.unsetenv("_R_RD_MACROS_PACKAGE_DIR_"))
    Sys.setenv("_R_RD_MACROS_PACKAGE_DIR_" = normalizePath(dir))

    pg <- list_files_with_type(file.path(dir, "man"), "docs", full.names = TRUE,
                               OS_subdirs = c("unix", "windows"))
    if(file.exists(nfile <- file.path(dir, "inst", "NEWS.Rd")))
        pg <- c(nfile, pg)
    bad <- character()
    for (f in pg) {
        ## FIXME: this may not work for no/fake install if the expressions
        ## involve the package under check.
        tmp <- tryCatch(suppressMessages(
            if (f == nfile)
                checkRd(f, encoding = "UTF-8", def_enc = TRUE,
                        stages = "install")
            else
                checkRd(f, encoding = enc, def_enc = def_enc,
                        macros = macros,
                        stages = c("build", "install", "render"))
        ), error = identity)
        if(inherits(tmp, "error")) {
            bad <- c(bad, f)
            if(!silent) message(geterrmessage())
        } else print(tmp, minlevel = minlevel)
    }
    if(length(bad)) bad <- sQuote(sub(".*/", "", bad))
    if(length(bad) > 1L)
        cat("problems found in ", paste(bad, collapse=", "), "\n", sep = "")
    else if(length(bad))
        cat("problem found in ", bad, "\n", sep = "")
    invisible()
}


### * .check_depdef

.check_depdef <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL, WINDOWS = FALSE)
{
    bad_depr <- c("plclust")

    bad_def <- c("La.eigen", "tetragamma", "pentagamma",
                 "package.description", "gammaCody",
                 "manglePackageName", ".readRDS", ".saveRDS",
                 "mem.limits", "trySilent", "traceOn", "traceOff",
                 "print.coefmat", "anovalist.lm", "lm.fit.null",
                 "lm.wfit.null", "glm.fit.null", "tkcmd",
                 "tkfile.tail", "tkfile.dir", "tkopen", "tkclose",
                 "tkputs", "tkread", "Rd_parse", "CRAN.packages",
                 "zip.file.extract",
                 "real", "as.real", "is.real",
                 ".find.package", ".path.package")

    ## X11 may not work on even a Unix-alike: it needs X support
    ## (optional) at install time and an X server at run time.
    bad_dev <- c("quartz", "x11", "X11")
    if(!WINDOWS)
        bad_dev <- c(bad_dev,  "windows", "win.graph", "win.metafile", "win.print")

    bad <- c(bad_depr, bad_def, bad_dev)
    bad_closures <- character()
    found <- character()

    find_bad_closures <- function(env) {
        objects_in_env <- as.list(env, all.names = TRUE, sorted = TRUE)
        x <- lapply(objects_in_env,
                    function(v) {
                        if (typeof(v) == "closure")
                            codetools::findGlobals(v)
                    })
        names(x)[vapply(x,
                        function(s) {
                            res <- any(s %in% bad)
                            if(res) found <<- c(found, s)
                            res
                        },
                        NA)]
    }

    find_bad_S4methods <- function(env) {
        gens <- .get_S4_generics(code_env)
        x <- lapply(gens, function(f) {
            tab <- get(methods:::.TableMetaName(f, attr(f, "package")),
                       envir = code_env)
            ## The S4 'system' does **copy** base code into packages ....
            any(unlist(eapply(tab, function(v) {
                if(!inherits(v, "derivedDefaultMethod")) FALSE
                else {
                    s <- codetools::findGlobals(v)
                    found <<- c(found, s)
                    any(s %in% bad)
                }
            })))
        })
        gens[unlist(x)]
    }

    find_bad_refClasses <- function(refs) {
        cl <- names(refs)
        x <- lapply(refs, function(z) {
            any(vapply(z,
                       function(v) {
                           s <- codetools::findGlobals(v)
                           found <<- c(found, s)
                           any(s %in% bad)
                       },
                       NA))
        })
        cl[unlist(x)]
    }


    ## FIXME: these are set but not used.
    bad_S4methods <- list()
    bad_refs <- character()
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        if(package %notin% .get_standard_package_names()$base) {
            .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
            code_env <- asNamespace(package)
            bad_closures <- find_bad_closures(code_env)
            if(.isMethodsDispatchOn()) {
                bad_S4methods <- find_bad_S4methods(code_env)
                refs <- .get_ref_classes(code_env)
                if(length(refs)) bad_refs <- find_bad_refClasses(refs)
            }
        }
    }
    else {
        ## The dir case.
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
        code_dir <- file.path(dir, "R")
        if(dir.exists(code_dir)) {
            code_env <- new.env(hash = TRUE)
            dfile <- file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION")
            meta <- if(file_test("-f", dfile))
                .read_description(dfile)
            else
                character()
            .source_assignments_in_code_dir(code_dir, code_env, meta)
            bad_closures <- find_bad_closures(code_env)
        }
    }

    found <- sort(unique(found))
    deprecated <- found[found %in% bad_depr]
    defunct <- found[found %in% bad_def]
    devices <- found[found %in% bad_dev]

    out <- list(bad_closures = bad_closures, deprecated = deprecated,
                defunct = defunct, devices = devices)
    class(out) <- "check_depdef"
    out
}

format.check_depdef <-
function(x, ...)
{
    out <- if(length(x$bad_closures)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_closures),
                        "Found an obsolete/platform-specific call in the following function:",
                        "Found an obsolete/platform-specific call in the following functions:"
                        )
        c(strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$bad_closures))
    } else character()
    if(length(x$bad_S4methods)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_S4methods),
                        "Found an obsolete/platform-specific call in methods for the following S4 generic:",
                        "Found an obsolete/platform-specific call in methods for the following S4 generics:"
                        )
        out <- c(out, strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$bad_S4methods))
    }
    if(length(x$bad_refs)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$bad_refs),
                        "Found an obsolete/platform-specific call in methods for the following reference class:",
                        "Found an obsolete/platform-specific call in methods for the following reference classes:"
                        )
        out <- c(out, strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$bad_refs))
    }
    if(length(x$deprecated)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$deprecated),
                        "Found the deprecated function:",
                        "Found the deprecated functions:"
                        )
        out <- c(out, strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$deprecated))
    }
    if(length(x$defunct)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$defunct),
                        "Found the defunct/removed function:",
                        "Found the defunct/removed functions:"
                        )
        out <- c(out, strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$defunct))
    }
    if(length(x$devices)) {
        msg <- ngettext(length(x$devices),
                        "Found the platform-specific device:",
                        "Found the platform-specific devices:"
                        )
        out <- c(out, strwrap(msg), .pretty_format(x$devices),
                 strwrap(paste("dev.new() is the preferred way to open a new device,",
                               "in the unlikely event one is needed.",
                               collapse = " ")))
    }
    out
}

### * .check_package_CRAN_incoming

## localOnly means to skip tests requiring Internet access.
## These are all done first.

.check_package_CRAN_incoming <-
function(dir, localOnly = FALSE, pkgSize = NA)
{
    out <- list()
    class(out) <- "check_package_CRAN_incoming"

    meta <- .get_package_metadata(dir, FALSE)
    lic_info <- analyze_license(meta["License"])
    ## Use later to indicate changes from FOSS to non-FOSS licence.
    foss <- lic_info$is_verified
    ## Record to notify about components extending a base license which
    ## permits extensions.
    if(length(extensions <- lic_info$extensions) &&
       ((length(components <- extensions$components) != 1L) ||
        (.license_component_is_for_stub_and_ok(components,
                                               dir) != 0L)) &&
       any(ind <- extensions$extensible)) {
        out$extensions <- extensions$components[ind]
        out$pointers <-
            Filter(length,
                   lapply(lic_info$pointers,
                          function(p) {
                              fp <- file.path(dir, p)
                              if(file_test("-f", fp)) {
                                  lines <- readLines(fp, warn = FALSE)
                                  ## Should this use the package
                                  ## encoding?
                                  ## (no, as we have LICENSE files with
                                  ## copyright signs in ASCII packages)
                                  pos <- grep("[^[:blank:]]", lines,
                                              useBytes = TRUE)
                                  c(p, if(len <- length(pos)) {
                                           lines[seq.int(from = pos[1L],
                                                         to = pos[len])]
                                  })
                              } else NULL
                          }))
    }

    out$Maintainer <- meta["Maintainer"]
    ## pick out 'display name'
    display <- gsub("<.*", "", as.vector(out$Maintainer))
    display <- sub("[[:space:]]+$", "",
                   sub("^[[:space:]]+", "", display, useBytes = TRUE),
                   useBytes = TRUE)
    ## RFC 5322 allows '.' in the display name, but 2822 did not.
    ## ',' separates email addresses.
    if(grepl("[,]", display, useBytes = TRUE) &&
       !grepl('^".*"$', display, useBytes = TRUE))
        out$Maintainer_needs_quotes <- TRUE
    if(!nzchar(display))
        out$empty_Maintainer_name <- TRUE
    ## Try to catch bad maintainer fields which give more than one
    ## person.  In principle, the field should be of the form
    ##   DISPLAY-NAME <ANGLE-ADDR>
    ## with the former (for simplicity) either a single quoted string,
    ## or several atoms.  (There are cases where <ANGLE-ADDR> does not
    ## follow whitespace, so simple tokenizing via scan() does not quite
    ## work.)
    check_maintainer_address <- function(s) {
        re <- paste0("^",
                     "[[:space:]]*",
                     "([^<]*|\"([^\"]|\\\\\")*\")", # display-name
                     "[[:space:]]*",
                     "(<[^>]+>)",           # angle-addr
                     "[[:space:]]*",
                     "(.*)",                # rest?
                     "[[:space:]]*",
                     "$")
        s <- unlist(regmatches(s, regexec(re, s)))
        length(s) && (s[5L] == "") ## && (s[2L] != "")
        ## (Adding the test for s[2L] would check for non-empty
        ## display-name which we already do separately.)
    }
    ## NOTE: perhaps whitespace should be canonicalized further above?
    maintainer <- gsub("\n", " ", meta["Maintainer"], fixed = TRUE)
    if((maintainer != "ORPHANED") &&
         !check_maintainer_address(maintainer))
        out$Maintainer_invalid_or_multi_person <- TRUE

    ver <- meta["Version"]
    if(is.na(ver))
        stop("Package has no 'Version' field", call. = FALSE)
    if(grepl("(^|[.-])0[0-9]+", ver) &&
       !grepl("^[0-9]{4}[.-][0-9]{2}", ver))
        out$version_with_leading_zeroes <- ver
    if((ver == "@VERSION@") &&
       !is.na(meta["Priority"]) &&
       (meta["Priority"] == "base"))
        ver <- meta["Version"] <- format(getRversion())
    unlisted_version <- unlist(package_version(ver))
    if(any(unlisted_version >= 1234 &
           unlisted_version != as.integer(format(Sys.Date(), "%Y"))) &&
       !config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_SKIP_LARGE_VERSION_",
                                         "FALSE")))
        out$version_with_large_components <- ver

    .aspell_package_description_for_CRAN <- function(dir, meta = NULL) {
        if(!is.null(meta)) {
            dir.create(dir <- tempfile(pattern = "aspell"))
            on.exit(unlink(dir, recursive = TRUE))
            .write_description(meta, file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION"))
        }
        ignore <-
            list(c("(?<=[ \t[:punct:]])'[^']*'(?=[ \t[:punct:]])",
                   "(?<=[ \t[:punct:]])([[:alnum:]]+::)?[[:alnum:]_.]*\\(\\)(?=[ \t[:punct:]])",
                   "(?<=[<])(https?://|DOI:|doi:|arXiv:)[^>]+(?=[>])"),
                 perl = TRUE)
        utils:::aspell_package_description(dir,
                                           ignore = ignore,
                                           control =
                                               c("--master=en_US",
                                                 "--add-extra-dicts=en_GB"),
                                           program = "aspell",
                                           dictionaries = "en_stats")
    }

    language <- meta["Language"]
    if((is.na(language) ||
        (language == "en") ||
        startsWith(language, "en-")) &&
       config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_USE_ASPELL_",
                                        "FALSE"))) {
        a <- tryCatch(.aspell_package_description_for_CRAN(dir),
                      error = identity)
        if(inherits(a, "error"))
            out$aspell_package_description_error <- conditionMessage(a)
        else if(NROW(a))
            out$spelling <- a
    }

    parse_description_field <- function(desc, field, default)
        str_parse_logic(desc[field], default=default)

    ## Check for possibly mis-spelled field names.
    nms <- names(meta)
    stdNms <- .get_standard_DESCRIPTION_fields()
    nms <- nms[nms %notin% stdNms &
               !grepl(paste0("^(",
                             paste(c("X-CRAN",
                                     "X-schema.org",
                                     "Repository/R-Forge",
                                     "VCS/",
                                     "Config/"),
                                   collapse = "|"),
                             ")"),
                      nms)]
    if(length(nms) && ## Allow maintainer notes  <stdName>Note :
       length(nms <- nms[nms %notin% paste0(stdNms,"Note")]))
        out$fields <- nms


    uses <- BUGS <- character()
    for (field in c("Depends", "Imports", "Suggests")) {
        p <- strsplit(meta[field], " *, *")[[1L]]
        ## multicore has been superseded by parallel.  Almost all of
        ## snow has been too, so it should be optional.
        ## <NOTE>
        ## However, as of 2024-08 there are still 40 and 64 CRAN
        ## packages which at least suggest snow or doSNOW, respectively,
        ## apparently needing the functionality of snow not ported to
        ## parallel (MPI, ...).  Hence better to no longer NOTE their
        ## use.
        ##   p2 <- grep("^(multicore|snow|doSNOW)( |\\(|$)", p, value = TRUE)
        ##   uses <- c(uses, p2)
        ## </NOTE>
        ## BRugs and R2OpenBUGS have a SystemRequirements of OpenBUGS.
        ## which requires ix86 (not x86-64) and currently installs
        ## only on Linux using a compiler supporting -m32.
        ## Some of R2WinBUGS requires a version of BUGS, but not all.
        ##
        ## mzR has a long record of not installing: in 2023 with neither
        ## gcc 13 nor clang 16.  xcms and MSnbase require it.
        p2 <- grep("^(BRugs|R2OpenBUGS|mzR|xcms|MSnbase)( |\\(|$)",
                   p, value = TRUE)
        BUGS <- c(BUGS, p2)
    }
    if (length(uses))
        out$uses <- sort(unique(gsub("[[:space:]]+", " ", uses)))
    if (length(BUGS)) ## and other non-portable packages
        out$BUGS <- sort(unique(gsub("[[:space:]]+", " ", BUGS)))

    ## Check for non-Sweave vignettes (as indicated by the presence of a
    ## 'VignetteBuilder' field in DESCRIPTION) without
    ## 'build/vignette.rds'.

    vds <- character()
    if(!is.na(meta["VignetteBuilder"])) {
        if(!file.exists(vds <- file.path(dir, "build", "vignette.rds")))
            out$missing_vignette_index <- TRUE
        else
            vds <- readRDS(vds)[, "File"]
    }

    ## Check for missing build/{partial.rdb,pkgname.pdf}
    ## Code similar to build.R, but we really need step = 2 here as this
    ## may throw errors ...
    Rdb <- tryCatch(.build_Rd_db(dir, stages = NULL,
                                 os = c("unix", "windows"), step = 2),
                    error = identity)
    if(inherits(Rdb, "error"))
        out$Rd_db_build_error <- conditionMessage(Rdb)
    else if(length(Rdb)) {
        names(Rdb) <-
            substring(names(Rdb), nchar(file.path(dir, "man")) + 2L)
        Rdb0 <- Rdb
        containsBuildSexprs <-
            which(vapply(Rdb,
                         function(Rd) any(getDynamicFlags(Rd)["build"]),
                         NA))
        if(length(containsBuildSexprs)) {
            built_file <- file.path(dir, "build", "partial.rdb")
            if(!file.exists(built_file))
                out$missing_partial_rdb <- TRUE
            else {
                ## Merge in the partial db: there could be build Sexprs
                ## giving install/render Sexprs ...
                built <- readRDS(built_file)
                pos <- match(basename(names(Rdb)), names(built), 0L)
                Rdb[pos > 0L] <- built[pos]
            }
        }
        containsLaterSexprs <-
            any(vapply(Rdb,
                       function(Rd)
                           any(.Rd_get_Sexpr_build_time_info(Rd)["later"]),
                       NA))
        if(containsLaterSexprs &&
           !file.exists(file.path(dir, "build", "stage23.rdb")))
            out$missing_stage23_rdb <- TRUE
        ## (Could checks whether this really contain all possibly unsafe
        ## install/render Sexprs.)
        if(containsLaterSexprs &&
           config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_NOTE_MISSING_MANUAL_PDF",
                                            "FALSE")) &&
           !file.exists(file.path(dir, "build",
                                  paste0( meta[["Package"]], ".pdf"))))
            out$missing_manual_pdf <- TRUE
        ## Also check for \keyword and \concept entries which use Rd
        ## markup or (likely) give multiple index terms.
        ## This could be moved to .check_Rd_metadata() ...
        .fmt <- function(x) {
            Map(function(f, e) {
                    e <- vapply(e, .Rd_deparse, "")
                    c(paste0("  File ", sQuote(f), ":"),
                      paste0("    ",
                             gsub("\n",
                                  "\n      ",
                                  ifelse(nchar(e) < 50L,
                                         e,
                                         paste(substr(e, 1L, 50L),
                                               "[TRUNCATED]")))))
                },
                names(x), x)
        }
        bad <- lapply(Rdb,
                      function(Rd) {
                          Rd <- Rd[RdTags(Rd) %in% c("\\keyword", "\\concept")]
                          Rd[vapply(Rd,
                                    function(e)
                                        any(unlist(RdTags(e)) != "TEXT"),
                                    NA)]
                      })
        bad <- Filter(length, bad)
        if(length(bad))
            out$Rd_keywords_or_concepts_with_Rd_markup <- .fmt(bad)
        bad <- lapply(Rdb,
                      function(Rd) {
                          Rd <- Rd[RdTags(Rd) %in% c("\\keyword", "\\concept")]
                          Rd[grepl("[,;\t\n]",
                                   trimws(vapply(Rd, paste, "",
                                                 collapse = "\n"))) &
                             !vapply(Rd,
                                     function(e)
                                         any(unlist(RdTags(e)) != "TEXT"),
                                     NA)]
                  })
        bad <- Filter(length, bad)
        if(length(bad))
            out$Rd_keywords_or_concepts_more_than_one <- .fmt(bad)
        ## Also check for URLs which should use \doi with the DOI name.
        .fmt <- function(x) {
            Map(function(f, e) {
                    c(paste0("  File ", sQuote(f), ":"),
                      paste0("    ", e))
                },
                names(x), x)
        }
        bad <- lapply(Rdb0,
                      function(Rd) {
                          grep("https?://(dx[.])?doi[.]org/10",
                               .get_urls_from_Rd(Rd),
                               value = TRUE)
                      })
        bad <- Filter(length, bad)
        if(length(bad))
            out$Rd_URLs_which_should_use_doi <- .fmt(bad)
    }


    ## Check for vignette source (only) in old-style 'inst/doc' rather
    ## than 'vignettes'.
    vign_dir <- file.path(dir, "vignettes")
    if(length(vds)) {
        sources <- setdiff(list.files(file.path(dir, "inst", "doc")),
                           list.files(vign_dir))
        sources <- intersect(vds, sources)
    } else {
        pattern <- vignetteEngine("Sweave")$pattern
        sources <- setdiff(list.files(file.path(dir, "inst", "doc"),
                                      pattern = pattern),
                           list.files(vign_dir, pattern = pattern))
    }

    if(length(sources)) {
        out$have_vignettes_dir <- dir.exists(vign_dir)
        out$vignette_sources_only_in_inst_doc <- sources
    }

    ## Check for Java files without sources (in the right place)
    ## NB: this is only a basic check: that directory need
    ## not contain all (or any) of the sources.
    ## We might in due course want to prompt looking into it.
    if (foss && !dir.exists(file.path(dir, "java"))) {
        allfiles <- list.files(file.path(dir, "inst"),
                               full.names = TRUE, recursive = TRUE)
        allfiles <- c(allfiles,  # misused by ndtv, sisus
                      list.files(file.path(dir, "exec"), full.names = TRUE))
        javafiles <- grep(".*[.](class|jar)$", allfiles, value = TRUE)
        if(length(javafiles)) out$javafiles <- javafiles
    }

    ## Check for installing Java source files
    {
        dotjava <- list.files(file.path(dir, "inst"), pattern = ".*[.]java$",
                              full.names = TRUE, recursive = TRUE)
        dotjava <- c(dotjava,  # misused by ndtv
                     list.files(file.path(dir, "exec"), pattern = ".*[.]java$",
                                full.names = TRUE))
        if(length(dotjava)) out$dotjava <- dotjava
    }

    ## Check CITATION file for CRAN needs.
    .check_citation_for_CRAN <- function(cfile, meta) {
        ## For publishing on CRAN, we need to be able to correctly
        ## process package CITATION files without having the package
        ## installed (actually, using only the base and recommended
        ## packages), which we cannot perfectly emulate when checking.
        ## The best we can easily do is reduce the library search path
        ## to the system and site library.  If the package is not
        ## installed there, check directly; otherwise, check for
        ## offending calls likely to cause trouble.
        ## Note however that in most cases, the issue is calling
        ## packageDescription() to get the package metadata, instead of
        ## using 'meta' as passed to readCitationFile() since R 2.8.0.
        ## Unfortunately, when the package is not installed,
        ## packageDescription() only warns and returns NA, or a vector
        ## of NAs if called with specific fields.  Subscripting the
        ## return value using $ will fail (as this needs lists);
        ## subscripting by other means, or using specific fields,
        ## incorrectly results in NAs.
        ## Hence, we also catch and report all warnings ...
        libpaths <- .libPaths()
        .libPaths(character())
        on.exit(.libPaths(libpaths))
        out <- list()
        installed <- nzchar(system.file(package = meta["Package"]))
        if(installed) {
            ## Ignore pre-2.8.0 compatibility calls to
            ## packageDescription() inside
            ##   if(!exists("meta") || is.null(meta))
            ccalls <- .parse_code_file(cfile, meta["Encoding"])
            ind <- vapply(ccalls,
                          function(e) {
                              is.call(e) &&
                              (length(e) == 3L) &&
                              identical(deparse(e[[1L]]), "if") &&
                              identical(deparse(e[[2L]]),
                                        "!exists(\"meta\") || is.null(meta)")
                          },
                          NA)
            if(any(ind))
                ccalls <- ccalls[!ind]
            ccalls <- .find_calls(ccalls, recursive = TRUE)
            cnames <-
                intersect(unique(.call_names(ccalls)),
                          c("packageDescription", "library", "require"))
            if(length(cnames))
                out$citation_calls <- cnames
        }
        .warnings <- character()
        cinfo <-
            withCallingHandlers(tryCatch(utils::readCitationFile(cfile,
                                                                 meta),
                                         error = identity),
                                warning = function(e) {
                                    .warnings <<- c(.warnings,
                                                    conditionMessage(e))
                                    tryInvokeRestart("muffleWarning")
                                })
        if(inherits(cinfo, "error")) {
            if(installed)
                out$citation_error_reading_if_installed <-
                    conditionMessage(cinfo)
            else
                out$citation_error_reading_if_not_installed <-
                    conditionMessage(cinfo)
            return(out)
        }
        if(length(.warnings))
            out$citation_trouble_when_reading <- unique(.warnings)
        ## If we can successfully read in the citation file, also check
        ## whether we can at least format the bibentries we obtained.
        cfmt <- tryCatch(format(cinfo, style = "text"),
                         warning = identity, error = identity)
        ## This only finds unbalanced braces by default, with messages
        ##   unexpected END_OF_INPUT ... { no }
        ##   unexpected '}'          ... } no {
        ## One can also find 'unknown Rd macros' by setting env var
        ## _R_UTILS_FORMAT_BIBENTRY_VIA_RD_PERMISSIVE_ to something
        ## true, and perhaps we should do this here.
        if(inherits(cfmt, "condition"))
            out$citation_problem_when_formatting <-
                conditionMessage(cfmt)

        ## Also capture calls to outdated personList() and citEntry()
        if(!installed) {
            ccalls <- .find_calls(.parse_code_file(cfile,
                                                   meta["Encoding"]),
                                  recursive = TRUE)
        }
        cnames <- .call_names(ccalls)
        if(any(cnames %in% c("personList", "as.personList")))
            out$citation_has_calls_to_personList_et_al <- TRUE
        if(any(cnames == "citEntry"))
            out$citation_has_calls_to_citEntry <- TRUE

        out
    }

    if(file.exists(cfile <- file.path(dir, "inst", "CITATION"))) {
        cinfo <- .check_citation_for_CRAN(cfile, meta)
        if(length(cinfo))
            out[names(cinfo)] <- cinfo
        ## Simply
        ##   out <- c(out, cinfo)
        ## strips the class attribute from out ...
    }

    ## Check Authors@R.
    if(!is.na(aar <- meta["Authors@R"]) &&
       ## DESCRIPTION is fully checked later on, so be careful.
       !inherits(aar <- tryCatch(str2expression(aar), error = identity),
                 "error")) {
        bad <- ((length(aar) != 1L) || !is.call(aar <- aar[[1L]]))
        if(!bad) {
            cname <- as.character(aar[[1L]])
            bad <-
                ((cname != "person") &&
                 ((cname != "c") ||
                  !all(vapply(aar[-1L],
                              function(e) {
                                  (is.call(e) &&
                                   is.name(x <- e[[1L]]) &&
                                   (as.character(x) == "person"))
                              },
                              FALSE))))
        }
        if(bad)
            out$authors_at_R_calls <- aar
        else {
            ## Catch messages about deprecated arguments in person() calls.
            aar <- meta["Authors@R"]
            aut <- tryCatch(.eval_with_capture(utils:::.read_authors_at_R_field(aar)),
                            error = identity)
            if(!inherits(aut, "error") && length(msg <- aut$message))
                out$authors_at_R_message <- msg
        }
    }
    if(is.na(meta["Authors@R"])) {
        aar <-
            utils:::.authors_at_R_field_from_author_and_maintainer(meta["Author"],
                                                                   maintainer)
        aar <- format(aar, style = "R")
        out$authors_at_R_missing <-
            paste(c("No Authors@R field in DESCRIPTION.",
                    "Please add one, modifying",
                    paste(c("  Authors@R:",
                            rep.int(strrep(" ", 12L),
                                    length(aar) - 1L)),
                          aar),
                    "as necessary."),
                  collapse = "\n")
    }

    ## Check Author field.
    auth <- trimws(as.vector(meta["Author"]))
    if(grepl("^Author *:", auth))
        out$author_starts_with_Author <- TRUE
    if(grepl("^(Authors@R *:|person *\\(|c *\\()", auth))
        out$author_should_be_authors_at_R <- auth

    ## Check Title field.
    title <- trimws(as.vector(meta["Title"]))
    title <- gsub("[\n\t]", " ", title)
    package <- meta["Package"]
    if (tolower(title) == tolower(package)) {
        out$title_is_name <- TRUE
    } else {
        if(grepl(paste0("^",
                        gsub(".", "[.]", package, fixed = TRUE),
                        "[ :]"), title, ignore.case = TRUE))
            out$title_includes_name <- TRUE
        language <- meta["Language"]
        if(is.na(language) ||
           (language == "en") ||
           startsWith(language, "en-")) {
            title2 <- toTitleCase(title)
            ## Keep single quoted elements unchanged.
            p <- "(^|(?<=[ \t[:punct:]]))'[^']*'($|(?=[ \t[:punct:]]))"
            m <- gregexpr(p, title, perl = TRUE)
            regmatches(title2, m) <- regmatches(title, m)
            if(title != title2)
                out$title_case <- c(title, title2)
        }
    }

    ## Check Description field.
    descr <- trimws(as.vector(meta["Description"]))
    descr <- gsub("[\n\t]", " ", descr)
    package <- meta["Package"]
    if(grepl(paste0("^['\"]?", package), ignore.case = TRUE, descr))
        out$descr_bad_start <- TRUE
    if(grepl("^(The|This|A|In this|In the) package", descr))
        out$descr_bad_start <- TRUE
    if(!isTRUE(out$descr_bad_start) && !grepl("^['\"]?[[:upper:]]", descr))
        out$descr_bad_initial <- TRUE
    descr <- strwrap(descr)
    if(any(ind <- grepl("(^|[^</\"])https?://", descr))) {
        ## Could try to filter out the matches for DOIs and arXiv ids
        ## noted differently below: not entirely straightforward when
        ## matching wrapped texts for to ease reporting ...
        out$descr_bad_URLs <- descr[ind]
    }
    if(any(ind <- grepl(paste(c("https?:.*doi.org/",
                                "(^|[^<])doi:",
                                "<doi[^:]",
                                "<10[.]"),
                              collapse = "|"),
                        descr, ignore.case = TRUE)))
        out$descr_bad_DOIs <- descr[ind]
    else if(any(ind <- grepl(
           # almost all others are publisher URLs that should be replaced by DOI markup
           "<https?:.*/10\\.\\d{4,}/.*?>",
           descr, ignore.case = TRUE)))
       out$descr_replace_by_DOI <- descr[ind]
    if(any(ind <- grepl(paste(c("<(arXiv|arxiv):(([[:alpha:].-]+/)?[[:digit:].]+)(v[[:digit:]]+)?([[:space:]]*\\[[^]]+\\])?>",
                                "https?://arxiv.org",
                                "(^|[^<])arxiv:",
                                "<arxiv[^:]"),
                              collapse = "|"),
                        descr, ignore.case = TRUE)))
        out$descr_bad_arXiv_ids <- descr[ind]

    ## Check URL field
    if(!is.na(v <- meta["URL"]) &&
       length(z <- .bad_DESCRIPTION_URL_field_parts(v)))
        out$url_field_parts <- z

    ## Check BugReports field
    if(!is.na(v <- meta["BugReports"])) {
        ## Should be a single URL: this is checked in check_meta()
        ## inside .check_packages().
        z <- parse_URI_reference(v)
        if((endsWith(tolower(z$authority), "github.com") ||
            endsWith(tolower(z$authority), "gitlab.com")) &&
           !grepl("/issues(/new)?/?$", z$path)) {
            w <- sprintf("%s/issues", sub("/$", "", v))
            out$bugreports <-
                paste(c("The BugReports field in DESCRIPTION has",
                        sprintf("  %s", v),
                        "which should likely be",
                        sprintf("  %s", w),
                        "instead."),
                      collapse = "\n")
        }
    }

    skip_dates <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_SKIP_DATES_",
                                         "FALSE"))

    ## Check Date
    date <- trimws(as.vector(meta["Date"]))
    if(!is.na(date)) {
        dd <- as.Date(date, "%Y-%m-%d")
        out$date_msg <- if(is.na(dd))
            "The Date field is not in ISO 8601 yyyy-mm-dd format."
        else if(!skip_dates) {
            if(dd < Sys.Date() - 31)
                "The Date field is over a month old."
            else if(dd > Sys.Date() + 7)
                ## seen: typo 10 vs. 01, reversed %d-%m, %Y+1
                "The Date field is in the future."
        }
    }

    ## Check build time stamp
    ptime <- trimws(as.vector(meta["Packaged"]))
    if(is.na(ptime)) {
        out$build_time_stamp_msg <-
            "The build time stamp is missing."
    } else {
        ts <- strptime(ptime, "%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S", "UTC")
        if(is.na(ts)) {
            out$build_time_stamp_msg <-
                "The build time stamp has an invalid/outdated format."
        }
        else if(!skip_dates) {
            if(as.Date(ts) < Sys.Date() - 31)
                out$build_time_stamp_msg <-
                    "This build time stamp is over a month old."
            else if(as.Date(ts) > Sys.Date() + 1)
                out$build_time_stamp_msg <-
                    "This build time stamp is in the future."
        }
    }

    ## Check DESCRIPTION placeholders
    placeholders <-
        c(if(!is.na(x <- tolower(meta["Title"])) &&
             startsWith(x, "what the package does"))
              x,
          if(!is.na(x <- meta["Author"]) &&
             (x == "Who wrote it"))
              x,
          if(!is.na(x <- meta["Maintainer"]) &&
             (startsWith(x, "Who to complain to") ||
              startsWith(x, "The package maintainer")))
              x,
          if(!is.na(x <- tolower(meta["Description"])) &&
             (startsWith(x, "what the package does") ||
              startsWith(x, "more about what it does")))
              x)
    if(length(placeholders))
        out$placeholders <- placeholders

    if(!is.na(enc <- meta["Encoding"]) && (enc != "UTF-8"))
        out$encoding <- enc

    ## Are there non-ASCII characters in the R source code without a
    ## package encoding in DESCRIPTION?
    ## Note that checking always runs .check_package_ASCII_code() which
    ## however ignores comments.  Ideally, the checks would be merged,
    ## with the comment checking suitably conditionalized.
    ## Note also that this does not catch the cases where non-ASCII
    ## content in R source code cannot be re-encoded using a given
    ## package encoding.  Ideally, this would be checked for as well.
    if(is.na(meta["Encoding"])) {
        ## A variation on showNonASCII():
        find_non_ASCII_lines <- function(f) {
            x <- readLines(f, warn = FALSE)
            asc <- iconv(x, "latin1", "ASCII")
            ind <- is.na(asc) | asc != x
            if(any(ind)) {
                paste0(which(ind),
                       ": ",
                       iconv(x[ind], "latin1", "ASCII", sub = "byte"))
            } else character()
        }
        code_files <- c(file.path(dir, "NAMESPACE"),
                        file.path(dir, "inst", "CITATION"))
        code_files <- code_files[file.exists(code_files)]
        if(dir.exists(file.path(dir, "R"))) {
            OS_subdirs <- c("unix", "windows")
            code_files <-
                c(code_files,
                  list_files_with_type(file.path(dir, "R"),
                                       "code",
                                       OS_subdirs = OS_subdirs))
        }
        names(code_files) <-
            file_path_relative_to(code_files, dir, parent = FALSE)
        lines <- Filter(length, lapply(code_files, find_non_ASCII_lines))
        if(length(lines))
            out$R_files_non_ASCII <- lines
    }

    if(file.exists(fp <- file.path(dir, "R",
                                   paste0(basename(dir),
                                          "-internal.R")))) {
        exprs <- parse(fp)
        tst <- function(e) {
            is.call(e) &&
                (length(s <- as.character(e[[1L]])) == 1L) &&
                (s == "<-") &&
                (length(s <- as.character(e[[2L]])) == 1L) &&
                (s == ".Random.seed")
        }
        if(any(vapply(exprs, tst, NA)))
            out$R_files_set_random_seed <- basename(fp)
    }

    if(!is.na(size <- as.numeric(pkgSize)) &&
       size > as.numeric(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_TARBALL_THRESHOLD_",
                                    unset = "1e7")))
        out$size_of_tarball <- size

    ## Check URLs.
    remote <-
        (!localOnly &&
         !config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_SKIP_URL_CHECKS_IF_REMOTE_",
                                           "FALSE")))
    check_urls_in_parallel <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_CHECK_URLS_IN_PARALLEL_",
                                         "FALSE"))
    if(!capabilities("libcurl") && remote)
        out$no_url_checks <- TRUE
    else if(is.null(out$Rd_db_build_error)) {
        ## Skip if building the Rd db failed.
        udb <- url_db_from_package_sources(dir)
        bad <- tryCatch(check_url_db(udb,
                                     remote = remote,
                                     parallel = check_urls_in_parallel),
                        error = identity)
        if(inherits(bad, "error")) {
            out$bad_urls <- bad
        } else if(NROW(bad)) {
            ## When checking a new submission, take the canonical CRAN
            ## package URL as ok, and signal variants using http instead
            ## of https as non-canonical instead of showing "not found".
            prefix <- "https://cran.r-project.org/package="
            ncp <- nchar(prefix)
            ind <- ((substring(tolower(bad$URL), 1L, ncp) == prefix) &
                    (substring(bad$URL, ncp + 1L) == package))
            if(any(ind))
                bad <- bad[!ind, ]
            prefix <- "http://cran.r-project.org/package="
            ncp <- nchar(prefix)
            ind <- ((substring(tolower(bad$URL), 1L, ncp) == prefix) &
                    (substring(bad$URL, ncp + 1L) == package))
            if(any(ind))
                bad[ind, c("Status", "Message")] <- ""
            if(NROW(bad)) {
                ## Drop non-OK results which are "basically ok" or one
                ## can do nothing about.
                dom <- parse_URI_reference(bad$URL)$authority
                val <- bad$Status
                ind <- ((endsWith(dom, "shinyapps.io") &
                         (val == "202")) |
                        (endsWith(dom, "linkedin.com") &
                         (val == "999")))
                if(any(ind))
                    bad <- bad[!ind, ]
            }
            if(NROW(bad) &&
               config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_URLS_TAKE_403_STATUS_AS_OK_",
                                                "TRUE"))) {
                ## Unfortunately, web servers increasingly use 403s for
                ## "non-browser" accesses (and issue captcha challenges
                ## otherwise), which seems strange for HEAD requests.
                ## Arguably, the 403s could be taken to indicate that
                ## the resource exists but access was not permitted, and
                ## hence (for now by default, could be changed to only
                ## optionally) take these as "OK".
                bad <- bad[bad$Status != "403", ]
            }
            if(NROW(bad))
                out$bad_urls <- bad
        }
        if(config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_CHECK_FILE_URIS_",
                                            "FALSE"))) {
            ## Also check file URIs in packages.
            ## These only make sense relative to their parent.
            ## We could integrate this check into check_url_db() by e.g.
            ## passing the top-level package dir via a suitable env var,
            ## but this is not quite straightforward as the check code
            ## aggregates parents according to URI.
            urls <- udb$URL
            parts <- parse_URI_reference(urls)
            ind <- (parts[, "scheme"] %in% c("", "file"))
            fpaths1 <- fpaths0 <- parts[ind, "path"]
            parents <- udb[ind, "Parent"]
            ## Help files, vignettes (and more) can be accessed via the
            ## dynamic HTML help system.  This employs an internal HTTP
            ## server which handles
            ##   /doc/html /demo /library
            ## and relative paths from help system components resolving
            ## to such.
            ## (Note that these will not work in general, e.g. for the
            ## pdf refmans.)
            if(any(ind <- (startsWith(fpaths0, "../") &
                           grepl("^(inst/doc|man|demo)", parents)))) {
                ## Vignettes have document root
                ##   /library/<pkg>/doc
                ## Help pages have
                ##   /library/<pkg>/html
                foo <- file.path("/library/<pkg>/<sub>", fpaths0[ind])
                fpaths1[ind] <- .remove_dot_segments(foo)
            }
            fpaths1[grepl("^(/doc/html|/demo|/library)", fpaths1)] <- ""
            fpaths1[(fpaths1 == "index.html") &
                    startsWith(parents, "inst/doc")] <- ""
            ## (Of course, one could verify that the special cased paths
            ## really exist.)
            ppaths <- dirname(parents)
            pos <- which(!file.exists(file.path(ifelse(nzchar(ppaths),
                                                       file.path(dir,
                                                                 ppaths),
                                                       dir),
                                                fpaths1)))
            if(length(pos))
                out$bad_file_URIs <-
                    cbind(fpaths0[pos], parents[pos])
        }
        if(remote) {
            ## Also check arXiv pseudo URIs not yet converted to arXiv
            ## DOIs.
            pat <- "<(arXiv|arxiv):(([[:alpha:].-]+/)?[[:digit:].]+)(v[[:digit:]]+)?([[:space:]]*\\[[^]]+\\])?>"
            dsc <- meta["Description"]
            ids <- .gregexec_at_pos(pat, dsc, gregexpr(pat, dsc), 3L)
            if(length(ids)) {
                ini <- "10.48550/arXiv."
                ddb <- doi_db(paste0(ini, ids),
                              rep.int("DESCRIPTION", length(ids)))
                bad <- tryCatch(check_doi_db(ddb,
                                             parallel =
                                                 check_urls_in_parallel),
                                error = identity)
                if(!inherits(bad, "error") && length(bad))
                    out$bad_arXiv_ids <-
                        substring(bad$DOI, nchar(ini) + 1L)
            }
            ## Also check ORCID iDs.
            odb <- .ORCID_iD_db_from_package_sources(dir)
            if(NROW(odb)) {
                ## Only look at things that may be valid: the others are
                ## complained about elsewhere.
                ind <- grepl(.ORCID_iD_variants_regexp, odb[, 1L])
                odb <- odb[ind, , drop = FALSE]
            }
            if(NROW(odb) && requireNamespace("curl", quietly = TRUE)) {
                ids <- .ORCID_iD_canonicalize(odb[, 1L])
                pos <- which(!.ORCID_iD_is_alive(ids))
                if(length(pos))
                    out$bad_ORCID_iDs <- odb[pos, , drop = FALSE]
            }
            ## Also check ROR IDs.
            rdb <- .ROR_ID_db_from_package_sources(dir)
            if(NROW(rdb)) {
                ## Only look at things that may be valid: the others are
                ## complained about elsewhere.
                ind <- grepl(.ROR_ID_variants_regexp, rdb[, 1L])
                rdb <- rdb[ind, , drop = FALSE]
            }
            if(NROW(rdb) && requireNamespace("curl", quietly = TRUE)) {
                ids <- .ROR_ID_canonicalize(rdb[, 1L])
                pos <- which(!.ROR_ID_is_alive(ids))
                if(length(pos))
                    out$bad_ROR_IDs <- rdb[pos, , drop = FALSE]
            }
        }
    }

    ## When running the incoming check code as part of the regular
    ## checks we need to drop the parts which are really specific for
    ## submission checks.  (Of course, ideally we would have skipped
    ## them above.)
    drop_submission_only <-
        config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_DROP_SUBMISSION_ONLY_",
                                         "FALSE"))
    if(drop_submission_only) {
        out[c("descr_bad_initial",
              "descr_bad_start",
              "title_includes_name",
              "title_case",
              "extensions",
              "pointers",
              "fields",
              "BUGS",
              "version_with_leading_zeroes",
              "version_with_large_components")] <- NULL
    }

    ## Checks from here down require Internet access, so drop out now if we
    ## don't want that.
    if (localOnly)
        return(out)

    urls <- utils::contrib.url(.get_standard_repository_URLs(),
                               "source")

    db <- tryCatch(utils::available.packages(urls,
                                             filters = list(),
                                             fields = c("File", "Path")),
                   error = identity)
    if(inherits(db, "error")) {
        message("NB: need Internet access to use CRAN incoming checks")
        ## Actually, all repositories could be local file:// mirrors.
        return(out)
    }

    ## Does this have strong dependencies not in mainstream
    ## repositories?  This should not happen, and hence is not compared
    ## against possibly given additional repositories.
    repository <- db[, "Repository"]
    strong_dependencies <-
        setdiff(unique(c(.extract_dependency_package_names(meta["Depends"]),
                         .extract_dependency_package_names(meta["Imports"]),
                         .extract_dependency_package_names(meta["LinkingTo"]))),
                c(.get_standard_package_names()$base,
                  db[(startsWith(repository, urls[1L]) |
                      startsWith(repository, urls[2L])),
                     "Package"]))
    if(length(strong_dependencies)) {
        out$strong_dependencies_not_in_mainstream_repositories <-
            strong_dependencies
    }

    adb <- NULL
    if(!is.na(aurls <- meta["Additional_repositories"])) {
        aurls <- .read_additional_repositories_field(aurls)
        ## Get available packages separately for each given URL, so that
        ## we can spot the ones which do not provide any packages.
        adb <-
            tryCatch(lapply(aurls,
                            function(u) {
                                utils::available.packages(utils::contrib.url(u,
                                                                             "source"),
                                                          filters =
                                                              c("R_version",
                                                                "duplicates"))
                            }),
                     error = identity)
        if(inherits(adb, "error")) {
            out$additional_repositories_analysis_failed_with <-
                conditionMessage(adb)
        } else {
            ## Check for additional repositories with no packages.
            ind <- vapply(adb, NROW, 0L) == 0L
            if(any(ind))
                out$additional_repositories_with_no_packages <-
                    aurls[ind]
        }
    } else {
        aurls <- NULL
    }

    if(drop_submission_only)
        return(out)

    ## If a package has a FOSS license, check whether any of its strong
    ## recursive dependencies restricts use.
    if(foss) {
        available <-
            utils:::available_packages_filters_db$R_version(db)
        available <- 
            utils:::available_packages_filters_db$duplicates(available)
        ## Modulo the additional Path field, same as
        ##   utils::available.packages(utils::contrib.url(urls, "source"),
        ##                             filters = c("R_version", "duplicates"))
        ## but faster.
        ## We need the current dependencies of the package (so batch
        ## upload checks will not necessarily do "the right thing").
        package <- meta["Package"]
        depends <- c("Depends", "Imports", "LinkingTo")
        ## Need to be careful when merging the dependencies of the
        ## package (in case it is not yet available).
        if(package %in% rownames(available)) {
            available[package, depends] <- meta[depends]
        } else {
            entry <- rbind(meta[colnames(available)])
            rownames(entry) <- package
            available <- rbind(available, entry)
        }
        ldb <- analyze_licenses(available[, "License"], available)
        depends <- unlist(package_dependencies(package, available,
                                               recursive = TRUE))
        ru <- ldb$restricts_use
        pnames_restricts_use_TRUE <- rownames(available)[!is.na(ru) & ru]
        pnames_restricts_use_NA <- rownames(available)[is.na(ru)]
        bad <- intersect(depends, pnames_restricts_use_TRUE)
        if(length(bad))
            out$depends_with_restricts_use_TRUE <- bad
        bad <- intersect(depends, pnames_restricts_use_NA)
        if(length(bad))
            out$depends_with_restricts_use_NA <- bad
        bv <- parse_description_field(meta, "BuildVignettes", TRUE)
        if (!bv) out$foss_with_BuildVignettes <- TRUE
    }

    ## Note that .get_standard_repository_URLs() puts the CRAN master first.
    CRAN <- urls[1L]

    ## Check for CRAN repository db overrides and possible conflicts.
    con <- url(sprintf("%s/PACKAGES.in", CRAN))
    odb <- read.dcf(con)
    close(con)
    ## For now (2022-09-22), PACKAGES.in is all ASCII, so there is no
    ## need to re-encode.  Eventually, it might be in UTF-8 ...
    entry <- odb[odb[, "Package"] == meta["Package"], ]
    entry <- entry[!is.na(entry) &
                   (names(entry) %notin% c("Package", "X-CRAN-History"))]
    if(length(entry)) {
        ## Check for conflicts between package license implications and
        ## repository overrides.  Note that the license info predicates
        ## are logicals (TRUE, NA or FALSE) and the repository overrides
        ## are character ("yes", missing or "no").
        if(!is.na(iif <- lic_info$is_FOSS) &&
           !is.na(lif <- entry["License_is_FOSS"]) &&
           ((lif == "yes") != iif))
            out$conflict_in_license_is_FOSS <- lif
        if(!is.na(iru <- lic_info$restricts_use) &&
           !is.na(lru <- entry["License_restricts_use"]) &&
           ((lru == "yes") != iru))
            out$conflict_in_license_restricts_use <- lru

        fmt <- function(s)
            unlist(lapply(s,
                          function(e) {
                              paste(strwrap(e, indent = 2L, exdent = 4L),
                                    collapse = "\n")
                          }))
        nms <- names(entry)
        ## Report all overrides for visual inspection.
        entry <- fmt(sprintf("  %s: %s", nms, entry))
        names(entry) <- nms
        out$overrides <- entry
        fields <- intersect(names(meta), nms)
        if(length(fields)) {
            ## Find fields where package metadata and repository
            ## overrides are in conflict.
            ind <- ! unlist(Map(identical,
                                fmt(sprintf("  %s: %s", fields, meta[fields])),
                                entry[fields]))
            if(any(ind))
                out$conflicts <- fields[ind]
        }
    }

    archive_db <- CRAN_archive_db()
    packages_in_CRAN_archive <- names(archive_db)

    ## Package names must be unique within standard repositories when
    ## ignoring case.
    package <- meta["Package"]
    packages <- db[, "Package"]
    if(package %notin% packages) out$new_submission <- TRUE
    clashes <- character()
    pos <- which((tolower(packages) == tolower(package)) &
                 (packages != package))
    if(length(pos))
        clashes <-
            sprintf("%s [%s]", packages[pos], db[pos, "Repository"])
    ## If possible, also catch clashes with archived CRAN packages
    ## (which might get un-archived eventually).
    if(length(packages_in_CRAN_archive)) {
        pos <- which((tolower(packages_in_CRAN_archive) ==
                      tolower(package)) &
                     (packages_in_CRAN_archive != package))
        if(length(pos)) {
            clashes <-
                c(clashes,
                  sprintf("%s [CRAN archive]",
                          packages_in_CRAN_archive[pos]))
        }
    }
    if(length(clashes))
        out$bad_package <- list(package, clashes)

    ## Is this duplicated from another repository?
    repositories <- db[(packages == package) &
                       !startsWith(db[, "Repository"], CRAN),
                       "Repository"]
    if(length(repositories))
        out$repositories <- repositories

    ## Does this have Suggests or Enhances not in mainstream
    ## repositories?
    suggests_or_enhances <-
        setdiff(unique(c(.extract_dependency_package_names(meta["Suggests"]),
                         .extract_dependency_package_names(meta["Enhances"]))),
                c(.get_standard_package_names()$base, db[, "Package"]))
    if(length(suggests_or_enhances)) {
        out$suggests_or_enhances_not_in_mainstream_repositories <-
            suggests_or_enhances
    }
    if(!is.null(aurls)) {
        if(!inherits(adb, "error")) {
            ## Merge available packages dbs and remove duplicates.
            adb <- do.call(rbind, adb)
            adb <- utils:::available_packages_filters_db$duplicates(adb)
            ## Ready.
            dependencies <- unique(c(strong_dependencies, suggests_or_enhances))
            pos <- match(dependencies, rownames(adb), nomatch = 0L)
            ind <- (pos > 0L)
            tab <- matrix(character(), nrow = 0L, ncol = 3L)
            if(any(ind))
                tab <- rbind(tab,
                             cbind(dependencies[ind],
                                   "yes",
                                   adb[pos[ind], "Repository"]))
            ind <- !ind
            if(any(ind))
                tab <- rbind(tab,
                             cbind(dependencies[ind],
                                   "no",
                                   "?"))
            ## Map Repository fields to URLs, and determine unused
            ## URLs.
            ## Note that available.packages() possibly adds Path
            ## information in the Repository field, so matching
            ## given contrib URLs to these fields is not trivial.
            unused <- character()
            for(u in aurls) {
                cu <- utils::contrib.url(u, "source")
                ind <- startsWith(tab[, 3L], cu)
                if(any(ind)) {
                    tab[ind, 3L] <- u
                } else {
                    unused <- c(unused, u)
                }
            }
            if(length(unused))
                tab <- rbind(tab, cbind("?", "?", unused))
            dimnames(tab) <- NULL
            out$additional_repositories_analysis_results <- tab
        }
    }

    ## Check DOIs.
    if(capabilities("libcurl") &&
       !config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_SKIP_DOI_CHECKS_",
                                         "FALSE"))) {
        bad <- tryCatch(check_doi_db(doi_db_from_package_sources(dir,
                                                                 Rd = TRUE),
                                     parallel = check_urls_in_parallel),
                        error = identity)
        if(inherits(bad, "error") || NROW(bad))
            out$bad_dois <- bad
    }

    ## Is this an update for a package already on CRAN?
    db <- db[(packages == package) &
             (db[, "Repository"] == CRAN) &
             is.na(db[, "Path"]), , drop = FALSE]
    ## This drops packages in version-specific subdirectories.
    ## It also does not know about archived versions.
    if(!NROW(db)) {
        if(package %in% packages_in_CRAN_archive) {
            out$CRAN_archive <- TRUE
            v_m <- package_version(meta["Version"])
            v_a <- sub("^.*_(.*)\\.tar.gz$", "\\1",
                       basename(rownames(archive_db[[package]])))
            v_a <- max(package_version(v_a, strict = FALSE),
                       na.rm = TRUE)
            if(v_m <= v_a)
                out$bad_version <- list(v_m, v_a)
        }
        if(!foss)
            out$bad_license <- meta["License"]
        return(out)
    }

    ## Checks from this point down should be for a package already on CRAN

    ## For now, there should be no duplicates ...

    ## Package versions should be newer than what we already have on CRAN.

    v_m <- package_version(meta["Version"])
    v_d <- max(package_version(db[, "Version"]))
    if((v_m <= v_d) &&
       !config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_SKIP_VERSIONS_",
                                         "FALSE")))
        out$bad_version <- list(v_m, v_d)
    if((v_m$major == v_d$major) && (v_m$minor >= v_d$minor + 10))
        out$version_with_jump_in_minor <- list(v_m, v_d)

    ## Check submission recency and frequency.
    current_db <- CRAN_current_db()
    mtimes <- c(current_db[match(package,
                                 sub("_.*", "", rownames(current_db)),
                                 nomatch = 0L),
                           "mtime"],
                archive_db[[package]]$mtime)
    if(length(mtimes)) {
        deltas <- Sys.Date() - as.Date(sort(mtimes, decreasing = TRUE))
        ## Number of days since last update.
        recency <- as.numeric(deltas[1L])
        if(recency < 7)
            out$recency <- recency
        ## Number of updates in past 6 months.
        frequency <- sum(deltas <= 180)
        if(frequency > 6)
            out$frequency <- frequency
    }

    ## Watch out for maintainer changes.
    ## Note that we cannot get the maintainer info from the PACKAGES
    ## files.
    db <- tryCatch(CRAN_package_db(), error = identity)
    if(inherits(db, "error")) return(out)

    meta1 <- db[db[, "Package"] == package, ]
    ## this can have multiple entries, e.g. for recommended packages.
    meta0 <- unlist(meta1[1L, ])
    m_m <- as.vector(meta["Maintainer"]) # drop name
    m_d <- as.vector(meta0["Maintainer"])
    if(tolower(sub("[^<]*<(.*)>.*", "\\1", m_m)) !=
       tolower(sub("[^<]*<(.*)>.*", "\\1", m_d))) {
        ## strwrap is used below, so we need to worry about encodings.
        ## m_d is in UTF-8 already
        if(Encoding(m_m) == "latin1") m_m <- iconv(m_m, "latin1")
        out$new_maintainer <- list(m_m, m_d)
    }

    l_d <- meta0["License"]
    if(!foss && analyze_license(l_d)$is_verified)
        out$new_license <- list(meta["License"], l_d)

    ## for incoming check we may want to check for GNU make in
    ## SystemRequirements here in order to auto-accept packages once
    ## this was already accepted before
    if(config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_NOTE_GNU_MAKE_",
                                        "FALSE"))){
        SysReq <- meta["SystemRequirements"]
        if(!is.na(SysReq) && grepl("GNU [Mm]ake", SysReq)) {
            out$GNUmake <- TRUE
        }
    }

    ## Re-check for some notes if enabled and current version was published recently enough.
    if(!inherits(year <- tryCatch(format(as.Date(meta0["Published"]), "%Y"),
                                     error = identity),
                    "error")){
        ## possible misspellings and keep only the new ones:
        if(NROW(a <- out$spelling)
           && config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_ASPELL_RECHECK_MAYBE_",
                                               "TRUE"))
           && (year >=
               as.numeric(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_ASPELL_RECHECK_START_",
                                     "2013")))) {
            a0 <- .aspell_package_description_for_CRAN(meta = meta0)
            out$spelling <- a[a$Original %notin% a0$Original, ]
        }

        # possible title_includes_name and only report if the title actually changed
        if(NROW(out$title_includes_name)
            && config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_TITLE_INCLUDES_NAME_RECHECK_MAYBE_",
                                "TRUE"))
            && (year >= as.numeric(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_TITLE_INCLUDES_NAME_RECHECK_START_",
                                     "2016")))
            && meta0["Title"] == meta["Title"]) {
                out$title_includes_name <- NULL
                }

        # possible title case problems and only report if the title actually changed
        if(NROW(out$title_case)
            && config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_TITLE_CASE_RECHECK_MAYBE_",
                                           "TRUE"))
            && (year >= as.numeric(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_TITLE_CASE_RECHECK_START_",
                                 "2016")))
            && meta0["Title"] == meta["Title"]) {
                out$title_case <- NULL
        }

        # possible bad Description start and only report if new:
        if(NROW(out$descr_bad_start)
            && config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_DESCR_BAD_START_RECHECK_MAYBE_",
                                           "TRUE"))
            && (year >= as.numeric(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_DESCR_BAD_START_RECHECK_START_",
                                 "2016")))) {
                descr0 <- trimws(as.vector(meta0["Description"]))
                descr0 <- gsub("[\n\t]", " ", descr0)
                if(grepl(paste0("^['\"]?", package), ignore.case = TRUE, descr0)
                        || grepl("^(The|This|A|In this|In the) package", descr0)){
                    out$descr_bad_start <- NULL
                }
        }

        # possible GNU make usage and only report if this is new
        if(NROW(out$GNUmake)
            && config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_GNU_MAKE_RECHECK_MAYBE_",
                                 "TRUE"))
            && (year >= as.numeric(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_CRAN_INCOMING_GNU_MAKE_RECHECK_START_",
                                 "2015")))) {
                SysReq0 <- meta0["SystemRequirements"]
                if(!is.na(SysReq0) && grepl("GNU [Mm]ake", SysReq0)) {
                    out$GNUmake <- NULL
                }
        }
    }

    out
}

format.check_package_CRAN_incoming <-
function(x, ...)
{
    fmt <- function(x) {
        if(length(x)) paste(x, collapse = "\n") else character()
    }

    c(character(),
      if(length(x$Maintainer))
          sprintf("Maintainer: %s", sQuote(lines2str(x$Maintainer, " ")))
      else
          "No maintainer field in DESCRIPTION file",
      fmt(c(if(isTRUE(x$Maintainer_invalid_or_multi_person))
                "The maintainer field is invalid or specifies more than one person",
            if(isTRUE(x$empty_Maintainer_name))
                'The maintainer field lacks a name',
            if(isTRUE(x$Maintainer_needs_quotes))
                'The display-name part of the maintainer field should be enclosed in ""')
          ),
      if(length(x$new_submission))
          "New submission",
      if(length(y <- x$bad_package))
          sprintf("Conflicting package names (submitted: %s, existing: %s)",
                  y[[1L]], y[[2L]]),
      if(length(y <- x$repositories))
          sprintf("Package duplicated from %s", y),
      if(length(y <- x$CRAN_archive))
          "Package was archived on CRAN",
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$bad_version))
                sprintf("Insufficient package version (submitted: %s, existing: %s)",
                        y[[1L]], y[[2L]]),
            if(length(y <- x$version_with_leading_zeroes))
                sprintf("Version contains leading zeroes (%s)", y),
            if(length(y <- x$version_with_large_components))
                sprintf("Version contains large components (%s)", y),
            if(length(y <- x$version_with_jump_in_minor))
                sprintf("Version jumps in minor (submitted: %s, existing: %s)",
                        y[[1L]], y[[2L]]))),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$recency))
                sprintf("Days since last update: %d", y),
            if(length(y <- x$frequency))
                sprintf("Number of updates in past 6 months: %d", y))),
      if(length(y <- x$new_maintainer))
          paste(c("New maintainer:",
                  strwrap(y[[1L]], indent = 2L, exdent = 4L),
                  "Old maintainer(s):",
                  strwrap(y[[2L]], indent = 2L, exdent = 4L)),
                collapse = "\n"),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$bad_license))
                sprintf("Non-FOSS package license (%s)", y),
            if(length(y <- x$new_license))
                paste(c("Change to non-FOSS package license.",
                        "New license:",
                        strwrap(y[[1L]], indent = 2L, exdent = 4L),
                        "Old license:",
                        strwrap(y[[2L]], indent = 2L, exdent = 4L)),
                      collapse = "\n"),
            if(length(y <- x$extensions)) {
                paste(c("License components with restrictions and base license permitting such:",
                        paste0("  ", y),
                        unlist(lapply(x$pointers,
                                      function(e) {
                                          c(sprintf("File '%s':", e[1L]),
                                            paste0("  ", e[-1L]))
                                      }))),
                      collapse = "\n")
            })),
      if(length(y <- x$aspell_package_description_error)) {
          paste(y, collapse = "\n")
      },
      if(NROW(y <- x$spelling)) {
          s <- split(sprintf("%d:%d", y$Line, y$Column), y$Original)
          paste(c("Possibly misspelled words in DESCRIPTION:",
                  sprintf("  %s (%s)",
                          names(s),
                          lapply(s, paste, collapse = ", "))),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      if(isTRUE(x$foss_with_BuildVignettes)) {
          "FOSS licence with BuildVignettes: false"
      },
      if(length(y <- x$fields)) {
          paste(c("Unknown, possibly misspelled, fields in DESCRIPTION:",
                  sprintf("  %s", paste(sQuote(y), collapse = " "))),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$overrides)) {
                paste(c("CRAN repository db overrides:", y),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$conflicts)) {
                paste(sprintf("CRAN repository db conflicts: %s",
                              sQuote(y)),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$conflict_in_license_is_FOSS)) {
                sprintf("Package license conflicts with %s override",
                        sQuote(paste("License_is_FOSS:", y)))
            },
            if(length(y <- x$conflict_in_license_restricts_use)) {
                sprintf("Package license conflicts with %s override",
                        sQuote(paste("License_restricts_use:", y)))
            })),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$depends_with_restricts_use_TRUE)) {
                paste(c("Package has a FOSS license but eventually depends on the following",
                        if(length(y) > 1L)
                            "packages which restrict use:"
                        else
                            "package which restricts use:",
                        strwrap(paste(y, collapse = ", "),
                                indent = 2L, exdent = 4L)),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$depends_with_restricts_use_NA)) {
                paste(c("Package has a FOSS license but eventually depends on the following",
                        if(length(y) > 1L)
                            "packages which may restrict use:"
                        else
                            "package which may restrict use:",
                        strwrap(paste(y, collapse = ", "),
                                indent = 2L, exdent = 4L)),
                      collapse = "\n")
            })),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$strong_dependencies_not_in_mainstream_repositories)) {
                  paste(c("Strong dependencies not in the CRAN or BioC software repositories:",
                          strwrap(paste(y, collapse = ", "),
                                  indent = 2L, exdent = 4L)),
                        collapse = "\n")
              },
              if(length(y <- x$suggests_or_enhances_not_in_mainstream_repositories)) {
                  paste(c("Suggests or Enhances not in mainstream repositories:",
                          strwrap(paste(y, collapse = ", "),
                                  indent = 2L, exdent = 4L)),
                        collapse = "\n")
              },
              if(length(y <- x$additional_repositories_analysis_failed_with)) {
                  paste(c("Using Additional_repositories specification failed with message:",
                          paste0("  ", y)),
                        collapse = "\n")
              },
              if(length(y <- x$additional_repositories_analysis_results)) {
                  paste(c("Availability using Additional_repositories specification:",
                          sprintf("  %s   %s   %s",
                                  format(y[, 1L], justify = "left"),
                                  format(y[, 2L], justify = "right"),
                                  format(y[, 3L], justify = "left"))),
                        collapse = "\n")
              },
              if(length(y <- x$additional_repositories_with_no_packages)) {
                  paste(c("Additional repositories with no packages:",
                          paste0("  ", y)),
                        collapse = "\n")
              })),
      if(length(y <- x$uses)) {
          paste(if(length(y) > 1L)
                "Uses the superseded packages:" else
                "Uses the superseded package:",
                paste(sQuote(y), collapse = ", "))
      },
      if(length(y <- x$BUGS)) {
          paste(if(length(y) > 1L)
                "Uses the non-portable packages:" else
                "Uses the non-portable package:",
                paste(sQuote(y), collapse = ", "))
      },
      if(length(y <- x$authors_at_R_calls)) {
          "Authors@R field should be a call to person(), or combine such calls."
      },
      if(length(y <- x$authors_at_R_message)) {
          paste(c("Authors@R field gives persons with deprecated or bad elements:",
                  paste0("  ", y)),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      if(length(y <- x$authors_at_R_missing)) y,
      if(length(y <- x$author_starts_with_Author)) {
          "Author field starts with 'Author:'."
      },
      if(length(y <- x$author_should_be_authors_at_R)) {
          paste(c("Author field should be Authors@R.  Current value is:",
                  paste0("  ", gsub("\n", "\n  ", y, fixed=TRUE))),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      if(length(y <- x$vignette_sources_only_in_inst_doc)) {
          if(isFALSE(x$have_vignettes_dir))
              paste(c("Vignette sources in 'inst/doc' with no 'vignettes' directory:",
                      strwrap(paste(sQuote(y), collapse = ", "),
                              indent = 2L, exdent = 2L),
                      "A 'vignettes' directory is required as from R 3.1.0"),
                    collapse = "\n")
          else
              paste(c("Vignette sources in 'inst/doc' missing from the 'vignettes' directory:",
                      strwrap(paste(sQuote(y), collapse = ", "),
                              indent = 2L, exdent = 2L)),
                    collapse = "\n")
      },
      if(length(y <- x$missing_vignette_index)) {
          "Package has a VignetteBuilder field but no prebuilt vignette index."
      },
      if(length(y <- x$Rd_db_build_error)) {
          paste(c("Reading Rd files failed with message:",
                  paste0("  ", y)),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$missing_partial_rdb)) {
                paste(strwrap("Package has help file(s) containing build-stage \\Sexpr{} expressions but no 'build/partial.rdb' file."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$missing_stage23_rdb)) {
                paste(strwrap("Package has help file(s) containing later-stage \\Sexpr{} expressions but no 'build/stage23.rdb' file."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$missing_manual_pdf)) {
                paste(strwrap("Package has help file(s) containing install/render-stage \\Sexpr{} expressions but no prebuilt PDF manual."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            })),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$dotjava)) {
                "Package installs .java files."
            },
            if(length(y <- x$javafiles)) {
                "Package has FOSS license, installs .class/.jar but has no 'java' directory."
            })),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$citation_calls)) {
                paste(c("Package CITATION file contains call(s) to:",
                        strwrap(paste(y, collapse = ", "),
                                indent = 2L, exdent = 4L)),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$citation_error_reading_if_installed)) {
                paste(c("Reading CITATION file fails with",
                        paste0("  ", gsub("\n", "\n  ", y))),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$citation_error_reading_if_not_installed)) {
                paste(c("Reading CITATION file fails with",
                        paste0("  ", gsub("\n", "\n  ", y)),
                        "when package is not installed."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$citation_trouble_when_reading)) {
                paste(c("Problems when reading CITATION file:",
                        paste0("  ", y)),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$citation_problem_when_formatting)) {
                paste(c("Problems when formatting CITATION entries:",
                        paste0("  ", y)),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(isTRUE(x$citation_has_calls_to_personList_et_al)) {
                paste(strwrap("Package CITATION file contains call(s) to old-style personList() or as.personList().  Please use c() on person objects instead."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(isTRUE(x$citation_has_calls_to_citEntry)) {
                paste(strwrap("Package CITATION file contains call(s) to old-style citEntry().  Please use bibentry() instead."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            }
            )),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$bad_urls)) {
                if(inherits(y, "error"))
                    paste(c("Checking URLs failed with message:",
                            paste0("  ", conditionMessage(y))),
                          collapse = "\n")
                else
                    paste(c(if(length(y) > 1L)
                                "Found the following (possibly) invalid URLs:"
                            else
                                "Found the following (possibly) invalid URL:",
                            paste0("  ", gsub("\n", "\n    ", format(y), fixed=TRUE))),
                          collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y) && any(nzchar(z <- y$CRAN))) {
                ul <- tolower(z)
                indp <- (grepl("^https?://cran.r-project.org/web/packages",
                               ul) &
                         !grepl("^https?://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/[.[:alnum:]_]+(html|pdf|rds)$",
                                ul))
                indv <- grepl("https?://cran.r-project.org/web/views/[[:alnum:]]+[.]html$",
                              ul)
                paste(c(if(any(indp)) {
                            c("The canonical URL of the CRAN page for a package is ",
                              "  https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=pkgname")
                        },
                        if(any(indv)) {
                            c("The canonical URL of the CRAN page for a task view is ",
                              "  https://CRAN.R-project.org/view=viewname")
                        },
                        if(any(nzchar(z) & !indp & !indv)) {
                            "Canonical CRAN.R-project.org URLs use https."
                        }),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y) && any(nzchar(y$New)) &&
               config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_URLS_SHOW_301_STATUS_", "FALSE"))) {
                paste(strwrap("For content that is 'Moved Permanently', please change http to https, add trailing slashes, or replace the old by the new URL."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y) && any(nzchar(y$Spaces))) {
                "  Spaces in an http[s] URL should probably be replaced by %20"
            },
            if(length(y) && any(ind <- nzchar(z <- y$R))) {
                ul <- tolower(z[ind])
                elts <- unique(sub("^http://([^.]+)[.].*", "\\1", ul))
                paste(sprintf("  Canonical %s.R-project.org URLs use https.",
                              elts),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y) &&
               any(ind <-
                       (grepl(re_or(c("^https?://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/[0-9]+",
                                      "^https?://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC[0-9]+/$",
                                      "^https?://academic.oup.com/.*(/[0-9]*){4}$",
                                      "^https?://journals.plos.org/.*/article",
                                      "^https?://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article")),
                              y$URL)))) {
                ## <FIXME>
                ## Ideally we would complain about such URLs in general
                ## and not only when the URL checks were not OK.
                paste(c("Please use DOIs for the following publisher URLs:",
                        paste0("  ", y$URL[ind])),
                      collapse = "\n")
                ## </FIXME>
            },
            if(length(y <- x$no_url_checks) && y) {
                "Checking URLs requires 'libcurl' support in the R build."
            })),
      if(length(y <- x$bad_file_URIs)) {
          paste(c(if(NROW(y) > 1L)
                      "Found the following (possibly) invalid file URIs:"
                  else
                      "Found the following (possibly) invalid file URI:",
                  sprintf("  URI: %s\n    From: %s", y[, 1L], y[, 2L])),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      fmt(if(length(y <- x$bad_dois)) {
              if(inherits(y, "error"))
                  paste(c("Checking DOIs failed with message:",
                           paste0("  ", conditionMessage(y))),
                        collapse = "\n")
              else
                  paste(c(if(length(y) > 1L)
                              "Found the following (possibly) invalid DOIs:"
                          else
                              "Found the following (possibly) invalid DOI:",
                          paste0("  ", gsub("\n", "\n    ", format(y),
                                            fixed = TRUE))),
                        collapse = "\n")
          }),
      fmt(if(length(y <- x$bad_arXiv_ids)) {
              paste(c(if(length(y) > 1L)
                          "The Description field contains the following (possibly) invalid arXiv ids:"
                      else
                          "The Description field contains the following (possibly) invalid arXiv id:",
                      paste0("  ", gsub("\n", "\n    ", format(y),
                                        fixed = TRUE))),
                    collapse = "\n")
          }),
      fmt(if(length(y <- x$bad_ORCID_iDs)) {
              paste(c(if(NROW(y) > 1L)
                          "Found the following (possibly) invalid ORCID iDs:"
                      else
                          "Found the following (possibly) invalid ORCID iD:",
                      sprintf("  iD: %s\t(from: %s)",
                              unlist(y[, 1L]),
                              vapply(y[, 2L], paste, "",
                                     collapse = ", "))),
                    collapse = "\n")
          }),
      fmt(if(length(y <- x$bad_ROR_IDs)) {
              paste(c(if(NROW(y) > 1L)
                          "Found the following (possibly) invalid ROR IDs:"
                      else
                          "Found the following (possibly) invalid ROR IDs:",
                      sprintf("  ID: %s\t(from: %s)",
                              unlist(y[, 1L]),
                              vapply(y[, 2L], paste, "",
                                     collapse = ", "))),
                    collapse = "\n")
          }),
      fmt(if(length(y <- x$encoding))
              c(sprintf("Package encoding '%s' is deprecated.", y),
                "Please change to UTF-8 for non-ASCII content.")),
      if(length(y <- x$R_files_non_ASCII)) {
          paste(c("No package encoding and non-ASCII characters in the following R files:",
                  paste0("  ", names(y), "\n    ",
                         vapply(y, paste, "", collapse = "\n    "),
                         collapse = "\n")),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      if(length(y <- x$R_files_set_random_seed)) {
          paste(c(sprintf("File '%s' sets .Random.seed.",
                          file.path("R", y)),
                  "This is usually neither needed nor wanted."),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      fmt(c(if(length(x$title_is_name)) {
                "The Title field is just the package name: provide a real title."
            },
            if(length(x$title_includes_name)) {
                "The Title field starts with the package name."
            },
            if(length(y <- x$title_case)) {
                paste(c("The Title field should be in title case. Current version is:",
                        paste0("  ", sQuote(y[1L])),
                        "In title case that is:",
                        paste0("  ", sQuote(y[2L]))),
                      collapse = "\n")
            })),
      fmt(c(if(length(x$descr_bad_initial)) {
                "The Description field should start with a capital letter."
            },
            if(length(x$descr_bad_start)) {
                "The Description field should not start with the package name,\n  'This package' or similar."
            },
            if(length(y <- x$descr_bad_URLs)) {
                paste(c("The Description field contains",
                        paste0("  ", y),
                        "Please enclose URLs in angle brackets (<...>)."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$descr_bad_DOIs)) {
                paste(c("The Description field contains",
                        paste0("  ", y),
                        "Please write DOIs as <doi:prefix/suffix>."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
            if(length(y <- x$descr_bad_arXiv_ids)) {
                paste(c("The Description field contains",
                        paste0("  ", y),
                        "Please refer to arXiv e-prints via their arXiv DOI <doi:10.48550/arXiv.YYMM.NNNNN>."),
                      collapse = "\n")
            },
           if(length(y <- x$descr_replace_by_DOI)) {
               paste(c("The Description field contains",
                       paste0("  ", y),
                       "Please use permanent DOI markup for linking to publications as in <doi:prefix/suffix>."),
                       collapse = "\n")
            }
           )),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$url_field_parts)) {
                paste(c("The URL field contains the following bad parts:",
                        paste0("  ", y),
                        strwrap("The URL field should be a list of URLs separated by commas or whitespace.")),
                      collapse = "\n")
            })),
      if(length(y <- x$bugreports)) y,
      fmt(c(if(length(x$GNUmake)) {
                "GNU make is a SystemRequirements."
            })),
      if(length(y <- x$date_msg)) y,
      if(length(y <- x$build_time_stamp_msg)) y,
      if(length(y <- x$placeholders)) {
          paste(c("DESCRIPTION fields with placeholder content:",
                  paste0("  ",
                         unlist(strsplit(formatDL(y,
                                                  style = "list",
                                                  indent = 2L),
                                         "\n", fixed = TRUE)))),
                collapse = "\n")
      },
      if(length(y <- x$size_of_tarball))
          paste("Size of tarball:", y, "bytes"),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$Rd_keywords_or_concepts_with_Rd_markup))
                paste(c("Found the following \\keyword or \\concept entries with Rd markup:",
                        unlist(y)),
                      collapse = "\n"),
            if(length(y <- x$Rd_keywords_or_concepts_more_than_one))
                paste(c("Found the following \\keyword or \\concept entries",
                        "which likely give several index terms:",
                        unlist(y)),
                      collapse = "\n"))),
      fmt(c(if(length(y <- x$Rd_URLs_which_should_use_doi))
                paste(c("Found the following URLs which should use \\doi (with the DOI name only):",
                        unlist(y)),
                      collapse = "\n")))
      )
}

print.check_package_CRAN_incoming <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(length(y <- format(x, ...)))
        writeLines(paste(y, collapse = "\n\n"))
    invisible(x)
}

### * .check_Rd_metadata

.check_Rd_metadata <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    ## Perform package-level Rd metadata checks:
    ## names and aliases must be unique within a package.

    ## Note that we cannot use Rd_aliases(), as this does
    ##   if(length(aliases))
    ##       sort(unique(unlist(aliases, use.names = FALSE)))

    out <- structure(list(), class = "check_Rd_metadata")

    meta <- if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        rds <- file.path(dir, "Meta", "Rd.rds")
        if(file_test("-f", rds)) { # should always exist, potentially 0-row
            readRDS(rds)
        } # else NULL
    } else {
        package <- .get_package_metadata(dir)["Package"]
        Rd_contents(Rd_db(dir = dir))
    }

    if (NROW(meta) == 0L)
        return(out)

    files <- meta$File
    names <- meta$Name
    aliases <- meta$Aliases
    doctypes <- meta$Type

    files_grouped_by_names <- split(files, names)
    files_with_duplicated_names <-
        files_grouped_by_names[lengths(files_grouped_by_names) > 1L]
    if(length(files_with_duplicated_names))
        out$files_with_duplicated_names <-
            files_with_duplicated_names

    nAliases <- lengths(aliases)
    files_grouped_by_aliases <-
        split(rep.int(files, nAliases),
              unlist(aliases, use.names = FALSE))
    files_with_duplicated_aliases <-
        files_grouped_by_aliases[lengths(files_grouped_by_aliases) > 1L]
    if(length(files_with_duplicated_aliases))
        out$files_with_duplicated_aliases <-
            files_with_duplicated_aliases

    files_without_aliases <- files[nAliases == 0L]
    if(length(files_without_aliases))
        out$files_without_aliases <- files_without_aliases

    aliases <- unlist(aliases)
    names(aliases) <- rep.int(files, nAliases) # again ...
    all_package_aliases <- aliases[endsWith(aliases, "-package")]
    the_package_alias <- sprintf("%s-package", package)
    if(the_package_alias %in% all_package_aliases) {
        ## Be nice: package names in standard repositories are unique
        ## ignoring case.
        all_package_aliases <-
            all_package_aliases[tolower(all_package_aliases) !=
                                tolower(the_package_alias)]
    }
    if(length(all_package_aliases))
        out$files_with_bad_package_aliases <-
            split(all_package_aliases, names(all_package_aliases))

    out
}

format.check_Rd_metadata <-
function(x, ...)
{
    c(character(),
      if(length(bad <- x$files_with_duplicated_name)) {
          unlist(lapply(names(bad),
                 function(nm) {
                     c(gettextf("Rd files with duplicated name '%s':",
                                nm),
                       .pretty_format(bad[[nm]]))
                 }))
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$files_with_duplicated_aliases)) {
          unlist(lapply(names(bad),
                 function(nm) {
                     c(gettextf("Rd files with duplicated alias '%s':",
                                nm),
                       .pretty_format(bad[[nm]]))
                 }))
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$files_without_aliases)) {
          c(gettext("Rd files without \\alias:"),
            .pretty_format(bad))
      },
      if(length(bad <- x$files_with_bad_package_aliases)) {
          unlist(lapply(names(bad),
                        function(nm) {
                            c(gettextf("Invalid package aliases in Rd file '%s':",
                                       nm),
                              .pretty_format(bad[[nm]]))
                        }))
      })
}

## * checkRdContents

## NOTE: this checks displayed content, not Rd_contents() metadata

checkRdContents <- # was  .check_Rd_contents <-
function(package, dir, lib.loc = NULL, chkInternal = NULL)
{
    out <- list()
    class(out) <- "checkRdContents" # was "check_Rd_contents"

 ### FIXME?  much of the following copy-pasted from checkDocFiles() above
    ## Argument handling.
    if(!missing(package)) {
        if(length(package) != 1L)
            stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")
        dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
        ## Using package installed in @code{dir} ...
    }
    else {
        if(missing(dir))
            stop("you must specify 'package' or 'dir'")
        ## Using sources from directory @code{dir} ...
        if(!dir.exists(dir))
            stop(gettextf("directory '%s' does not exist", dir),
                 domain = NA)
        else
            dir <- file_path_as_absolute(dir)
    }

    check_internal_specially <- FALSE
    ## Do
    ##   if(!isTRUE(chkInternal) && !isFALSE(chkInternal))
    ## more efficiently.
    if(is.null(chkInternal) ||
       !is.logical(chkInternal) ||
       (length(chkInternal) != 1L) ||
       is.na(chkInternal))
        chkInternal <- check_internal_specially <- TRUE

    db <- if(!missing(package))
              Rd_db(package, lib.loc = dirname(dir))
          else
              Rd_db(dir = dir)

    for(nm in names(db)) {
        rd <- db[[nm]]
        keywords <- .Rd_get_metadata(rd, "keyword")

        ## If !chkInternal, exclude internal Rd objects from further
        ## computations.  Otherwise, maybe treat them specially, and
        ## ignore: arguments with no description, missing value section.
        internal <- "internal" %in% keywords
        if(internal && !chkInternal) next
        special <- (internal && check_internal_specially)

        ## \description is mandatory except for package overviews
        type <- .Rd_get_doc_type(rd)
        tags <- RdTags(rd)
        missing_description <- (type != "package") &&
            "\\description" %notin% tags

        ## Functions without \value.
        graphics <- c("aplot", "hplot", "device", "dynamic") # ignore for now
        missing_value <- !(special || nzchar(type) ||
                           any(keywords %in% graphics)) &&
            length(rd_usage <- .Rd_get_section(rd, "usage")) &&
            "\\value" %notin% tags &&
            "\\special" %notin% RdTags(rd_usage) # PkgUtils.Rd etc.

        ## Arguments with no description.
        arguments_with_no_description <- if(special) NULL else {
            arg_table <- .Rd_get_argument_table(rd)
            arg_table[grepl("^[[:space:]]*$", arg_table[, 2L]),
                      1L]
        }

        ## Autogenerated Rd content which needs editing.
        offending_autogenerated_content <-
            .Rd_get_offending_autogenerated_content(rd)

        if(missing_description
           || missing_value
           || length(arguments_with_no_description)
           || length(offending_autogenerated_content)) {
            out[[nm]] <-
                list(missing_description = missing_description,
                     missing_value = missing_value,
                     arguments_with_no_description =
                     arguments_with_no_description,
                     offending_autogenerated_content =
                     offending_autogenerated_content)
        }
    }

    out
}

format.checkRdContents <-
function(x, ...)
{
    glimpse <- function(x, tail = FALSE) {
        x <- lines2str(x, " ")
        if ((nc <- nchar(x)) > 63L) {
            if (tail) paste0("...", substr(x, nc-59L, nc))
            else paste0(substr(x, 0, 60L), "...")
        } else x
    }
    .fmt <- function(nm) {
        y <- x[[nm]]
        c(character(),
          if(length(arguments_with_no_description <-
                    y[["arguments_with_no_description"]])) {
              c(gettextf("Argument items with no description in Rd file '%s':",
                         nm),
                .pretty_format(arguments_with_no_description))
          },
          if(length(autocontents <- y[["offending_autogenerated_content"]])) {
              c(gettextf("Auto-generated content requiring editing in Rd file '%s':",
                         nm),
                sprintf("  %s: %s", autocontents[, 1L],
                        sQuote(mapply(glimpse, autocontents[, 2L],
                                      autocontents[, 1L] == "\\details"))))
          })
    }
    .fmt_missing <- function(section) {
        files <- names(which(vapply(x, `[[`, TRUE, paste0("missing_", section))))
        if(length(files))
            c(gettextf("Rd files without %s:", paste0("\\", section)),
              .pretty_format(files))
    }
    c(character(),
      .fmt_missing("description"),
      if(config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_RD_CONTENTS_VALUE_", "FALSE")))
          .fmt_missing("value"),
      as.character(unlist(lapply(names(x), .fmt))))
}

### * .check_Rd_line_widths

.check_Rd_line_widths <-
function(dir, limit = c(usage = 95, examples = 105), installed = FALSE)
{
    db <- if(installed)
        Rd_db(basename(dir), lib.loc = dirname(dir))
    else
        Rd_db(dir = dir)
    out <- find_wide_Rd_lines_in_Rd_db(db, limit, installed)
    class(out) <- "check_Rd_line_widths"
    attr(out, "limit") <- limit
    out
}

format.check_Rd_line_widths <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(!length(x)) return(character())

    .truncate <- function(s) {
        ifelse(nchar(s) > 140L,
               paste(substr(s, 1, 140L),
                     "... [TRUNCATED]"),
               s)
    }

    limit <- attr(x, "limit")
    ## Rd2txt() by default adds a section indent of 5 also incorporated
    ## in the limits used for checking.  But users actually look at the
    ## line widths in their source Rd file, so remove the indent when
    ## formatting for reporting check results.
    ## (This should reduce confusion as long as we only check the line
    ## widths in verbatim type sections.)
    limit <- limit - 5L

    sections <- names(limit)

    .fmt <- function(nm) {
        y <- x[[nm]]
        c(sprintf("Rd file '%s':", nm),
          unlist(lapply(sections,
                        function(s) {
                            lines <- y[[s]]
                            if(!length(lines)) character() else {
                                c(sprintf("  \\%s lines wider than %d characters:",
                                          s, limit[s]),
                                  .truncate(lines))
                            }
                        }),
                 use.names = FALSE),
          "")
    }

    as.character(unlist(lapply(names(x), .fmt)))
}

find_wide_Rd_lines_in_Rd_db <-
function(x, limit = NULL, installed = FALSE)
{
    y <- lapply(x, find_wide_Rd_lines_in_Rd_object, limit, installed)
    Filter(length, y)
}

find_wide_Rd_lines_in_Rd_object <-
function(x, limit = NULL, installed = FALSE)
{
    if(is.null(limit))
        limit <- list(usage = c(79, 95), examples = c(87, 105))
    sections <- names(limit)
    if(is.null(sections))
        stop("no Rd sections specified")
    if (installed) x <- prepare_Rd(x, stages = "render")
    y <- Map(function(s, l) {
        out <- NULL
        zz <- textConnection("out", "w", local = TRUE)
        on.exit(close(zz))
        pos <- which(RdTags(x) == s)
        ## measure length in chars, not in bytes after substitutions
        Rd2txt(x[pos[1L]], out = zz, fragment = TRUE, outputEncoding = "UTF-8")
        nc <- nchar(sub("[ \t]+$", "", out))
        if(length(l) > 1L) {
            ind_warn <- (nc > max(l))
            ind_note <- (nc > min(l)) & !ind_warn
            Filter(length,
                   list(warn = out[ind_warn], note = out[ind_note]))
        } else {
            out[nc > l]
        }
    },
             paste0("\\", sections),
             limit)
    names(y) <- sections
    Filter(length, y)
}


### * .find_charset

.find_charset <-
function()
{
    l10n <- l10n_info()
    enc <- if(l10n[["UTF-8"]]) "UTF-8" else utils::localeToCharset()
    cat("charset: ", enc, "\n", sep = "")
    invisible()
}


### * Utilities

### ** as.alist.call

as.alist.call <-
function(x)
{
    y <- as.list(x)
    ind <- if(is.null(names(y)))
        seq_along(y)
    else
        which(names(y) == "")
    if(length(ind)) {
        names(y)[ind] <- vapply(y[ind], paste, "", collapse = " ")
        y[ind] <- rep.int(list(alist(irrelevant = )[[1L]]), length(ind))
    }
    y
}

### ** as.alist.symbol

as.alist.symbol <-
function(x)
{
    as.alist.call(call(as.character(x)))
}

### ** .arg_names_from_call

.arg_names_from_call <-
function(x)
{
    y <- as.character(x)
    if(!is.null(nx <- names(x))) {
        ind <- which(nzchar(nx))
        y[ind] <- nx[ind]
    }
    y
}

### ** .dquote_method_markup

## See the notes below.
## An alternative and possibly more efficient implementation could be
## based using gregexpr(re, txt), massaging the matches and merging with
## the non-matched parts.

.dquote_method_markup <-
function(txt, re)
{
    out <- ""
    while((ipos <- regexpr(re, txt)) > -1L) {
        epos <- ipos + attr(ipos, "match.length") - 1L
        str <- substring(txt, ipos, epos)
        str <- sub("\"", "\\\"", str, fixed = TRUE)
        str <- sub("\\", "\\\\", str, fixed = TRUE)
        out <- sprintf("%s%s\"%s\"", out,
                       substring(txt, 1L, ipos - 1L), str)
        txt <- substring(txt, epos + 1L)
    }
    paste0(out, txt)
}

### ** .format_calls_in_file

.format_calls_in_file <-
function(calls, f)
{
    c(gettextf("File %s:", sQuote(f)),
      paste0("  ",
             unlist(lapply(calls,
                           function(e)
                           paste(deparse(e), collapse = "\n")))))
}

### ** .functions_to_be_ignored_from_usage

.functions_to_be_ignored_from_usage <-
function(package_name)
{
    c("<-", "=",
      if(package_name == "base")
      c("(", "{", "function", "if", "for", "while", "repeat",
        "Math", "Ops", "Summary", "Complex", "matrixOps"),
      if(package_name == "utils") "?",
      if(package_name == "methods") "@")
}

### ** get_S4_generics_with_methods

## FIXME: make option of methods::getGenerics()
## JMC agreed & proposed argument  'excludeEmpty = FALSE'
get_S4_generics_with_methods <-
function(env, verbose = getOption("verbose"))
{
    env <- as.environment(env)
    ##  Filter(function(g) methods::isGeneric(g, where = env),
    ##         methods::getGenerics(env))
    r <- methods::getGenerics(env)
    if(length(r) && {
        hasM <- lapply(r, function(g)
                       tryCatch(methods::hasMethods(g, where = env),
                                error = identity))
        if(any(hasErr <- vapply(hasM, inherits, NA, what = "error"))) {
            dq <- function(ch) paste0('"', ch ,'"')
            rErr <- r[hasErr]
            pkgs <- r@package[hasErr]
            ## FIXME: This warning should not happen here when called
            ## from R CMD check, but rather be part of a new "check"
            ## there !
            warning(gettextf("Generics 'g' in 'env' %s where '%s' errors: %s\nMay need something like\n\n%s\nin NAMESPACE.",
                             format(env),
                             "hasMethods(g, env)",
                             paste(sQuote(rErr), collapse = ", "),
                             paste0("  importFrom(",
                                    paste(dq(pkgs), dq(rErr), sep =", "),
                                    ")\n")
                             ),
                    domain = NA)
            hasM <- hasM[!hasErr]
        }
        !all(ok <- unlist(hasM))
    }) {
        if(verbose)
            message(sprintf(ngettext(sum(!ok),
                                     "Generic without any methods in %s: %s",
                                     "Generics without any methods in %s: %s"),
                            format(env),
                            paste(sQuote(r[!ok]), collapse = ", ")),
                    domain = NA)
        r[ok]
    }
    else as.vector(r)# for back-compatibility and current ..../tests/reg-S4.R
}

### ** .get_S4_generics

## For several QC tasks, we need to compute on "all S4 methods in/from a
## package".  These days, this can straightforwardly be accomplished by
## looking at all methods tables in the package environment or namespace.
## Somewhat historically, we organize our computations by first using
## using methods::getGenerics() to find all S4 generics the package has
## methods for, and then iterating over these.  To make this work
## conveniently, we wrap around methods::getGenerics() to rewrite its
## "ObjectsWithPackage" result into a (currently unclassed) list of
## generic-name-with-package-name-attribute objects, and wrap around
## methods::findMethods() to perform lookup based on this information
## (rather than the genericFunction object itself), and also rewrite the
## MethodsList result into a simple list.

.get_S4_generics <-
function(env)
{
    env <- as.environment(env)
    g <- suppressMessages(methods::getGenerics(env))
    y <- Map(function(f, p) {
                 attr(f, "package") <- p
                 f
             },
             g@.Data,
             g@package)
    names(y) <- g@.Data
    y
}

### ** .get_S4_methods_list

.get_S4_methods_list <-
function(f, env)
{
    ## Get S4 methods in environment env for f a structure with the name
    ## of the S4 generic and its package in the corresponding attribute.

    ## For the QC computations, we really only want the S4 methods
    ## defined in a package, so we try to exclude derived default
    ## methods as well as methods inherited from other environments.

    env <- as.environment(env)

    ## <FIXME>
    ## Use methods::findMethods() once this gets a package argument.
    ## This will return a listOfMethods object: turn this into a simple
    ## list of methods named by hash-collapsed signatures.
    tab <- get(methods:::.TableMetaName(f, attr(f, "package")), envir = env)
    mlist <- as.list(tab, all.names = TRUE, sorted = TRUE)
    ## </FIXME>

    ## First, derived default methods (signature w/ "ANY").
    if(any(ind <- vapply(mlist, methods::is, NA, "derivedDefaultMethod")))
        mlist <- mlist[!ind]

    if(length(mlist)) {
        ## Determining the methods defined in a package from the package
        ## env or the associated namespace seems rather tricky.  What we
        ## seem to observe is the following.
        ## * If there is a namespace N, methods defined in the package
        ##   have N as their environment, for both the package env and
        ##   the associated namespace.
        ## * If there is no namespace, methods defined in the package
        ##   have an environment E which is empty and has globalenv() as
        ##   its parent.  (If the package defines generics, these seem
        ##   to have E as their parent env.)
        ## However, in the latter case, there seems no way to infer E
        ## from the package env.  In the old days predating methods
        ## tables, we compared methods in the package env with those in
        ## its parent env, and excluded the ones already found there.
        ## This no longer works, so we exclude "at least" all methods
        ## with a namespace environment (as these cannot come from a
        ## package with no namespace).

        namespace <- if(isNamespace(env)) env else .get_namespace_from_package_env(env)
        mlist <- if(!is.null(namespace))
            Filter(function(m) identical(environment(m), namespace), mlist)
        else
            Filter(function(m) environmentName(environment(m)) == "", mlist)
    }

    mlist
}

.get_ref_classes <-
function(env)
{
    env <- as.environment(env)
    cl <- methods::getClasses(env)
    cl <- cl[vapply(cl,
                    function(Class)
                        methods::is(methods::getClass(Class, where = env),
                                    "refClassRepresentation"),
                    NA)]
    if(length(cl)) {
        res <- lapply(cl, function(Class) {
            def <- methods::getClass(Class, where = env)
            ff <- def@fieldPrototypes
            accs <- vapply(ff,
                           function(what)
                               methods::is(what, "activeBindingFunction") &&
                               !methods::is(what, "defaultBindingFunction"),
                           NA)
            c(as.list(def@refMethods), as.list(ff)[accs])
        })
        names(res) <- cl
        res
    } else list()
}

.get_namespace_from_package_env <-
function(env)
{
    package <-
        sub(".*:([^_]*).*", "\\1", attr(env, "name", exact = TRUE))
    if(length(package) && nzchar(package)) .getNamespace(as.name(package))
}


### ** .is_call_from_replacement_function_usage

.is_call_from_replacement_function_usage <-
function(x)
{
    ((length(x) == 3L)
     && identical(x[[1L]], quote(`<-`))
     && (length(  x[[2L]]) > 1L)
     && is.symbol(x[[3L]]))
}

### ** .make_siglist

.make_siglist <-
function(x)
{
    ## Argument 'x' should be a named list of methods as obtained by
    ## methods::findMethods() or .get_S4_methods_list().
    gsub("#", ",", names(x), fixed = TRUE)
}

### ** .make_signatures

.make_signatures <-
function(cls)
{
    ## Note that (thanks JMC), when comparing signatures, the signature
    ## has to be stripped of trailing "ANY" elements (which are always
    ## implicit) or padded to a fixed length.
    sub("(#ANY)*$", "", unlist(lapply(cls, paste, collapse = "#")))
}

### ** .massage_file_parse_error_message
.massage_file_parse_error_message <-
function(x)
    sub("^[^:]+:[[:space:]]*", "", x)

## get rid of "file/name" where file/name maybe "<text>"
## new *classed* parseError messages look like
##    "function '(' not supported in RHS call of a pipe (filename:1:8)"
.massage_file_parse_error <- function(e) { # 'e' : the error itself
    msg <- conditionMessage(e)
    if(inherits(e, "parseError"))
        ## get rid of 'file name:'
        sub("\\([^:]+:(.*)\\)", "(\\1)", msg)
    else ## old version: == .massage_file_parse_error_message(msg)
        sub("^[^:]+:[[:space:]]*", "", msg)
}


### ** .package_env

.package_env <-
function(package_name)
{
    as.environment(paste0("package:", package_name))
}

### ** .parse_text_as_much_as_possible

.parse_text_as_much_as_possible <-
function(txt)
{
    fun <- function(txt) {
        if(!l10n_info()$MBCS && identical(Encoding(txt), "UTF-8"))
            parse(text = txt, encoding = "UTF-8")
        else
            str2expression(txt)
    }
    exprs <- tryCatch(fun(txt), error = identity)
    if(!inherits(exprs, "error")) return(exprs)
    exprs <- expression()
    lines <- unlist(strsplit(txt, "\n"))
    bad_lines <- character()
    while((n <- length(lines))) {
        i <- 1L; txt <- lines[1L]
        while(inherits(yy <- tryCatch(fun(txt), error = identity),
                       "error")
              && (i < n)) {
            i <- i + 1L; txt <- paste(txt, lines[i], collapse = "\n")
        }
        if(inherits(yy, "error")) {
            bad_lines <- c(bad_lines, lines[1L])
            lines <- lines[-1L]
        }
        else {
            exprs <- c(exprs, yy)
            lines <- lines[-seq_len(i)]
        }
    }
    attr(exprs, "bad_lines") <- bad_lines
    exprs
}

### ** .parse_usage_as_much_as_possible

.parse_usage_as_much_as_possible <-
function(x)
{
    if(!length(x)) return(expression())
    ## Drop specials and comments.
    ## Note that when used from the QC functions, building the Rd db
    ## already dropped all parts that are not rendered, including
    ## comments.
    x <- .Rd_drop_nodes_with_tags(x, c("COMMENT", "\\special"))
    ## Transform \dots and \ldots to '...'.
    ## For many years we did
    ##   txt <- .Rd_deparse(x, tag = FALSE)
    ##   txt <- gsub("\\\\l?dots", "...", txt)
    ## but as <https://bugs.r-project.org/show_bug.cgi?id=18574>
    ## reports, this also incorrectly transforms dots markup in value
    ## strings.  So we really need to transform while we have the Rd
    ## structure available.  This could use something like
    ##   f <- function(e) {
    ##     switch(attr(e, "Rd_tag"),
    ##            "\\special" =,
    ##            "COMMENT" = NULL,
    ##            "\\ldots" =,
    ##            "\\dots" = structure("...", Rd_tag = "TEXT"),
    ##            e)
    ## }
    ## (including dropping specials and comments, and actually things
    ## inside \usage are RCODE and not TEXT).
    ## For now, we use as.character.Rd() on the Rd which should allow to
    ## identify the macros as literals.
    attr(x, "Rd_tag") <- "Rd"
    txt <- as.character.Rd(x)
    txt[txt %in% c("\\dots", "\\ldots")] <- "..."
    txt <- paste(txt, collapse = "")
    ## Ideally we would also make the subsequent S3/S4 method markup
    ## transformations before collapsing ...
    txt <- .dquote_method_markup(txt, .S3_method_markup_regexp)
    txt <- .dquote_method_markup(txt, .S4_method_markup_regexp)
    ## \usage is only 'verbatim-like'
    ## now any valid escape by \ is
    ##   \a \b \f \n \r \t \u \U \v \x \' \" \\ or \octal
    txt <- gsub("(^|[^\\])\\\\($|[^abfnrtuUvx0-9'\"\\])",
                "\\1<unescaped bksl>\\2", txt)
    ## and since this may overlap, try again
    txt <- gsub("(^|[^\\])\\\\($|[^abfnrtuUvx0-9'\"\\])",
                "\\1<unescaped bksl>\\2", txt)
    .parse_text_as_much_as_possible(txt)
}

### ** .pretty_format

.strwrap22 <- function(x, collapse = " ")
    strwrap(paste(x, collapse=collapse), indent = 2L, exdent = 2L)

.pretty_format <-
function(x, collapse = " ", q = getOption("useFancyQuotes"))
    .strwrap22(sQuote(x, q=q), collapse=collapse)

.pretty_format2 <-
function(msg, x, collapse = ", ", useFancyQuotes = FALSE)
{
    xx <- strwrap(paste(sQuote(x, q=useFancyQuotes), collapse=collapse), exdent = 2L)
    if (length(xx) > 1L || nchar(msg) + nchar(xx) + 1L > 75L)
        ## trash 'xx', instead wrap w/ 'indent' :
        c(msg, .pretty_format(x, collapse=collapse, q=useFancyQuotes))
    else paste(msg, xx)
}

### ** .pretty_print

.pretty_print <-
function(x, collapse = " ")
    writeLines(.strwrap22(x, collapse=collapse))


### ** .strip_backticks

.strip_backticks <-
function(x)
    gsub("`", "", x, fixed=TRUE)

### ** .transform_S3_method_markup

.transform_S3_method_markup <-
function(x)
{
    ## Note how we deal with S3 replacement methods found.
    ## These come out named "\method{GENERIC}{CLASS}<-" which we
    ## need to turn into 'GENERIC<-.CLASS'.
    re <- sprintf("%s(<-)?", .S3_method_markup_regexp)
    ## Note that this is really only called on "function" names obtained
    ## by parsing the \usage texts, so that the method regexps possibly
    ## augmented by '<-' fully match if they match.
    ## We should be able to safely strip all backticks; alternatively,
    ## we could do something like
    ##   cl <- .strip_backticks(sub(re, "\\4", x))
    ##   sub(re, sprintf("\\3\\5.%s", cl), x)
    .strip_backticks(sub(re, "\\3\\5.\\4", x))
}

### ** .transform_S4_method_markup

.transform_S4_method_markup <-
function(x)
{
    re <- sprintf("%s(<-)?", .S4_method_markup_regexp)
    ## We should be able to safely strip all backticks; alternatively,
    ## we could do something like
    ##   sl <- .strip_backticks(sub(re, "\\3", x))
    ##   sub(re, sprintf("\\\\S4method{\\2\\7}{%s}", sl), x)
    .strip_backticks(sub(re, "\\\\S4method{\\2\\7}{\\3}", x))
}

### ** .S3_method_markup_regexp

## For matching \(S3)?method{GENERIC}{CLASS}.
## GENERIC can be
## * a syntactically valid name
## * one of $ [ [[ @
## * one of the binary operators
##   + - * / ^ < <= > >= != == | & %something%
## * unary !
## (as supported by Rdconv).
## CLASS can be a syntactic name (we could be more precise about the
## fact that these must start with a letter or '.'), or anything quoted
## by backticks (not containing backticks itself for now).  Arguably,
## non-syntactic class names should best be avoided, but R has always
## had them at least for
## R> class(bquote({.}))
## [1] "{"
## R> class(bquote((.)))
## [1] "("

## <NOTE>
## Handling S3/S4 method markup is somewhat tricky.
## When using R to parse the usage entries, we turn the
##   \METHOD{GENERIC}{CLASS_OR_SIGLIST}(args)
## markup into (something which parses to) a function call by suitably
## quoting the \METHOD{GENERIC}{CLASS_OR_SIGLIST} part.  In case of a
## replacement method
##   \METHOD{GENERIC}{CLASS_OR_SIGLIST}(args) <- value
## parsing results in a
##   \METHOD{GENERIC}{CLASS_OR_SIGLIST}<-
## pseudo name, which need to be transformed to
##   \METHOD{GENERIC<-}{CLASS_OR_SIGLIST}
## We currently use double quoting for the parse step.  As we also allow
## for non-syntactic class names quoted by backticks, this means that
## double quotes and backslashes need to be escaped.  Alternatively, we
## could strip backticks right away and quote by backticks, but then the
## replacement method transformation would need different regexps.
## </NOTE>

.S3_method_markup_regexp <-
    sprintf("(\\\\(S3)?method\\{(%s)\\}\\{(%s)\\})",
            paste(c("[._[:alnum:]]*",
                    ## Subscripting
                    "\\$", "\\[\\[?", "\\@",
                    ## Binary operators and unary '!'.
                    "\\+", "\\-", "\\*", "\\/", "\\^",
                    "<=?", ">=?", "!=?", "==", "\\&", "\\|",
                    "\\%[[:alnum:][:punct:]]*\\%"),
                  collapse = "|"),
            "[._[:alnum:]]+|`[^`]+`")

### ** .S4_method_markup_regexp

## For matching \S4method{GENERIC}{SIGLIST}.
## SIGLIST can be a comma separated list of CLASS specs as above.

.S4_method_markup_regexp <-
    sprintf("(\\\\S4method\\{(%s)\\}\\{(%s)\\})",
            paste(c("[._[:alnum:]]*",
                    ## Subscripting
                    "\\$", "\\[\\[?",
                    ## Binary operators and unary '!'.
                    "\\+", "\\-", "\\*", "\\/", "\\^",
                    "<=?", ">=?", "!=?", "==", "\\&", "\\|",
                    "\\%[[:alnum:][:punct:]]*\\%"),
                  collapse = "|"),
            "(([._[:alnum:]]+|`[^`]+`),)*([._[:alnum:]]+|`[^`]+`)")

### ** .valid_maintainer_field_regexp

.make_RFC_2822_email_address_regexp <-
function()
{
    ## Local part consists of ASCII letters and digits, the characters
    ##   ! # $ % * / ? | ^ { } ` ~ & ' + = _ -
    ## and . provided it is not leading or trailing or repeated, or must
    ## be a quoted string.
    ## Domain part consists of dot-separated elements consisting of
    ## ASCII letters, digits and hyphen.
    ## We could also check that the local and domain parts are no longer
    ## than 64 and 255 characters, respectively.
    ## See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Email_address.
    ASCII_letters_and_digits <-
        "ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZabcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz0123456789"
    l <- sprintf("[%s%s]", ASCII_letters_and_digits, "!#$%*/?|^{}`~&'+=_-")
    d <- sprintf("[%s%s]", ASCII_letters_and_digits, "-")
    ## Be careful to arrange the hyphens to come last in the range spec.
    sprintf("(\\\".+\\\"|(%s+\\.)*%s+)@(%s+\\.)*%s+", l, l, d, d)
}

.valid_maintainer_field_regexp <-
    sprintf("^[[:space:]]*(.*<%s>|ORPHANED)[[:space:]]*$",
            .make_RFC_2822_email_address_regexp())

### ** .Rd_get_offending_autogenerated_content

.Rd_get_offending_autogenerated_content <-
function(x)
{
    out <- NULL

    ## prompt[Data]():
    s <- .Rd_get_section(x, "title")
    if(length(s)) {
        s <- .Rd_deparse(s, tag = FALSE)
        ## FIXME: some start with "~~ ", see FIXME in methods::promptMethods
        if(startsWith(trimws(s), "A Capitalized Title"))
            out <- rbind(out, c("\\title", s))
    }
    ## catch dummy texts generated by R < 2.9.0 (still some on internal pages)
    s <- .Rd_get_section(x, "details")
    if(length(s)) {
        s <- .Rd_deparse(.Rd_drop_comments(s), tag = FALSE)
        if(grepl("If necessary, more details than the description above",
                 s, fixed = TRUE))
            out <- rbind(out, c("\\details", s))
    }
    tab <- .Rd_get_argument_table(x)
    if(length(tab)) {
        descs <- trimws(tab[, 2L])
        ind <- descs == sprintf("~~Describe \\code{%s} here~~", tab[, 1L])
        if(any(ind))
            out <- rbind(out,
                         cbind(sprintf("\\arguments: %s", tab[ind, 1L]),
                               tab[ind, 2L]))
    }

    ## promptPackage(): (catch some dummy texts generated by R < 4.4.0)
    s <- .Rd_get_section(x, "details")
    if(length(s) && length(s) <= 11 &&
       any(grepl("~~ An overview of how to use the package",
                 unlist(s[RdTags(s) == "TEXT"]), fixed = TRUE)))
        out <- rbind(out, c("\\details", .Rd_deparse(s, tag = FALSE)))
    ## the following three also match Rcpp's manual-page-stub.Rd skeleton
    s <- .Rd_get_section(x, "references")
    if(length(s)) {
        s <- .Rd_deparse(.Rd_drop_comments(s), tag = FALSE)
        if(grepl("[Ll]iterature or other references for background information",
                 gsub("[[:space:]]+", " ", s)))
            out <- rbind(out, c("\\references", s))
    }
    s <- .Rd_get_section(x, "seealso")
    if(length(s) && length(s) <= 5) {
        s <- .Rd_deparse(.Rd_drop_comments(s), tag = FALSE)
        if(grepl("Optional links to other man pages",
                 s, fixed = TRUE))
            out <- rbind(out, c("\\seealso", s))
    }
    s <- .Rd_get_section(x, "examples")
    if(length(s)) {
        s <- .Rd_deparse(.Rd_drop_comments(s), tag = FALSE)
        if(grepl("Optional simple examples of the most important functions",
                 s, fixed = TRUE))
            out <- rbind(out, c("\\examples", s))
    }

    ## promptMethods():
    ## <FIXME>
    ## r50996 changed to produce commented descriptions, so this is obsolete
    tab <- .Rd_get_methods_description_table(x)
    if(length(tab)) {
        descriptions <- trimws(tab[, 2L])
        ## /data/rsync/PKGS/coin/man/initialize-methods.Rd
        ind <- descriptions == "~~describe this method here"
        if(any(ind))
            out <- rbind(out,
                         cbind(sprintf("section 'Methods', description of item '%s'",
                                       tab[ind, 1L]),
                               tab[ind, 2L]))
    }
    ## </FIXME>

    if(config_val_to_logical(Sys.getenv("_R_CHECK_RD_CONTENTS_KEYWORDS_",
                                        "FALSE"))) {
        k <- .Rd_get_metadata(x, "keyword")
        k <- k[k %in% .Rd_keywords_auto]
        if(length(k)) {
            out <- rbind(out,
                         cbind("\\keyword", k))
        }
    }

    out
}


### ** .check_pragmas

.check_pragmas <-
function(dir)
{
    ## Check a source package for disallowed pragmas in src and inst/include
    ## Try (not very hard) to avoid ones which are commented out (RcppParallel)
    ## One could argue for recording all uses of #pragma ... diagnostic
    ## There are also
    ##   #pragma warning (disable:4996)
    ##   #pragma warning(push, 0)
    ## which seem intended for MSVC++ and hence not relevant here.
    found <- warn <- port <- character()
    od <- setwd(dir); on.exit(setwd(od))
    ff <- dir(c('src', 'inst/include'),
              pattern = "[.](c|cc|cpp|h|hh|hpp)$",
              full.names = TRUE, recursive = TRUE)
    pat <- "^\\s*#pragma (GCC|clang) diagnostic ignored"
    ## -Wmissing-field-initializers looks important but is not part of -Wall
    pat2 <- "^\\s*#pragma (GCC|clang) diagnostic ignored[^-]*[-]W(uninitialized|float-equal|array-bound|format)"
    ## gcc8 -W warnings not accepted by clang 7
    ## found by listing with gcc -Q --help=warning and testing with clang.
     nonport <-
         c("abi-tag", "aggressive-loop-optimizations", "aliasing",
           "align-commons", "aligned-new", "alloc-size-larger-than",
           "alloc-zero", "alloca", "alloca-larger-than", "ampersand",
           "argument-mismatch", "array-temporaries",
           "assign-intercept", "attribute-alias", "bool-compare",
           "bool-operation", "builtin-declaration-mismatch",
           "c-binding-type", "c90-c99-compat", "c99-c11-compat",
           "cast-function-type", "catch-value",
           "character-truncation", "chkp", "class-memaccess",
           "clobbered", "compare-reals", "conditionally-supported",
           "conversion-extra", "coverage-mismatch", "designated-init",
           "discarded-array-qualifiers", "discarded-qualifiers",
           "do-subscript", "duplicated-branches", "duplicated-cond",
           "format-contains-nul", "format-overflow",
           "format-signedness", "format-truncation", "frame-address",
           "frame-larger-than", "free-nonheap-object",
           "function-elimination", "hsa", "if-not-aligned",
           "implicit-interface", "implicit-procedure",
           "inherited-variadic-ctor", "int-in-bool-context",
           "integer-division", "intrinsic-shadow", "intrinsics-std",
           "invalid-memory-model", "jump-misses-init", "larger-than",
           "line-truncation", "literal-suffix", "logical-op",
           "lto-type-mismatch", "maybe-uninitialized",
           "memset-elt-size", "misleading-indentation",
           "missing-attributes", "missing-parameter-type",
           "multiple-inheritance", "multistatement-macros",
           "namespaces", "noexcept", "non-template-friend",
           "nonnull-compare", "normalized", "old-style-declaration",
           "openmp-simd", "override-init",
           "override-init-side-effects", "packed-bitfield-compat",
           "packed-not-aligned", "placement-new", "pmf-conversions",
           "pointer-compare", "property-assign-default", "psabi",
           "real-q-constant", "realloc-lhs", "realloc-lhs-all",
           "restrict", "return-local-addr", "scalar-storage-order",
           "shadow-compatible-local", "shadow-local",
           "sized-deallocation", "sizeof-pointer-div", "stack-usage",
           "strict-null-sentinel", "stringop-overflow",
           "stringop-truncation", "subobject-linkage",
           "suggest-attribute", "suggest-final-methods",
           "suggest-final-types", "suggest-override", "surprising",
           "switch-unreachable", "sync-nand", "tabs",
           "target-lifetime", "templates", "terminate", "traditional",
           "traditional-conversion", "trampolines",
           "undefined-do-loop", "underflow",
           "unsafe-loop-optimizations", "unsuffixed-float-constants",
           "unused-but-set-parameter", "unused-but-set-variable",
           "unused-dummy-argument", "use-without-only",
           "useless-cast", "vector-operation-performance",
           "virtual-inheritance", "virtual-move-assign",
           "vla-larger-than", "zerotrip")
    pat3 <- paste0("^\\s*#pragma (GCC|clang) diagnostic[^-]*[-]W(",
                   paste(nonport, collapse="|"), ")")
    for(f in ff) {
        if(any(grepl(pat, readLines(f, warn = FALSE),
                     perl = TRUE, useBytes = TRUE)))
            found <- c(found, f)
        else next
        if(any(grepl(pat2, readLines(f, warn = FALSE),
                     perl = TRUE, useBytes = TRUE)))
            warn <- c(warn, f)
        if(any(grepl(pat3, readLines(f, warn = FALSE),
                     perl = TRUE, useBytes = TRUE)))
            port <- c(port, f)
    }
    structure(found, class = "check_pragmas", warn = warn, port = port)
}

print.check_pragmas <-
function(x, ...)
{
    if(length(x)) {
        if(length(x) == 1L)
            writeLines("File which contain pragma(s) suppressing diagnostics:")
        else
            writeLines("Files which contain pragma(s) suppressing diagnostics:")
        .pretty_print(x)
    }
    x
}

### ** .check_S3_methods_needing_delayed_registration

.check_S3_methods_needing_delayed_registration <-
function(package, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    mat <- matrix(character(), 0L, 3L,
                  dimnames = list(NULL,
                                  c("Package", "Generic", "Method")))
    out <- list(mat = mat, bad = character())
    class(out) <- "check_S3_methods_needing_delayed_registration"

    if(length(package) != 1L)
        stop("argument 'package' must be of length 1")

    if(package == "base") return()

    dir <- find.package(package, lib.loc)
    if(!dir.exists(file.path(dir, "R"))) return()

    db <- .read_description(file.path(dir, "DESCRIPTION"))
    suggests <- unname(.get_requires_from_package_db(db, "Suggests"))
    if(!length(suggests)) return()

    reg <- parseNamespaceFile(package, dirname(dir))$S3methods
    reg <- reg[!is.na(reg[, 4L]), , drop = FALSE]
    if(length(reg))
        out$reg <- cbind(Package = reg[, 4L],
                         Generic = reg[, 1L],
                         Class = reg[, 2L],
                         Method = reg[, 3L])

    .load_namespace_quietly(package, dirname(dir))
    code_env <- asNamespace(package)

    ok <- vapply(suggests, requireNamespace, quietly = TRUE,
                 FUN.VALUE = NA)
    out$bad <- suggests[!ok]

    suggests <- suggests[ok]
    generics <- lapply(suggests, .get_S3_generics_in_ns_exports)

    packages <- rep.int(suggests, lengths(generics))
    generics <- unlist(generics, use.names = FALSE)

    objects_in_code <- sort(names(code_env))
    functions_in_code <-
        Filter(function(f) is.function(code_env[[f]]),
               objects_in_code)

    ## Look only at the *additional* generics in suggests.
    ind <- (generics %notin%
            c(Filter(function(f) .is_S3_generic(f, code_env),
                     functions_in_code),
              .get_S3_generics_in_env(parent.env(code_env)),
              .get_S3_generics_in_base()))
    if(!all(ind)) {
        generics <- generics[ind]
        packages <- packages[ind]
    }

    methods_stop_list <- nonS3methods(basename(dir))
    methods <- lapply(generics,
                      function(g) {
                          i <- startsWith(functions_in_code,
                                          paste0(g, "."))
                          setdiff(functions_in_code[i],
                                  methods_stop_list)
                      })
    len <- lengths(methods)
    ind <- (len > 0L)

    if(!any(ind)) return(out)

    len <- len[ind]
    out$mat <-
        cbind(Package = rep.int(packages[ind], len),
              Generic = rep.int(generics[ind], len),
              Method = unlist(methods[ind], use.names = FALSE))
    out
}

format.check_S3_methods_needing_delayed_registration <-
function(x, ...)
{
    c(character(),
      if(length(bad <- x$bad)) {
          c("Suggested packages not available for checking:",
            strwrap(paste(bad, collapse = " "), indent = 2L))
      },
      if(length(mat <- x$mat)) {
          c("Apparent S3 methods needing delayed registration:",
            sprintf("  %s %s %s",
                    format(c("Package", mat[, 1L])),
                    format(c("Generic", mat[, 2L])),
                    format(c("Method", mat[, 3L])))
            )
      },
      if(length(reg <- x$reg)) {
          c("S3 methods using delayed registration:",
            sprintf("  %s %s %s %s",
                    format(c("Package", reg[, 1L])),
                    format(c("Generic", reg[, 2L])),
                    format(c("Class", reg[, 3L])),
                    format(c("Method", reg[, 4L])))
            )
      })
}

.get_S3_generics_in_ns_exports <-
function(ns)
{
    env <- asNamespace(ns)
    nms <- sort(intersect(names(env), getNamespaceExports(env)))
    .get_S3_generics_in_env(env, nms)
}

### ** .check_package_datalist

.check_package_datalist <-
function(package, lib.loc = NULL)
{
    out <- list()
    ans1 <- list_data_in_pkg(package, lib.loc)
    ans2 <- list_data_in_pkg(package, lib.loc, use_datalist = FALSE)
    ## Canonicalize.
    ans1 <- lapply(ans1, sort)
    ans1 <- ans1[order(names(ans1))]
    ans2 <- lapply(ans2, sort)
    ans2 <- ans2[order(names(ans2))]
    if(!identical(ans1, ans2)) {
        nx1 <- names(ans1)
        nx2 <- names(ans2)
        ex1 <- unlist(ans1)
        ex2 <- unlist(ans2)
        out <- Filter(length,
                      list(n12 = setdiff(nx1, nx2),
                           n21 = setdiff(nx2, nx1),
                           e12 = setdiff(ex1, ex2),
                           e21 = setdiff(ex2, ex1)))
    }
    class(out) <- "check_package_datalist"
    out
}

format.check_package_datalist <-
function(x, ...)
{
    fmt <- function(s) .strwrap22(s, " ")
    c(character(),
      if(length(y <- x$n12))
          c("Data files in 'datalist' not in 'data' directory:",
            fmt(y)),
      if(length(y <- x$n21))
          c("Data files in 'data' directory not in 'datalist':",
            fmt(y)),
      if(length(y <- x$e12))
          c("Data objects in 'datalist' not in 'data' directory:",
            fmt(y)),
      if(length(y <- x$e21))
          c("Data objects in 'data' directory not in 'datalist':",
            fmt(y)))
}

### ** .bad_DESCRIPTION_URL_field_parts

.bad_DESCRIPTION_URL_field_parts <-
function(s)
{
    if(is.na(s)) return(character())
    y <- .get_urls_from_DESCRIPTION_URL_field(s)
    z <- strsplit(s,
                  "[[:space:]]*(\\([^)]*\\))?([,[:space:]]+|$)")[[1L]]
    if(length(y) == length(z))
        character()
    else {
        z <- z %w/o% y
        z[!grepl("^<?(svn://|doi:)", z)]
    }
}


### Local variables: ***
### mode: outline-minor ***
### outline-regexp: "### [*]+" ***
### End: ***
